3 ms·
Which would kill the subsidised console market, nobody is going to buy a console for $600, and would just turn iOS into a clone of the fragmented dumpster fire
by simonh 6y ago
Which would kill the subsidised console market, nobody is going to buy a console for $600, and would just turn iOS into a clone of the fragmented dumpster fire that is the Android app ecosystem.
This is why we can't have nice things.
- criddell 6y agoThe subsidized console market is largely a myth anyway.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe subsidies mostly aren't in exclusive cash - although they have a razor and blades style price shifting for upfront hardware and "console tax" on games but in "standardization" - having a big 3 or so system configurations to design and test for is easy and gives them a big market with just one and the biggest if across all 3 compared to Windows PCs and their minority of minorities mac and Linux share.
- simonh 6y agoConsoles are mostly sold at slightly above the cost of manufacture, maybe 5%, but that's nowhere near enough to recoup the costs of development, distribution, marketing and maintaining the attached online services. To make a profit on them as a standalone consumer product MS and Sony would to charge another 30% to 40%. The bill of manufacture for a PS 5 is estimated at $450, that's why I said they would probably have to charge $600. The console market is highly price sensitive and we've seen time and again a premium of just $100 can kill a product.
- criddell 6y agoSony is also in the software business. Their hardware margins may be thin, but how profitable is Naughty Dog? Or Insomniac? What kind of money do they make from the subscription services sold on the console?
- simonh 6y agoI'm not sure what you're implying. Are you saying Sony and Microsoft should just make less money? It's entirely possible to lose money on consoles. Microsoft wrote off such a huge loss on the first XBOX, between $5bn and $7bn, that counting inflation on the losses they probably still haven't made a profit off it. The other problem with that is it would make it flat out impossible for any other company ever to enter the console market. The up front cost is device losses would be staggering. It was bad enough for Microsoft as it is.
- criddell 6y ago> Are you saying Sony and Microsoft should just make less money? Not at all. I'm merely pointing on that their console business is composed of many streams and focusing on one part of it to the exclusion of others is deceiving. Supposedly, Return of the Jedi has never made money yet they kept making Star Wars movies. > it would make it flat out impossible for any other company ever to enter the console market I disagree. It's harder to compete with competitors that are selling their product below the cost of production. I've always wondered if an EU-based company came out with a console, what would happen? I think Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo would be forced to sell their consoles at or above cost in the EU or face dumping charges.
- simonh 6y agoI don’t think it’s deceiving at all. If you don’t think it would lead to them to make less money, can you explain how? It seems to me that if the consoles cost 1/3 more they would sell fewer of them (Lots of empirical evidence for this), and therefore sell fewer games and make less revenue on services to their smaller customer base, who now can by games from other publishers without the console vendor making a penny. After all isn’t the point of this to cut off their other revenue streams at the knees? I may well be missing something though.
- mhermher 6y agoToo bad. I guess they'll have to find some other way to make money outside of rent.
- LexGray 6y agoLooking forward to a fun new App Store world. Just like streaming services it will fragment to many different subscribed stores, each with their own privacy and sharing policies, for temporary access to exclusive games. Nothing like a little offshore gaming or porn gaming to pass the time in class.