5 ms·
My experience: I proposed a thesis to an advisor who deemed it unlikely to work. He ran it by a colleague who came to the same conclusion. I went to a different
by bumby 6y ago
My experience: I proposed a thesis to an advisor who deemed it unlikely to work. He ran it by a colleague who came to the same conclusion. I went to a different major and pursued the same thesis and invited the previous faculty who initially turned it down to the defense because it was relevant to their field.
It was frustrating to hear them voice their opinions in the defense that they felt, “of course it world work.” After seeing the data, they took the exact opposite side claiming it was obvious to the point of being of limited publishing value.
- executesorder66 6y agoDidn't you ask them "But didn't you say this was uspublishable?" and what was their response?
- bumby 6y agoI did not. Maybe I was being weak or maybe I didn’t want to try and make them look bad in front of their peers but I did not bring up any of the previous conversations during the defense
- executesorder66 6y agoThanks for the response. I'm always just curious how people react to things like that.
- raincom 6y agoAcademia is 'full' of people who lack intellectual integrity. Imagine Frege's response to Bertrand Russell's letter concerning barber's paradox: 'it's obvious!' Instead of doing that, Frege openly acknowledged Russell's criticism in his book.
- PeterStuer 6y agoImagine how much worse it is outside where there's even no pretense of adhering to any intellectual rigor. Also within academia there is still a wide spectrum of intellectual rigor across the disciplines. Some things are just more verifiable than others.
- smnrchrds 6y agoSince the first and second interactions were 4 or more years apart, it is entirely conceivable that the field had moved enough during those years to warrant a genuine change in opinion.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- matthewdgreen 6y agoIt's also possible that they were just trying to protect a student from investing years into a project that they deemed to have a low (but perhaps non-zero) chance of success. This is a thing that good advisors should do to protect their students from career-wasting wild goose chases. The fact that the two interactions were very different with four years and a completed thesis between them doesn't surprise me at all. My own embarrassing story is that I advised Jason Donenfeld to submit his WireGuard paper to NDSS, forgot about the meeting entirely after a few months, then complained (in retrospect, unfairly) when NDSS accepted it. Advisors do stupid, embarrassing, forgetful things all the time. The OP's story isn't even a misdemeanor.
- sullyj3 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindsight_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hindsight_bias
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoI recall Dan Ariely mentioning this in one of his books. His field is psychology/behavioural economics, a field where very often either outcome of an experiment can seem obvious after the fact. (Questions like Do newborn babies have an intuitive understanding of gravity?) As I recall, he restructured his lectures, asking upfront for a show of hands as to which outcome everyone anticipated, before the big reveal. After making this change, he had fewer people approaching him after lectures saying how obvious the outcome was.
- spidersouris 6y agoDo you know which book?
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoIt's one of the three of his books I own, I'm afraid I can't easily narrow it down further. (I own all three as audiobooks, and I recall Simon Jones reading it, but it turns out he read all three.) • Predictably Irrational • The (Honest) Truth About Dishonesty • The Upside of Irrationality
- elliekelly 6y agoTangentially related I wish there were a way to “search” within audio books. Once you’ve finished the book its almost impossible to figure out where a specific chapter or passage is if you’d like to go back.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoThey'd rather charge you separately for a DRM-locked ebook version.
- ScottBurson 6y agoI guess the lesson is, when an advisor rejects your thesis idea, get them to put their reasons in writing.
- bumby 6y agoI had their rejections in email. Ultimately, the committee brought them around and accepted my thesis so I didn’t feel it was worth burning those bridges.
- WJW 6y agoWhat would that get you though, other than knowing you were right (which you already knew without having it in writing) and (if you decide to publicly call them out on it) enemies for life in your chosen field of study?
- ScottBurson 6y agoOh, I wouldn't do it publicly. The point would be to push back, in private discussions, against the argument that the result was not interesting enough to publish.
- bobloblaw45 6y agoI would have challenged them to a duel.
- maze-le 6y agoBut be sure to put all your brilliant thoughts into writing and send it to a friend, you just might get a whole area of mathematics named after you...
- conjectures 6y agoWell I guess the problem there is inviting them to your defence. People gonna people.
- bumby 6y agoTrue. In retrospect, I was a bit naïve.
- montalbano 6y agoI believe this quote from J.B.S. Haldane is relevant here: I suppose the process of acceptance will pass through the usual four stages: (i) This is worthless nonsense; (ii) This is an interesting, but perverse, point of view; (iii) This is true, but quite unimportant; (iv) I always said so
- akiselev 6y agoIt's actually pretty impressive when a scientist goes through the full cycle, especially if they're already at the top of their field. Usually, they never make it past (ii) hence the Planck principle: "science advances one funeral at a time" (see The Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Kuhn)