14 ms·
I've been spending quite a bit of time interacting with the young-earth creationist community on Reddit and YouTube. It is closely related to flat-earth, thoug
by lisper 6y ago
I've been spending quite a bit of time interacting with the young-earth creationist community on Reddit and YouTube. It is closely related to flat-earth, though there is one significant difference: YEC is overtly religious, and specifically Christian. Other than that many of the forms of argument are the same. From that experience I have made two observations:
1. These people are not idiots (at least the YECs aren't, I can't speak for the flat-earthers) and to dismiss them as idiots who will just go away is a serious mistake. They are very good at presenting convincing-sounding arguments, and refuting them can actually be quite challenging.
2. The root of their reasoning is a tacit acceptance of teleology, which cannot be logically refuted. They approach existential questions with the assumption that there has to be some kind of point to existence, some transcendent meaning or purpose. If you accept this premise, then there is actually a logically defensible line of reasoning that leads you to Christianity and thence to the inerrancy of the Bible, and thence to YEC (and even a flat earth if you're really being intellectually honest!) A failure to appreciate this is IMHO one of the reasons that the secular world is having such a hard time effectively resisting these movements. A life without purpose makes no sense to these people, just as a theory at odds with the data makes no sense to someone with a scientific mindset. So if science leads you to the conclusion that life has no transcendent purpose (and it does) then, on their world-view, science must be wrong, full stop. No amount of data is going to persuade them otherwise.
- baddox 6y agoIt’s still not a good explanation to say “humans must have some purpose, therefore this one very specific made-up thing must be true.” What about all the other made-up things which also purport to explain the purpose of humans? Explanations of this form are extremely easy to vary, which is why they are not good explanations.
- lisper 6y agoBut that only matters if you think that explanations are what matters. That is an assumption. That's the whole point: some people value purpose more than they value explanation.
- baddox 6y ago> That's the whole point: some people value purpose more than they value explanation. Sure, but I don't think the debate is over whether creationists derive a sense of purpose from their beliefs. I have no doubt that they do. You'd never need to discuss things like fossils or evolution or cosmology to determine whether one derives a sense of purpose from one's beliefs. My assumption was that these debates are about the epistemological status of these claims, which is largely independent of whether one derives a sense of purpose.
- lisper 6y agoYes, you're right. But by the time you get around to arguing about fossils your thought processes have already diverged beyond reconciliation. It's not because either of you are idiots, it's because you started from different foundational assumptions.
- baddox 6y agoThat may very well be true, but making arguments that conceal your true world view or "axioms" is intellectually dishonest.
- lisper 6y agoI've never encountered a YEC who concealed their foundational belief in the inerrancy of the Bible. In fact, if you watch Kent Hovind, he opens every single video he makes with, "I believe that the Bible is true and scientifically accurate." If you're going to lob charges of intellectual dishonesty you should be very careful that you're not living in a glass house.
- baddox 6y ago> In fact, if you watch Kent Hovind, he opens every single video he makes with, "I believe that the Bible is true and scientifically accurate." If you're spending lots of effort making what appear to be good-faith arguments toward some conclusion, but that conclusion is in fact an axiom that you hold, then that's intellectually dishonest. If "Bible is true and scientifically accurate" is one of your axioms, then it's intellectually dishonest to provide some supposed piece of evidence that supports this claim (e.g. supposed missing links in the fossil record), because by definition 1) no evidence is necessary to support an axiomatic claim and 2) no evidence or explanation can possibly change your mind.
- cma 6y agoWhy would some point of existence or meaning lead specifically to Christianity?
- isaachier 6y agoIt doesn't. But trying to convince them to abandon Christian literalism would require an alternative that satisfies this need for purpose.
- dsr_ 6y agoBecause they come to the discussion wearing a filter that tells them that some things are Truth and other things are Heresy: notably, that stories from their culture are True and cannot even be compared to stories from other cultures, because that is Heresy.
- lisper 6y agoThat is a very good question, and the answer is very long, much too long for an HN comment. But there IS an answer. (There is of course an answer for all other religions as well.)
