5 ms·
Bacteria forming macro scale structures in nearly every wet ecosystem studied. Perhaps we need new definitions for 'organism'.
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Bacteria forming macro scale structures in nearly every wet ecosystem studied. Perhaps we need new definitions for 'organism'.
- taneq 6y agoOur innate fixation on categorizing everything has given us strange blind spots all over the place. Take the whole thing with plants in a rain forest communicating via chemicals and intermediate fungii and all sorts of things - we insist on thinking of them as separate organisms mutely battling each other, or (hippie hat firmly in place) as a single cohesive whole living in harmony. In reality it's neither, it's a disparate bunch of organisms in a complicated web of iterated cooperation and defection in a cutthroat battle for individual (and therefore often communal) survival.
- ChefboyOG 6y agoI think this is actually a major point that doesn't get discussed enough. Our human impulse to apply a rigid taxonomy to things, to model them as discrete, absolute units instead of complex systems, is obviously very useful and intuitive, but comes up short when we try to study things of sufficient complexity.
- hcarvalhoalves 6y agoI don't think it's necessarily a human impulse, it's just so foundational in our culture that we can't unlearn. Blame Plato. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonism
- meowface 6y agoWhat if we look at it from the other side, too? How much competition and individual optimization is going on among the cells in the bodies and brains of animals, including humans? I suppose one of the big differences is the shared lineage and DNA, though I don't know how much that affects cooperation.
- taneq 6y agoExactly! We think ourselves as a single thing but we're more like a megalopolis inhabited mostly by bacteria with infrastructure provided by a clone army. Of course in our dystopian internal society any unsanctioned individuality is quashed by the militarised police... unless of course it isn't at which point it metastatizes and everyone dies. (The question about shared DNA is really interesting - so much of our individual drive for survival is a result of our K-strategist genetics and the resultant selection pressures over the years. If we spawned like octopi or grew from spores like orks, how much different would our worldview be?)
- youareostriches 6y agoMany types of stem cells indeed undergo competitive selection within a tissue, and the victors differentiate into somatic cells. Reduced competition within this process is responsible for things like skin aging.
- maxerickson 6y agoEcology is a major field.
- tambourine_man 6y agoIt's easy to see things falling through taxonomy cracks, but it's also an incredibly useful tool. If we imagine that intelligence and comprehension involves information compression, it might be an unavoidable strategy.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoYep, just think of eukaryotes themselves -- symbiosis between entirely different kingdoms of life (bacterial mitochondria & archaea host) is built into the very lifeform itself. And when they form multicellular creatures, and then those multicellular creatures hang with other creatures... it's so blurry. Not only are we intensely focused on categorizing, we also have the need/instinct to identify "things" and "units" and "selves" -- when in reality those lines 'between things' don't really exist except as a tool for cognition.
- andrewflnr 6y agoYep. Divisions of the world into categories are models. All models are wrong. Some models are useful.
- rotexo 6y agoIf I might make a gentle counterpoint: if we didn't follow a rigorous reductionist process, the article you are commenting on wouldn't exist and we wouldn't know a thing about bacteria forming large-scale structures in order to take advantage of spatially separated resources in their environment. I wouldn't say that our blind spots exist because scientists follow a reductionist line of inquiry; instead, I think our blind spots exist because we are, to some degree, born ignorant in a universe of evolving life. Now, of course the reductionist process can't tell us everything, but I think it is possible to recognize and appreciate what the process can help us understand.
- ManBlanket 6y agoIdentifying a gap in our understanding of something can be as conversely significant as a given finding. I take umbrage with allowing reductionism to prevent consideration of other ideas where it fails to explain something. I know it's not scientific to suppose the balance of life's complex systems is deterministic, but if you look at population dynamics a possible explanation is homeostasis as the destination state. The motivations of the individual be damned, life seems to find a balance. Perhaps our understanding of what's really going on in the biosphere is as limited as the perspective of an immune cell in the human body. Just saying, determinism might not be terribly scientific, but it's still worth considering in the context of what we can't explain with reductionism. You have to admit, what we're all experiencing right now, life, is pretty flippin' remarkable.
