3 ms·
Over many years, I had to port an addon from Greasemonkey to XUL to Jetpack to WebExtensions. The number of add-on users steadily dropped as the number of Firef
by Animats 6y ago
Over many years, I had to port an addon from Greasemonkey to XUL to Jetpack to WebExtensions. The number of add-on users steadily dropped as the number of Firefox users dropped.
Now, if you write a Firefox extension, and it's not a Mozilla-recommended extension (something you have to beg for) anyone installing it gets a scary notice:
"This is not monitored for security through Mozilla's Recommended Extensions program. Make sure you trust it before installing."
This is after going through Mozila's approval and signing process. Unsigned extensions won't install at all in the release version of Firefox.
Firefox extensions aren't something worth working on any more.
- JanisL 6y ago> Firefox extensions aren't something worth working on any more. Unfortunately I now totally share this sentiment, I had an extension that delayed page loads in a realistic way to test slower connections. I started on back when XUL was the way to do it but dealing with the churn led me to give up. When XUL was being deprecated I ported to the newer way but I could tell that the churn was starting to get annoying and that my enthusiasm had changed. As much as I would have liked to continue work with that extension with the recent changes I'm glad I gave up when I did. I'd really like to see something change to make working on extensions feel like it's more worthwhile again. Do people think that things are likely to stabilize in the next few years?
- dralley 6y agoThe entire point of switching to WebExtensions was that things could be stabilized permanently.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Animats 6y agoBrowser extensions are probably going to go away, at least in Chrome. Google needs to control ad blocking. They've never been a big thing on the Chrome side anyway. Firefox is down to 8.61% market share worldwide. As Google removes user control, they can make Firefox go along, since they're Mozilla's biggest revenue source.
- Yoric 6y ago> As Google removes user control, they can make Firefox go along, since they're Mozilla's biggest revenue source. So far, the only manners in which Google has influenced Firefox are: - the influence of Google in standards; - the need for Mozilla to keep improving its products to remain competitive. So, if Google removes user control, that's actually good news for Firefox.