- rhn_mk1 6y agoDon't leave us hanging! Where can we learn the answer?
- lisper 6y agoAny Christian apologetics web site. Or your local church.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoI was hoping for something more precise tbh. Christian apologetics web sites and local churches also offer answers to lots of questions I don't care about, so if you already sifted through them, I was hoping you could share that advantage with the broader public.
- Jtsummers 6y agoIn a different fashion, I found myself physically surrounded by YECs at a job many years ago. It was a surreal experience. They definitely aren't idiots, many were among the best I've seen at technical work. But like you said in (2), they start with different assumptions. Their logic is totally sound if you agree with the assumptions. I spent some time reading and watching YEC material to have a better understanding of their positions. While there were certainly some really stupid arguments, most were sound but based on either an assumption of the existence of God (unprovable either way) and some implications of that, or a flawed understanding of physics/chemistry/biology. The latter were the only arguments that could be refuted because they were the only ones where you could point out the specific flaw in reasoning. Until you find the difference in assumptions, you can't effectively argue against their position. And, then, only by talking about the assumptions and not the conclusions/implications.
- kmnc 6y agoSo, they are idiots. If no logic can change their minds then isn’t dismissing them as idiots the best course of action?
- lisper 6y agoYou have completely missed the point. Their argument is logical. It just starts from a different foundational assumption.
- erdos4d 6y agoIn math we have an proof technique called reductio ad absurdum that deals with this situation. They seem to be doing it wrong though, because they don't reject the faulty hypothesis after the conclusion is logically inconsistent with reality.
- lisper 6y agoI can apply the same argument to science: all of the laws of physics are symmetric with respect to time and space. But all of the data I have direct access to comes to me from a privileged frame of reference that I call "here and now". Therefore, all of this data is in direct conflict with physics, and so physics must be wrong.
- Rury 6y agoEverything starts with an assumption. However, in science, if the assumption's conclusion doesn't match the observed evidence, we reject our assumption as true, and we start with a new assumption. As so, science doesn't have a "foundational" assumption (because it's willing to change its assumptions). Rather, science subjects assumptions to evidence - not the other way around...
- lisper 6y ago> science doesn't have a "foundational" assumption Yes, it does: it assumes that evidence is a reliable guide to truth.
- GijsjanB 6y agoIt's fine to come up with some magician who created our world and is looking at us through his/her terrarium, if that makes you feel warm and cosy. It's a whole other level to claim the world is flat and/or just a couple of thousand yours old. Than you're just an idiot.
- renox 6y agoI'm not sure there is really a big difference if you accept this magician then you usually also accept impossible things..
- Folcon 6y agoSo the appropriate argument is to ask why we shouldn't be sun worshipers instead?
- Folcon 6y agoIt seems my short statement has been taken by some to be flippant rather than serious, it's not. In history there have been thousands of religions with various beliefs, many of which ascribed purpose to the actions of believers which was considered significant how specifically does the purpose given to those who follow Christianity provide "a logically defensible line of reasoning that leads you to Christianity and thence to the inerrancy of the Bible" over any one of those other religions? And if every religion gains equal weight then why not follow all of them equally using that same rationale? I mean I don't particularly care what people believe, but that's a pretty strong statement.
- DjiboutiJon 6y agoYou put into very readable language what I have felt to be true for some time. What I appreciate about your comment also is you mention the necessity to understand their presuppositions and reason that way (at least sometimes). I feel like the issue with many discourses going on right now is a lack of good faith understanding of the other "sides" presuppositions. And yet, it can be so painful for someone to even pretend they can identify with the following belief for example this belief > So if science leads you to the conclusion that life has no transcendent purpose (and it does) then, on their world-view, science must be wrong, full stop The much easier tact for lets say a standard pro-science metropolitan is to decide the YEC-er person actually knows what is "true" (e.g. what the metropolitan thinks is obvious) but is actively choosing to do wrong. Then you can refute their point as purposely provoking _and_ also put them in the "bad people" box with one little mental facade. I'm not trying to build a purposely weak example of either group, I think all humans have a simplifying mechanism when it comes to viewpoints/ideas and that we need that to survive in some sense- and that we do it all the time probably in benign ways. But acknowledging what other people believe is a great skill to build I think.
