4 ms·
What the majority of the people here are saying is that Apple margins are artificial and built on having an unescapable walled garden You mean the same 30% mar
by scarface74 6y ago
What the majority of the people here are saying is that Apple margins are artificial and built on having an unescapable walled garden
You mean the same 30% margin that Google, Sony, Microsoft (Xbox), Nintendo, Spotify, etc. charge?
Apple bluetooth profile has been for years not compatible with device to device transfer (I don knwow about the newer models)
People still use slow BT transfers? Why? This isn’t 2004. There are much better ways to transfer files.
Apple messaging platforms can't be made interoperable with Android because Apple does not want to
Sure it is. SMS.
it costs more to buy NY Times subscription from the iOS app - to cover the Apple cut on it
It cost more to buy a soda from the convenience store than the grocery store. I couldn’t advertise at Best Buy that you can buy the same product cheaper at Amazon.
- romanoderoma 6y ago> You mean the same 30% margin that Google, Sony, Microsoft (Xbox), Nintendo, Spotify, etc. charge? You mean the same argument that Apple fanboys have been repeating over and over, except that I can side load apps on Android and consoles are hardly needed (smartphones are)? BTW I can buy new and used games at GameStop Does an AppleStop exist? Can I buy used apps on the aftermarket? I can sell the same song on Spotify, Bandcamp, on my website directly and also have a patreon. Can I do the same with an app for iPhone? Spotify is also different because they mostly sell copyrighted material owned by a copyright holder which usually is not the author. It's more like Apple music, which I don't have a problem with since there are alternatives and I can watch the content on other devices (the apps are available on the play store, for example) and Apple is making deals with labels, the same labels that sell to Spotify or YouTube But to be completely honest, it would be great if MS, Sony, Spotify etc etc were forced to open up their platforms because they are found using unfair competition tactics. But Apple IMO is the worst offender of the lot. > Sure it is. SMS. It isn't though... My plan doesn't include SMS I have unlimited data, unlimited phone calls, but no SMS So, again, Apple is reducing user experience to lock users in. also: SMS travel in clear text So much for security... > It cost more to buy a soda from the convenience store than the grocery store. Because there is a grocery store available Where is the Apple grocery store? > I couldn’t advertise at Best Buy that you can buy the same product cheaper at Amazon. That's because best buy and Amazon are competitors And competition is good Apple, on the other hand, don't like competitors, Apple loves a monopoly, and doesn't let you advertise your own website So it's like you put your product at best buy and best buy put it out like it was a best buy product Would you like it? Of course you wouldn't, you would retire it immediately and sell it on the many other channels available, because there isn't only best buy. But when it's about Apple you are ok with it. I guess that's what happen when people suffer from Stockholm syndrome But I prefer to think that it's just Apple forcing people to defend their abusive behaviour online It makes me feel less sad for those who really believe Apple is the good guy
- scarface74 6y agoMy plan doesn't include SMS I have unlimited data, unlimited phone calls, but no SMS So it’s Apple’s fault that your plan doesn’t have SMS? Where is the Apple grocery store? It’s called Android, their are literally dozens of other phones out their from $50-$2000 in every shape and form you can imagine. I wouldn’t complain because I couldn’t get pizza in a Chinese restaurant. I would go to a Pizza shop. That's because best buy and Amazon are competitors And competition is good Apple, on the other hand, don't like competitors, Apple loves a monopoly, and doesn't let you advertise your own website You are just as free to say that you can get a cheaper subscription on your one website as you can say you can buy a TV cheaper somewhere else - just not in a competitors store. Apple, on the other hand, don't like competitors, Apple loves a monopoly, and doesn't let you advertise your own website Apple has plenty of competition. I go into a cell phone store, I see dozens of phones besides iPhones. Just like when I go into GameStop I see three incompatible consoles. Of course you wouldn't, you would retire it immediately and sell it on the many other channels available, because there isn't only best buy. But when it's about Apple you are ok with it. I don’t complain on the internet about Android or Windows. I choose the alternative. I didn’t need the government for that. Free will is great isn’t it. I also didn’t complain back in the day that Nintendo only allowed certain types of games - I bought an alternate console. Even when people were complaining that Microsoft was a monopoly. I had an MS free house. I guess that's what happen when people suffer from Stockholm syndrome What do you say about people that constantly complain about products that they don’t own? If Apple is stifling competition, where all of the profitable, successful Android only apps?
