2 ms·
On the other hand we have no direct evidence for Inflation and no idea what the Inflaton field is, what causes it or where it went. Yes I know the theory makes
by simonh 6y ago
On the other hand we have no direct evidence for Inflation and no idea what the Inflaton field is, what causes it or where it went. Yes I know the theory makes some predictions that have turned out to be correct, but if there are other theories that can also predict the same outcomes they deserve a hearing.
I don't think there's anything dogmatic about keeping an open mind. If you want to see dogma at work, see a reply to another comment of mine here where I'm ranted at about what is or isn't 'Scientific' and questions being 'non-scientific' simply for pointing out that the Big Bang isn't a complete model of the origin of the universe.
There are a lot of unanswered questions in this area and it's far from clear to me at least how they will be resolved, but I'm very excited to find out. I just don't think mud slinging about dogma and being non-scientific is going to help with that.
- ziotom78 6y ago> Yes I know the theory makes some predictions that have turned out to be correct However, I must say that once P. Steinhardt gave a seminar in my department, and he debunked two famous "predictions" of the inflationary theory (flat universe, scalar index n_s slightly less than ne) showing that papers published in the 90s claimed that inflation predicted "naturally" an open universe with a scalar index larger than one [1]. He used this to stress the fact that inflation can predict almost everything. I must say he sounded very convincing, he wasn't claiming that inflation is false, only that it is far from being a well-established theory, and that other hypotheses must be considered as well. [1] http://physics.princeton.edu/~cosmo/sciam/index.html#facts http://physics.princeton.edu/~cosmo/sciam/index.html#facts