- Spellman 6y agoThis gets to one of the big issues. A lot of these beliefs arise from very fundamental axioms of belief that only show up through these high-order belief systems. If you fundamentally believe you should follow the evidence no matter what and THAT is the highest priority of your belief, then you are (more likely) going to fall into the camps of hard science and nothing but the science. Or perhaps in a different vein, do you fundamentally believe you are a good person fighting evil? Then anyone who disagrees is THE ENEMY and must be DESTROYED. And not only are they doing bad things, but they are fundamentally BAD PEOPLE. They're not just baby killers, they're Satanic Baby Killers. Of course, we are all a vibrant mix of these beliefs, and some may change over time with enough exposure. And many often hold beliefs counter to other base axioms and a careful walk may help expose and nudge their higher-order beliefs. But recognizing that it isn't just about Evolution or just about the world being flat, it's actually built on layers and layers of logic from very low-fundamental beliefs is key. Because even if you prune some of the top facts, the base layers will remain, and they'll adapt to stay aligned with their core beliefs.
- erdos4d 6y agoI just don't get this at all. Could you explain how they refute things like ISS camera footage showing a clearly round earth with the station going around it? Are you saying that they just refute science outright because it conflicts with their teleology beliefs? If that is the case, they actually are idiots, regardless of how erudite their arguments may be.
- cupofinsane 6y agoThey say it's CGI and dismiss it
- burlesona 6y agoYoung Earth Creationism isn’t the same as Flat Earth. An argument I’ve heard before is that God made the universe relatively recently (10k years ago or so) but with the appearance of age. Something like God “fast forwarded” through time to skip to the part where humans started recording history. In that theory both the majority of modern science and a strangely literal interpretation of the Bible can both be true at the same time. The scientists are unable to measure that God “fast-forwarded” the universe because he didn’t leave any evidence of it. In my experience the majority of Christians don’t hold that view, but instead see Genesis as metaphorical, and thus it actually fits in rather well with the current Big Bang model. So well, in fact, that early on a lot of scientists rejected the Big Bang as “creationist rubbish.”
- brightball 6y agoInerrancy is a whole other bag of chips. I teach a Sunday School class and one of my big topics is man made rules that aren’t Biblically supported. Inerrancy falls in that camp from my reading. There’s a single verse that the basis for the entire doctrine. 2 Timothy 3:16-17 “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness, so that the servant of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work.” This verse is interpreted to mean that it is inerrant. There’s a wide gap between inerrant and useful for teaching from my own reading. There are many people wiser than me who disagree on the subject. My own interpretation is simply that Jesus constantly spoke in metaphor because it was more useful for teaching. Why would we assume that the creation of everything, that involves so many intricate details, would be any different? Would we expect books on microbiology and geology to accompany Genesis? Of course not. Genesis, Revelation and Job are 3 books of the Bible that don’t document events as observed. I believe (not 100%) that all the rest do. Bookenders as I call them, people who only want to argue about Genesis and Revelation, are a concern because they take away from the real message to pursue an argument that nobody can win. It’s not productive and it’s not useful. If everyone was convinced that the earth was or wasn’t 6,000 years old tomorrow it wouldn’t change a single facet of life on earth for anyone. It would only remove one argument. IMO, that makes it a pointless subject to debate and only creates friction. Romans 14 is pretty clear about this too. https://www.biblehub.com/niv/romans/14.htm https://www.biblehub.com/niv/romans/14.htm
- CodeAndCuffs 6y agoYou may enjoy some of Pete Enns' books. Namely "The Bible Tells Me So", Which dives into biblical inaccuracy head first. It's not a "Oh well, if you apply some mental gymnast it's okay" book. It's "Here's a bunch of reasons inerrancy makes zero sense and here is why that's okay and doesn't mean God isn't real".