- romanoderoma 6y ago> So it’s Apple’s fault that your plan doesn’t have SMS? It's Apple fault to not make an iMessage app for Android though My friends with iPhones don't even know that when they are messaging with me I receive an SMS, because Apple never made it clear that iMessage is Apple only SMS by the way is not a chat protocol, it's an alerting protocol So Apple is using it wrong > It’s called Android, their are literally dozens of other phones out their from $50-$2000 in every shape and form you can imagine. Android is not Apple competitor. Android is iOS competitor and prior was Windows Mobile or Blackberry competitor. In fact you can install a different OS on Android phones, you can't on Apple phones and that's the point, if it's a closed platform, it's a closed market, different from other markets and Apple is a monopolist in it. You are conflating you arguments with meaningless comparisons. > I wouldn’t complain because I couldn’t get pizza in a Chinese restaurant. I would go to a Pizza shop. You would if the chinese store forced you to buy pizza from them because you have chinese pottery at home I don't know why is it so hard to understand that these arguments are childish at best > You are just as free to say that you can get a cheaper subscription on your one website as you can say you can buy a TV cheaper somewhere else - just not in a competitors store. No, you are not on Apple store. From their developers' guidelines Chapter 3, paragraph 3.1 > Apps may not use their own mechanisms to unlock content or functionality, such as license keys, augmented reality markers, QR codes, etc. Apps and their metadata may not include buttons, external links, or other calls to action that direct customers to purchasing mechanisms other than in-app purchase. I imagined that before engaging in a discussion you read the relative documentation ... I guess you didn't > Apple has plenty of competition It does not. It's artificial competition. The point is Apple is a market per se and is a monopolist in that market. If only people could have some degree of freedom it would be a different situation. > I choose the alternative. THere's no alternative to Apple, Apple is a different closed ecosystem. When you'll understand that, everything will be clearer. > I didn’t need the government for that. Iḿ sorry to state it like this, Iḿ Italian and my english is decent at best, but who cares what you need? I don't need a doctor right now, but I'm happy the government of my country is funding a public healthcare that can take care for free of people who need it and/or couldn't afford it if it was an expensive procedure > Even when people were complaining that Microsoft was a monopoly. I had an MS free house. They weren't complaining, they were stating the obvious, in fact MS was sentenced for "abuse of dominant position" Sun Microsystem raised the complain and won. Epic is doing the same to Apple, and will probably get some satisfaction. > What do you say about people that constantly complain about products that they don’t own? What do you say of people that constantly assume? > If Apple is stifling competition, where all of the profitable, successful Android only apps? The same apps that are profitable on iOS are profitable on Android, but they cost less for the user and the developer have the possibility of earning more You can play Fortnite on Android even if Google removes it from their store. Can you do the same on iOS?
- danShumway 6y ago> You mean the same 30% margin that Google, Sony, Microsoft (Xbox), Nintendo, Spotify, etc. charge? Why do people think this is an effective argument? In any other context, noting that prices are standardized across the entire market would be strong evidence that the market was not competitive. If you went into a shoe store and every shoe in the shop was $49.99, that's pretty good evidence that the shoe manufactures are not competing with each other over price the way that they should be. You look at something like gas prices, service industries, physical goods, games, online payment providers -- you see lots of different prices and fees, deals, and marketing strategies. You don't see a standardized price that's universally applied to everyone, because the companies are actually competing with each other to attract customers with diverse offerings. An unspoken agreement between every digital storefront to charge developers 30% fees on even unrelated services is bad. On more open platforms, you don't see that: Steam, Epic, GoG, Itch, and Humble all have different fees because they're actually competing with each other and it's actually possible for upstarts to disrupt the market.
- scarface74 6y agoYou can sideload on Android - why is Google charging 30%? You have a choice of three consoles - why aren’t developers side loading there? Where are the successful third party app stores for Android? Why did Epic decide to relent and make their game available on Google Play?
- danShumway 6y ago> You can sideload on Android [...] Where are the successful third party app stores for Android? [...] Why did Epic decide to relent and make their game available on Google Play? Epic is actively suing Google for using anti-competitive practices to force phone makers not to include 3rd-party app stores on their phones[0]. One example they bring up: > Epic struck a deal with OnePlus to make Epic games available on its phones through an Epic Games app. The Epic Games app would have allowed users to seamlessly install and update Epic games, including Fortnite, without obstacles imposed by Google’s Android OS. But Google forced OnePlus to renege on the deal, citing Google’s “particular[] concern” about Epic having the ability to install and update mobile games while “bypassing the Google Play Store”. If you want to show that sideloading doesn't make a difference for storefront fees, you should pick a company not currently being sued for antitrust to demonstrate it. ---- > You have a choice of three consoles - why aren’t developers side loading there? You can't sideload on a console, I don't know what you're getting at. In regards to price fixing on consoles: you're right, the console situation is also bad. We effectively have only 3 major consoles, and a reasonably high barrier of entry into the space for similar reasons as mobile phones. Of course, the console space is better (in no small part because the PC market exists), and console manufacturers do compete more for developers than Apple and Google do. But it's not perfect, and as a result, you still see some issues around competition. It took direct action from developers like Epic to even force the issue on cross-play, which is a decent sign that console manufactures really didn't feel like they needed to compete with each other in that area. However, it is generally ill-advised to sue every single major games distributor at the same time, so it is perfectly reasonable for Epic to target what they see as the biggest problem-areas first. The whataboutism doesn't really work here. Yes, console sideloading would probably be good for the market, it's just not as big and immediate of a problem as Apple is -- in part because more people own iPhones than an Xbox, in part because the barriers of entry to console competition are slightly lower, and in part because the PC games market provides somewhat of an escape hatch for console games, and that escape hatch isn't applicable to the mobile app market. [0]: https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/21759099/file0.243586135368002.pdf https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/21759099/f...