5 ms·
According to he article, modelling shows that lockdowns are unnecessary if mask and hand washing compliance is > 70% and contact tracing effectiveness is > 80%.
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
According to he article, modelling shows that lockdowns are unnecessary if mask and hand washing compliance is > 70% and contact tracing effectiveness is > 80%.
- ryanbrunner 6y agoThe problem is, contact tracing in the U.S. is impossible right now, there's just way too many infections to possibly have an effective contact tracing program.
- cstejerean 6y agoHence the need for lockdowns to drive infections down to the level where contact tracing becomes feasible.
- jerf 6y agoLockdowns are not a thing being proposed as a future policy. They are here, and have been for several incubation periods. For that purpose, they have failed. Past tense. I post this as a segue into the general observation that there's still way too many people speaking about hypotheticals as if we're not six months into this process, and have plenty of concrete data to consult rather than theory. If the purpose of X is Y, we are not in a place where we should start doing X to get Y; we are in a place to look to see if X got us Y. In this particular case, it apparently did not. (It's also not a great time to say "Well, X would have led to Y if we just X'd harder". In a good chunk of the world, we X'd as hard as we can. If we didn't get Y, it's not something you're going to get in the future, either. That is something we have to accept and deal with, not wish we could just X harder.)
- EForEndeavour 6y ago> In a good chunk of the world, we X'd as hard as we can. A good chunk of the USA very explicitly did not "X" anywhere near as hard or smart as they could have.
- ryandrake 6y ago"Lockdown" pretty much never happened in the USA. There were these half-assed stay at home orders, which in practice ended up being voluntary and unenforced. People were out horsing around and very few enforcement actions happened, despite most of the orders being enforceable as misdemeanors. Fortunately most people voluntarily did the right thing, but not enough for it to matter.
- jerf 6y agoMileage varied significantly on those. I haven't seen a lot of evidence that better participation led to proportionately better outcomes. Besides, lockdowns, which have never really been done like this before, may just be something that can not work. You can't suddenly demand that everyone in a society be in the 80%th percentile of conscientiousness, and also be just hunky dory with not going to work anymore and being under effective house arrest for extended periods of time. This is probably one of those cases where HN is not equipped to make an accurate assessment, being exceedingly preferentially chosen from high conscientiousness and college-educated populations (as, if nothing else, college indicates a certain amount of discipline). If you project yourself and your peers out onto society, you are going to grossly misunderstand the real society. Plans to avoid contagion need to deal with the society that we have, not the one we want.
- ebalit 6y agoWhat do you do of the effects of lock-down in European countries?
- occamrazor 6y agoHow didn’t they work? Every time they have been implemented properly (Hubei, Italy, Spain. NYC, New Zealand) they reached the objective of reducing the infection levels to a few new cases per day. Obviously they cannot be a permanent solution, but they were never meant to be one.
- zxspectrum1982 6y agoLook at Spain right now. Infection rate is huge again, even with masks being mandatory in public. Lockdown is useless and destroyed their economy, and masks are mostly useless. That's the hard reality. Luckily, this virus is not making us zombies, or killing our children. It's killing our elders and people with a weakened immune system; it's sad but it's great. It could have been a lot worse.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 6y agoAgreed. I tried putting that into my comment, but it turned my comment from a nice factual statement about the article into a screed about the incompetence of government.
- irq11 6y agoIf you set the parameters properly, modeling shows anything you want it to show. The paper cited by the nature article does not explicitly consider masks or hand washing. It combines all measures recommended by the Mexican government, and makes a broad assumption about their overall effectiveness: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0025556420300596 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002555642... All of the models for handwashing and masks that I am aware of have made blithely optimistic assumptions about their effectiveness. The WHO meta-study of masks, eye protection and social distancing found that masks overall had an odds ratio of 0.33 - and most of that evidence came from N95 respirators, used in hospitals, for personal protection: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(20)31142-9/fulltext#figures https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... We have essentially no evidence that non-respirator masks, in the hands of the public, does anything at all: https://www.cebm.net/covid-19/masking-lack-of-evidence-with-politics/ https://www.cebm.net/covid-19/masking-lack-of-evidence-with-... (Edit: as per usual, factual discussion of masks is censored on HN. This is not a political debate! I have provided links to legitimate scientific resources to support all of my arguments. Consider your bias before reflexively jabbing the downvote button.)
- bryanlarsen 6y ago> We have essentially no evidence that non-respirator masks, in the hands of the public, does anything at all: We have tons of evidence. Countries with high mask compliance have done a much better job of containing the virus. It's difficult to determine if it's causative or coincidental so it's not conclusive, but it certainly is evidence.
- irq11 6y agoI cited the evidence - the links to the WHO meta-study and the oxford center for evidence-based medicine are comprehensive, and results are as I quoted them. If you think there is additional evidence that they have not covered, cite it. “Countries with high mask compliance” is not a definable parameter. Japan was held up as a “mask-wearing country”, but is currently in the midst of a major outbreak. Hawaii is locked down again. Singapore has had recurrent outbreaks, despite widespread mask use. Sweden and the Netherlands do not require masks, and have brought their epidemics under control. Any attempt to draw conclusions based on what happens to a country after passing a mask rule, is an exercise in post hoc fallacious reasoning.
- solidasparagus 6y agoThe world is not going to wear masks forever. If we haven't solved the problem in the next two years people are just going to accept Coronavirus as a normal risk in life like car accidents, cancer and heart disease. Also, permanent contact tracing sounds like a real dystopia - and I can't imagine it holding up long-term in US courts.
- thinkingemote 6y agoOne thing that could be permanent is the world wearing masks when they have cold symptoms. Like in Asian countries. The way to do that would be via social pressure (like in Asian countries) than legal measures.
- me_me_me 6y ago> The way to do that would be via social pressure (like in Asian countries) Except that its not really a pressure, but a social contract. 'I am sick so the least i can do is wear a mask while outside to protect others. So others do the same.' Win-win.
- threatofrain 6y agoOne of the mechanisms of social contracts is pressure. Is this a radical idea? A few individuals always have a different perspective on any deal, and the majority will need a way to enforce the look and feel of community lifestyle. Such as an agreement for racial harmony.
- bookofjoe 6y agoIn Japan masks in public have been the default for many years.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]