7 ms·
Ammonia as a fuel for compression ignition engines
- djrogers 6y agoSoooo... It has to be mixed with a co-combustion fuel, is dirtier than diesel, and requires more space and weight to clean up it's exhaust. The article really should have gone into some of the 'why' side of things - what are the advantages of ammonia?
- piannucci 6y agoKnowing nothing about this, broadly speaking, the enthalpy of formation of the diatomic nitrogen molecule is very high, and you might expect to achieve high energy density. Also it does not produce any CO2.
- neltnerb 6y agoSo for context -- I was working on this ten years ago. I don't have much to say about this particular example other than to note that almost all ammonia today is made using natural gas as the hydrogen source. Using ammonia is a neat idea, if made renewably, but it will continue to be a challenge to use in cars because it is pressurized, corrosive, and toxic even compared to gasoline. Obviously the bigger market for renewable ammonia should be fertilizers because right now we're feeding our crops petrochemicals in order to get high enough yields to feed us. That seems like a bad situation to put yourself in if there's any other choice.
- AprilArcus 6y agoIt's technologically trivial to make renewable hydrogen from clean electricity and non-potable water, under the right economic incentives (Carbon tax)
- neltnerb 6y agoIndeed. I would put "making transportation fuels" at about the bottom of the list in terms of the best use of electricity until such time as all electricity is renewable. It just doesn't make sense until the entire grid or close to it is renewable already because if you use 1J of electricity to make 0.95J of hydrogen that gets turned into 0.9J of ammonia you'd have been way better off just using 0.9J of gasoline in the first place because that 1J of electricity probably was generated from 3J of fossil fuels. So I'd say the same regarding fertilizers -- I'd rather they didn't use natural gas as a hydrogen feedstock, but generating hydrogen from electricity generated at a natural gas plant is a very Rube Goldbergy way to generate ammonia that still uses natural gas. That's changing, but it's nowhere near true yet. Generating ammonia from excess renewable electricity that the grid can't sink does make more sense to me.
- Symmetry 6y agoI'm not sure I'd agree about ordering. Solar power seems to be getting cheaper faster than batteries are. We might be in the position in the not too distant future where we have more electricity during sunny days than we know what to do with but still need some natural gas power plants to get us through cloudy months. Depending on capital costs "make H while the sun shines" might be a reasonable business.
- neltnerb 6y agoYeah, I am also on board with diverting excess electricity into transportation fuels if it literally can't fit on the grid. But every joule of electricity generated from renewables that makes it to the grid is a joule of electricity that wasn't generated with petrochemicals at the moment because natural gas peaker plants are still a thing. I had to once write a grant proposal for essentially the kind of thing you're talking about. It's exceptionally hard to make a good overall systems efficiency case for taking electricity and turning it back into fuels. I hope you agree that displacement of petrochemical electricity sources is far preferable to generating chemicals as a byproduct if the grid does have room for more electrons. The only way I was able to find to make it work economically was to take excess electricity and convert it into fairly high value chemicals -- but even there, just turning petrochemicals into those same chemicals would in almost every case be more efficient. I look forward to the day when we have so much renewable generation that we have no petrochemical electric plants left to displace. Hopefully it is not too far off, I like your optimism about solar and agree it may be warranted.
- jccooper 6y agoIf they had a FAQ I'd be looking for "How does ammonia power handle the many significant dangers of ammonia?" Except when extremely diluted that stuff makes diesel look like milk.
- FranOntanaya 6y agoMaybe it'd work for large trucks in very cold environments. Not much around in an accident and it handles lower temperatures.
- asdfadsfgfdda 6y agoThe main "why" is a carbon-free fuel (when produced by solar) in a relatively dense form. Liquid ammonia has higher energy density than liquid hydrogen, is easier to store, and is already used a bulk chemical around the world. It also is more energy efficient than liquifying hydrogen. If you imagined what oil would look like without carbon, ammonia is pretty close. The toxicity probably prevents cars and trucks from using ammonia, but for marine power or grid energy, it seems feasible. Also, the co-combustion fuel can be supplied on-site by cracking the ammonia to hydrogen. https://www.kallanishenergy.com/2020/07/08/air-products-to-build-5b-ammonia-project-in-saudi-arabia/ https://www.kallanishenergy.com/2020/07/08/air-products-to-b...
- elcritch 6y agoCargo/freight shipping could be a prime target for a cleaner ammonia base fuel as most of the ships currently run dirty semi-processed petroleum, “bunker fuel”. It’s a hyper-cost sensitive market so without regulation I’d doubt ammonia would compete. Still it could be a feasible option to reduce pollution. Some Western countries might accept ammonia or similar diesel replacement, as it’d be a sort of natural tariff, but likely China would lobby hard against such a measure. There’s have to be a very strong push from a few nations, which I’ll doubt we’ll see anytime soon.
- lpcam33 6y agoWhat is the energy return of energy invested on getting hydrogen from solar and then turning into ammonia?
