3 ms·
My biggest concern with this study is sampling. My read is that test subjects were entirely self-selected, which mean strong bias to those who suspected (or fe
by dredmorbius 6y ago
My biggest concern with this study is sampling.
My read is that test subjects were entirely self-selected, which mean strong bias to those who suspected (or feared) exposure, had access to testing, and (where and when necessary) could pay for same (I don't know whether or when NYC instituted universal free test access).
That's in addition to any issues with test accuracy, procedures, or reporting itself.
The information tells a story. It's not immediately evident just how accurate that story is, an uncertainty which may further muddy conversations and decisionmaking regarding the outbreak.
As any statistician worth their salt will tell you, sample size is vastly less relevant than sample method, and a rigorous, though small (a few hundred, perhaps 1,000 or so randomly selected casess) would be highly valuable. The alternative (at far greater cost) is near-total testing. Itally have conducted comprehensive testing within specific small towns. Some smaller countries and territories (Andorra, Faroe Islands, Monaco, Luxembourg) have attained 100% test coverage. These still suggest 1-6.% CFR.
New York City's test coverage, whilst large, could still remain quite biased.