- Kednicma 6y agoYou may be interested in a detailed breakdown of authorship of various parts of the Bible [0]. In summary, to a first approximation, only the books written during the Babylonian Exile and during the preaching of Peter and Paul were written during the events that they describe, and most other books were written much later. The Gospels are decades after Jesus' life and death, and all of the Bronze Age stories are set centuries before they were recorded. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authorship_of_the_Bible https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authorship_of_the_Bible
- natcombs 6y agoYEC is not closely related to Flat earthers. I know many YEC that refute flat earth theory completely. The overlap of the two is small, but maybe there are a few outspoken ones on Reddit (it’s always the outspoken ones isn’t it?)
- Covzire 6y agoJust a hunch, but I think the correlation of flat earthers to schizophrenia is a thousand times stronger than any other.
- lisper 6y agoThey are more closely related than you think. Flat-earth is actually a natural conclusion from the assumption of Biblical inerrancy (e.g. 1Sm2:8, Mat4:8, Isa11:12).
- simplify 6y ago> So if science leads you to the conclusion that life has no transcendent purpose (and it does) How does it lead to that? I feel like that's a false assumption that many people make, religious or not.
- lisper 6y agoDo you have a theory of purpose that is consistent with the laws of physics? Because that would be a major breakthrough. All of the evidence (AFAICT) indicates that nature is utterly indifferent to our existence.
- simplify 6y agoNature may be indifferent to our existence, but we are not indifferent to nature. How is this?
- llimos 6y agoScience leads you to the conclusion that we are here as the result of a series of chance events. Not because of any "decision" to put us here. If we're all just here by fluke, and when we're gone we're gone entirely and completely, what transcendence could there be?
- giomasce 6y agoHow does science exclude the possibility of a decision to put us here? It seems to me that science (paired with a good bunch of epistemological assumptions) gives us the laws our universe follows. But as for why such laws are like that, or who possibly decided them and with which purpose, I'd say such questions do not even make sense for science.
- simplify 6y agoScience can only "lead" you to that conclusion if you already think in specific philosophical ways. In this case it sounds like you are presuming materialism.
- jfengel 6y agoI can't really find any word for "No amount of data is going to persuade them otherwise." than "idiot". They may be able to constrain their idiocy to certain domains -- after all the early history of the planet (whether 5,000 or 5 billion years ago) has no real effect on your daily life. But in my experience, it nonetheless creeps out to affect other areas of their life. YECs are often afflicted with other conspiracy theories, not just flat earthers but also climate denialsm, and these days, COVID denialism. I find that the assumption isn't so much the teleology as the group superiority. It's not so much that the Bible is inerrant as that they are the ones who hold the truth, and those who disagree must in all cases be wrong -- and not merely wrong, but out to get them. The appeal to teleology is more about literal divine right, that "God shed his grace on thee". That leads them to make alliance with those who don't accept young-earth creationism but nonetheless share their nationalistic, chauvinist, xenophobic aims.
- lisper 6y ago> I can't really find any word for "No amount of data is going to persuade them otherwise." than "idiot". That's because you find the data persuasive. They don't. That in and of itself does not make them idiots.
- jfengel 6y agoIt's not just that I find the data persuasive, but that I find data persuasive. They don't. They reject the notion of data when it doesn't suit them. That makes them not merely wrong, but dangerous to me. They will go out of their way to make my life worse, without being able to judge the cost to themselves. Regardless of what derogatory name I choose to call it, our outlook is fundamentally at odds. They've shown repeatedly that they wish to use it to harm me, and my names for them are going to be negative.
- lisper 6y agoLook, I'm on your side. I agree that YECs are both wrong and dangerous. My point here is that you cannot effectively oppose them on those grounds. They believe that you are wrong and dangerous, so the situation is symmetric. A mere belief that the opposition is wrong and dangerous cannot prevail on its own.
