3 ms·
For the hundredth time, "popular vote" doesn't matter in the US system. And that's a feature, not a bug.
by refurb 6y ago
For the hundredth time, "popular vote" doesn't matter in the US system. And that's a feature, not a bug.
- pessimizer 6y ago"The popular vote" is another tactic in the PR competition between Democrats and Republicans to declare every election that the other party won illegitimate. Has a predictable effect on the general public's confidence in US democracy. It also encourages decisions like overcampaigning in California as a result of last minute polling in Wisconsin and Michigan looking like a coin toss. A loss is bad, but a loss that can't be marketed as illegitimate afterwards is far worse.
- 082349872349872 6y agoI am always amazed that the US will get into the decimal points of invalid mail voting when the whole one-person-some-weighting-of-vote electoral college is staring them in the face. I guess the elephant in the room must be too large? (To be fair, yes, getting the slave states on board a few centuries back required it. Legacy code probably wouldn't be there if it hadn't done something at one point.)
- TallGuyShort 6y agoThe Connecticut Compromise had to do with getting small states on board with the union, so their sovereignty wouldn't just be overpowered by population centers. I think you're thinking of the 3/5 compromise which doesn't have much to do with the electoral college vs direct voting. It's just plain partial-disenfranchisement of blacks.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> For the hundredth time, "popular vote" doesn't matter in the US system It does matter to claims of breadth of appeal, whether or not it matters elsewhere. (It's true, breadth of appeal isn't as important in the US, if you have the right narrow appeal, than it would be in a representative democracy, but the claim.made was about breadth of appeal.) Insofar as Presidents have limited formal power and their informal power is at least as important, and is based in no small part on the perception of a democratic mandate (because whether the formal processes of the US system are democratic or not, democratic values are widespread in US culture), it actually can matter. > And that's a feature, not a bug. Well, it was designed in; whether it's a positive feature or a misfeatures depends on what you value. If you value the systematic disenfranchisement that the electoral college system rewards, the racial repression that it and the Senate structure which underlies it was designed to protect (and still does, though in somewhat less odious form than it originally did), and the idea of structurally promoting tyranny of a particular minority, then, sure, it's a positive feature.
- refurb 6y agoThis is all subjective. The point is, under our system, Trump won the presidency. Any other claim of legitimacy is just sour grapes. I guarantee the same people making this claim would be silent if it was their party who had won. And the Electoral College was an effort to not have the small state dominated by the large ones. That seems like a positive feature, even today.