3 ms·
I know Joe, I've worked both with and for him. Frankly, this sounds completely out of character for him. He's someone who has a strong moral compass and has b
by jedberg 6y ago
I know Joe, I've worked both with and for him. Frankly, this sounds completely out of character for him. He's someone who has a strong moral compass and has been catching black hats for over 20 years.
There has to be more to this story. I feel like he was probably railroaded by Uber's legal team/CEO and they did things he may not have been fully aware of. That's the only explanation I can come up with.
I look forward to him having his day in court to vindicate himself.
- lhorie 6y agoMy admittedly limited understanding/speculation (from what I saw disclosed in the media and the timing of the events) is that this breach came to light shortly after Dara took over as CEO (presumably from a review of finances), and that Dara then voluntarily disclosed the breach to the public as part of Uber's reputation house cleaning effort, and that the failure to disclose the breach was the reason for Joe's termination. I don't know whether Uber had a proper bug bounty program setup at the time this happened, nor whether this could be considered one, so I can't comment on the specifics.
- j4nt4b 6y agoA lot of this information is available in the compliant that was filed by the FBI against Sullivan: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/7041237/Joseph-Sullivan-Complaint.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/7041237/Joseph-Su... In particular, part of Sullivan's cover-up efforts included passing the breach off as a $100,000 bug (their largest at the time) in the bounty program and trying to sign secret NDAs with the hackers. He also paid them a bitcoin ransom. > Witnesses reported SULLIVAN was visibly shaken by the events. It's a good read.
- mascafe 6y agoYour views conflict with facts 1) https://web.archive.org/web/20200414123312/http://www.uberscandals.org/category/managers/joe-sullivan/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200414123312/http://www.ubersc... 2) https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/12/new-letter-top-uber-officials-engaged-in-illegal-wiretapping-shady-spycraft/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/12/new-letter-top-u...
- rhacker 6y agoWho wrote the facts?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- matchagaucho 6y agoI've also worked with Joe. Great guy and one of the pioneers that implemented bounty programs at massive scale. Puzzling case, as the hackers apparently moved on from Uber to hack other companies. Not something within Uber's control.
- tptacek 6y agoThe hackers first broke into Lynda.com, using the same techniques, and emailed a ransom demand; Lynda responded by immediately disclosing the breach. Uber moved the conversation to HackerOne, and then made two $50,000 bitcoin payments to the still-pseudonymous hackers. What appears to be making this a big deal is that Uber had been hacked several years prior, and was negotiating with the FTC over the breach; the 2016 breach was not timely disclosed to the FTC, despite formal statements being provided after the breach occurred. Misleading the FTC is pretty clearly something that was under Uber's control.
- ponker 6y agoPeople can appear different to different people the same way that a person with multiple Reddit accounts can be entirely different personas on them. When we see accounts of someone that strongly conflict with our accounts of that person, our inclination is to believe that our view of that person is the "right" one. This is just an artifact of human's natural sensory self-centrism: you can only see him as the person you have seen him as. The likely truth, about everyone, is that like a 3D object viewed from a single vantage point, that no one person ever truly knows another. And obviously, everyone deserves their day in court.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jhanschoo 6y agoIt is not unreasonable that an ethically minded person would have chosen to take the actions that he did. For example, consider if his first priority was to protect the people whose PII was leaked. With the hackers' identities known, Uber or Sullivan is able to use the threat of exposing their crime as leverage if they should notice that the PII is being exploited. The 100k doesn't make single-game game-theoretic sense but can guard against people who expect a tit-for-tat.