- shkkmo 6y agoWell, epistemologically, there is a big difference between YEC and flat-earth. Flat earth can be confidently debunked in quite a large number of ways, including direct experience. YEC is, at its core, fundementally undisprovable. There really no way to prove that the universe wasn't recently created by some force with a consistent apparent history. Indeed, there are philosophers who have made strong arguments that we live in a simulation which makes such a "created with history" scenario seem more plausible. > If you accept this premise, then there is actually a logically defensible line of reasoning that leads you to Christianity I rather doubt that. You may be able to show that some of these beliefs are logically consistent given that premise, but that is a far cry from showing that they are logically derivable from that premise as you seem to be saying. I do think there is data that will persuade these people, but nobody is willing to out the time and effort in to do so. (Since these are quite divergent beliefs, any education program would probably need to be customized on a per person basis.)
- Kednicma 6y agoThis is part of why I go directly for discrediting the Bible as part of my refutation. There's no point in letting folks shelter themselves behind the delusion that the Bible is historically accurate enough to be useful for scientific predictions. We should be willing to crack open those religious beliefs, and not let them hide behind some sort of special motte-and-bailey construction just for the sole purpose of making bogus historical/cosmological/etc. claims.
- hhas01 6y ago“convincing-sounding arguments” Maybe to people who don’t know any better. To anyone with basic knowledge of the subject and crib notes on common logical fallacies, not so much. I mean, the ancient Greeks figured out the Earth was spherical over 2000 years ago. Good grief; Eratosthenes even worked out its approximate circumference with nothing but a road atlas and a twig! So if flat Earthers can’t even bring themselves to reproduce that ancient experiment themselves, it’s only because they don’t want to see the answer. Frankly, it’s more useful to dissect the reasons why such people retain and defend such beliefs in the face of openly available evidence. And dollars to donuts you’ll find a manipulatively dishonest, self-serving paranoid narcisissm at heart: that consuming need to believe themselves powerful and clever, and in Control. As Francis Bacon once observed: Knowledge itself is Power. He did not specify that it had to be right. And that’s ultimately all it’s about. Just one more Means to Power. As thinking creatures go, they are all so very flat and squalid. (See also Moon Hoaxers, 911 Truthers, Qanoners, and every other ego-masturbating skinsack of Fail that wastes their all-too-brief potential to be anything greater than just a future worm’s dinner.)
- paulryanrogers 6y agoAt one time I flirted with the YEC point of view as a Christian. What helped me change both (I'm an atheist now) was exposure to more points of view and modest experiments applying biblical teachings personally. After years of twisting logic I could no longer justify the magical thinking. Because none of the experiments were convincing. (Don't forget that God can't be tested! Except when it comes to donating to his chosen leaders.) And within the Christian communities I saw so much harm from the various biases and non-critical methods it was heart breaking. Sadly it can still be hard to leave when you're taught you're choosing pleasure, hell fire, selfishness, and abandoning absolute truth and love.
- BrandoElFollito 6y ago> one of the reasons that the secular world is having such a hard time effectively resisting these movements It depends on the country. These movements are non - existant in France for instance. When we hear of them or is usually about the ones in the US (I do not think I heard about another country). When we hear of them it is because something happened (the death of one of the leaders who blew up in his rocket IIRC), never because we have a hard time resisting them. Out of curiosity I search in French for flat earth. All the hits are about the US (and sometimes UK) based movement. This is the same for the young earth one, and creationism generally speaking. But fear not, we have homeopathy as a national sport (and plenty of other alternative "medicine", taken seriously here)
- lisper 6y ago> These movements are non - existant in France I think they exist but just have a different flavor. In the U.S. we have Christian extremists, in France you have Muslim extremists.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoSure, there are religious extremists (and we painfully felt it ove the terrorist attacks). I was talking about either flat earth, or the idea that earth is young. These are concepts which are completely foreign to France and not even carried by the religious extremists (maybe someone is telling this, but they have zero traction). Specifically, I was commenting on > one of the reasons that the secular world is having such a hard time effectively resisting these movements