3 ms·
Can someone tell me how these large financial transfers work, and why there isn't a time period when the money can be returned? I think an error of this magnitu
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Can someone tell me how these large financial transfers work, and why there isn't a time period when the money can be returned? I think an error of this magnitude would have been recognized almost immediately, no?
I mean, if someone does an ACH transfer into my bank account, it can 'clear', but it can still be revoked days later if there was something wrong with the transaction. Indeed, this was the basis for a bunch of "Nigerian Prince" scams where scammers would send money to someone's account, that person would see it 'cleared', then they'd send some larger amount of money to the Nigerian Prince, after which the original deposit was revoked, and the bank account holder was on the hook for the now (usually large) negative balance.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoIt depends. Given the amounts involved, it is unlikely that ACH was used. With wire transfers, the basic rule is 'once it is out, it is out'. You may be able to get money back by communicating with recipient and by sending a request for the funds back, but they do not have to honor it. Recipient's back will basically ask the recipient if they agree to the return, and if they don't, that is the end of the story. That is basically why CITI was forced to sue. Other recipients played nice. That one recipient did not. edit: There may be some leeway if there is fraud involved, but even then it is more along the lines of bank freezing the funds than about sending them back.
- avianlyric 6y agoThere are many different payment scheme out there, which all have different parameters. ACH is someone unique in that money can just be pulled back, and even in transactions that take a long time to clear, doesn’t mean that you can cancel them. Clearing time is usually caused by multiple sequential systems at multiple institutions taking their time do something. But once Citi started the transaction, and their system send the payment messages they probably couldn’t retract the payment. Once the first payment message was sent it immediately created a liability on Citi for the money (either to the payment scheme or the receiving bank), at that point actually moving the money becomes a bit academic, an unbreakable promise has already been made.