- adrianN 6y agoIt's really poor, you need at least hydrogen for seasonal energy storage.
- ZeroGravitas 6y agoAre you counting the energy cost of preventing or mitigating climate change? It's not as good as plugging ibto the mains or using batteries, but it could well be the best option for industrial hydrogen, large boats and planes.
- jessaustin 6y agoIt has to be mixed with diesel in order to function in compression ignition engines, otherwise known as "diesel engines". So, this "criticism" could be leveled at gasoline and other fuels as well. Spark plugs will ignite ammonia just fine. There is a single reference to this in a different post on the site. [0] My understanding is that most "hobbyist" ammonia fuel setups (i.e. "my pickup runs on ammonia now!") also use spark ignition. I suspect they're investigating the diesel engine possibilities because they would require fewer modifications to existing large marine engines. [0] https://www.ammoniaenergy.org/articles/wartsila-tests-internal-combustion-of-ammonia/ https://www.ammoniaenergy.org/articles/wartsila-tests-intern...
- abe_m 6y agoI came across this a few years ago. The largest problem is that Ammonia is very toxic. It is also very corrosive. If you look around, there a lots of articles about problems when delivery systems are used to transport ammonia, and then propane. Trace contamination causes failure in propane systems due to corrosion. So in a crash situation, if the ammonia ruptures, you're probably dead, and everyone else in the vicinity. With gasoline, diesel, propane, or natural gas, if the tank ruptures, people in the vicinity are likely fine if it doesn't ignite. On heavy trucks, ruptured diesel tanks are quite common in crashes. Fires lighting from them, much less common (i.e. most ruptures don't result in fire). The article is devoid of any comment on the safety aspects, which from what I see, is likely the more important point.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoTypically the good thing with ammonia is that it's smell is easily detectable by people well below it's toxicity level. I don't think this helps if the tank us crushed and you are trapped inside an upside down car right next to it though. I think for the most part it is more interesting as a energy storage from renewable overproduction than in cars.
- rbanffy 6y agoOnly if the energy storage facility is far from everything. A large tank leak and you'll end up killing a whole city.
- AprilArcus 6y agoThis is a very reasonable point, and even somewhat understated, since even when ignited hydrocarbon fuel burns more safely than ammonia. Nitrogenous compounds don't ignite and gradually burn off; they detonate.
- mannykannot 6y agoDon't try this at home, but IIRC from my mis-spent youth you can light the ammonia gas in a half-empty bottle of household ammonia solution and it will burn off quietly. According to Wikipedia (which suggests that my memory may be faulty in this case): "The combustion of ammonia in air is very difficult in the absence of a catalyst (such as platinum gauze or warm chromium(III) oxide), due to the relatively low heat of combustion, a lower laminar burning velocity, high auto-ignition temperature, high heat of vaporization, and a narrow flammability range." Unlike nitrate compounds such as ammonium nitrate, ammonia contains no oxygen, and disassociates into hydrogen and nitrogen only.
- CyanLite2 6y agoAmmonia production consumes about 2% of the world's energy and generates 1% of its CO2.
- Animats 6y agoMAN, the biggest producer of marine diesels, was supposedly working on this. But there's nothing about it on the MAN site. Just on the "ammoniaenergy.org" site. The case for marine diesels is reasonable. The energy density is higher than bunker fuel, and the fuel only has to be available at major ports.
- ZeroGravitas 6y agoI belive Maersk has decided on Ammonia as the future for their ships, with refits of diesel engines acting as bridge to fuel cells.
- airstrike 6y agoMAN and Wartsila are both working on it Paywalled, unfortunately: https://m.shippingwatch.com/article/12359286 https://m.shippingwatch.com/article/12359286
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AngryData 6y agoScariest shit I ever did was help pull a completely full anhydrous ammonia tank out of a 6 foot ditch. The trailer it was attached to had slid off the gravel road and twisted upside down in the ditch, some nearby farmer bringing it home from fillup. And it was not made to be picked up at all when full, but you know smaller farmer not wanting to lose his ass and farm with it by calling out some hazmat crew to drain it and transfer it. Used an excavator with a chains to very carefully pick it up and roll it out onto the road so they could pull it onto another trailer. If that fucker cracked open basically all of us down in that little valley would have died horribly. But doing dangerous as fuck shit on the cheap is the only way these small time farmers are holding on in the face of corporate monoculture farms, and hope they can survive long enough for those corporate farms to leave the area when the soil is depleted and worthless from their unsustainable practices.
- pfdietz 6y agoOne use case for ammonia is in alkaline fuel cells. Ammonia can be reformed to nitrogen + hydrogen by passing it over a hot catalyst. The gas coming out is free of CO2, so it can be used in alkaline fuel cells without carbonate formation (the CO2 in the air used by the cell must still be scrubbed, but that's an easier problem). Alkaline fuel cells can use nickel instead of platinum electrodes.