4 ms·
Well, Firefox is far from dead, is it? I guess the issue is a different view of what Firefox should be; I feel that many people would be satisfied if Firefox w
by arp242 6y ago
Well, Firefox is far from dead, is it?
I guess the issue is a different view of what Firefox should be; I feel that many people would be satisfied if Firefox was just a small(ish) browser catering to power users. There's nothing wrong with that: power users are users too (and there are more of them than many seem to think), and I feel that many people are somewhat frustrated that all software seems designed with only my grandmother in mind. This is an issue that extends far beyond XUL by the way.
- kmeisthax 6y agoThe original design goal of Firefox was to be a "90/10" browser (relative to the old Mozilla suite). e.g. 90% of the people only need 10% of the features. Catering to power users was never the goal of Firefox and they lost users to Chrome when they did. What people want is a browser that loads webpages quickly and doesn't use a lot of system resources doing so.
- arp242 6y agoWell, Mozilla included email, chat, and whatnot. Regardless of what the goals were, it did cater to power users and clearly many people don't want the direction Firefox went in.
- Semaphor 6y ago> and clearly many people don't want the direction Firefox went in. A majority? I doubt it. I think it’s an extremely vocal minority that don’t care about the slowness of their browser (pre-e10s, pre-quantum), about things breaking (XUL extensions) or about UI features for the broad masses. I’d bet money that FF’s 25% in Germany would be far closer to US numbers if they stayed where those vocal people want them.
- arp242 6y agoI never said majority. All I'm saying is that based on my observations people's views on what Firefox should or should not be are different, and that this explains why people are still "angry" about the extensions breaking and such. I'm not having an argument with anyone.
- cedilla 6y agoThat may seem like bloat today, but in those days, web mail barely existed and was inferior. If anything, using the MUA bundled with your browser was less power-userish than using a stand-alone client.
- arp242 6y agoI still miss the old Opera, including the built-in email client I used. So yeah, I agree. Honestly, Opera is one of the best pieces of software I've ever used. It had tons of features and customizability without being slow or feeling "bloated". I never quite understood why it failed to gain marketshare 10 years ago while Firefox did.
- zokula 6y ago> I never quite understood why it failed to gain marketshare 10 years ago while Firefox did. Firefox was free and Opera wasn't. Geeks don't trust proprietary garbage.
- m4rtink 6y agoThese "most people only use 10% of the features, so we can drop the rest" ideas are just soo stupid & can quickly kill otherwise good projects. And it's not just about chasing away power users, who are about the only advocates and marketing you have. Its mainly about the 10% being different for every user, effectively covering the full feature matrix!
- Dagger2 6y agoExactly. There's no such thing as an average user: https://www.thestar.com/news/insight/2016/01/16/when-us-air-force-discovered-the-flaw-of-averages.html https://www.thestar.com/news/insight/2016/01/16/when-us-air-... If you design your thing for the average user, it won't work well for any user.
- Karunamon 6y agoYet that seems to be precisely who they're targeting. The only benefit Firefox now has over Chrome is a vague political notion of not using Google-made software, something that there isn't enough call for in the real world to drive significant marketshare. Their real differentiation was sacrificed on the altar of ease of development, and now what we're left with is an also-ran, in multiple meanings of that term. Worse, an also-ran that's doing increasingly arational things, almost as if they're wildly groping about for the mythical marketshare.
- Izkata 6y agoWell, perhaps not the only thing: Tree Style Tabs opens in a sidebar in Firefox (and with user CSS, can be made to auto-expand), while in Chrome it opens in a separate window.
- The_Colonel 6y ago> I feel that many people would be satisfied if Firefox was just a small(ish) browser catering to power users. There's no way to do that in today's environment. Browser development is extremely expensive (there's only 3 companies in the world developing competitive browser engines) so you need money. For Firefox, the only way to get serious cash is to have serious marketshare. And in reality there isn't that many "power users". I mean, even a lot of developers (like me) use barely any extensions and in any case prefer more speed than more extensibility.
- slightwinder 6y agoBrowser development is not that expensive. Developing of Web-Engines is the dark part that sucks all the money. > For Firefox, the only way to get serious cash is to have serious marketshare. Not true. That's only valid if your single income is marketshare-based. Mozilla for some unknown reasons hasn't made any serious attempts in the last 15+ years to get any alternative income, instead it was satisfied with being feeding on google and yahoo, while wasting money on some obvious dead projects.
- The_Colonel 6y ago> Browser development is not that expensive. Developing of Web-Engines is the dark part that sucks all the money. Of course, but then there's enough Chromium skins, no? Without independent browser engine you have no clout in defining and ratifying standard (as MS recently found out) which means giving Google full control. > Mozilla for some unknown reasons hasn't made any serious attempts in the last 15+ years to get any alternative income, instead it was satisfied with being feeding on google and yahoo, while wasting money on some obvious dead projects. They had some feeble attempts which largely failed. Mozilla's main expertise is still browser technology based and it is probably difficult to monetize it.
- slightwinder 6y ago> Of course, but then there's enough Chromium skins, no? Most of them are more than skins. A browser is the interface and whole workflow, not just the way the website is displayed. > as MS recently found out What do you mean? > They had some feeble attempts which largely failed. They had no SERIOUS attempt. Well until now at least. They did some half-assed with pocket and now VPN-reselling, but never touched real business.
- dao- 6y ago> if Firefox was just a small(ish) browser catering to power users. There's nothing wrong with that Except that it couldn't work in today's world, as more and more web sites would stop working in Firefox. Firefox needs significant market share to survive with an independent browser engine. Having an independent engine is key to achieving Mozilla's mission: https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/mission/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/mission/ You can build a browser focused on power users if you don't need to worry about the engine. Perhaps you want to take a look at Vivaldi?
- rvba 6y agoWhen you have a browser that is USED by programmers, the programmers will know that their own site is bad. Problems started when it stopped being a browser for programmers and power users. They were the ones marketing it. Mozilla cut the branch on which they were sitting and is now shocked that they lose maretshare.