- rotexo 6y agoMaybe I am misunderstanding the terms we are using. Allow me to articulate what I think the valuable line of inquiry is here, and then maybe you can identify what I am missing philosophically, because I'm still not sure exactly what that is, even after reading your comment. In my thinking, a reductionist thought process goes something like this: we observe oxidation of the hydrogen sulfide in mud, even when there are no apparent electron acceptors in the immediate vicinity. We then identify bacterial filaments which appear to allow electron transport from the reducing agent to the electron acceptor. Furthermore, we will then attempt to isolate the bacteria making up the filaments, and then attempt to identify what structures they synthesize to allow this feat. And a few follow up questions to your comment: what do you think population dynamics have to do with the current phenomenon, or was that more a related thought? When you talk about "destination states," are you insinuating that there is some design occurring, or that we can observe states in the state space that seem to be stable, and that random walks tend to end up in those stable states? If it is the latter, I totally agree, and I don't see how that is outside of the purview of science as traditionally practiced. It might be an interpretation or model for how the parts of a system fit together, but an attempt at synthesis is basically in the conclusions section of any paper ever written in biology. So I guess it boils down to the same question I posed earlier: how exactly are scientists failing to describe natural phenomena?
- bawolff 6y agoWhat's the alternative? Never categorizing anything? Breaking complex things into simpler parts is the foundation of most understanding. Yes categorization implies putting things in boxes, and the box chosen is often the incorrect abstraction. However i think the answer is to make better boxes; not throw out the idea of categorizing things. Similar to how if your code base is full of bad abstractions, you wouldn't try to fix it by having no abstractions.
- taneq 6y ago> What's the alternative? Never categorizing anything? Ah, yes, because the alternative to 'always' is 'never', not 'sometimes when appropriate.' Categorisation is great and helps us make sense of the world. It's just sometimes misleading and we should always be on guard against category errors.
- bawolff 6y agoWhen would it not be appropriate? Even calling something sui generis is an act of categorization (not that very many things are, esoecially natural things) Sure category errors are a thing, but the error is not in the act of categorizing something at all. They are errors in using an inapropriate schemata.
- agumonkey 6y agois it an organism or a society ?
- cestith 6y agoIs each of us? Is the truth that it depends on context? You're about 10% human by cell count but 97% human by weight, as am I. The microflora and microfauna of the gut, mouth, and skin are amazingly deep topics we as a species have so far only shallowly investigated. On another level and somewhat figuatively, is the Internet a society of its own or simply a bridge among societies? Is it a bunch of communities (definitely yes at some level) or one big community with several sub-communities and cliques? Is it a culture, a subculture, a counterculture, a blending of cultures, a point of contact between distinct cultures? Yes, it's all that, and in certain contexts more one than another.
- agumonkey 6y agoThat was included in my question :)
- hammock 6y ago>10% human by cell count but 97% human by weight Interested why the difference between cell count and cell weight is so different in the human and non-human parts? Most of the total weight is water, right? So why is all of the water stored in the human cells but not in the non-human cells?
- frank2 6y agoThe human cells are on average much larger. In general eukaryotic cells are much larger than prokaryotic cells, and most of the non-human cells in a human are prokaryotic. All bacteria for example are prokaryotic. I don't think the fraction of water is higher in eukaryotic cells than in prokaryotic cells. I think water constitutes about 70% of both types of cells.
- rotexo 6y agoAt least regarding this particular piece, it seems to me (microbiology PhD) that we have a perfectly adequate definition of organism (I like a definition of life put forwards by NASA: a self-sustaining chemical system capable of undergoing evolution). It is a definition that allowed us to discover and formulate answerable questions about an interesting and novel (to us, at least) form of life, after all. Moreover, cooperative bacteria forming large-scale structures is not new to science (see, for instance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myxococcus_xanthus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myxococcus_xanthus). What do you think needs to be added to the definition of organism? What do you think would be gained from that addition?