4 ms·
It seems like the right balance. As the author says: > As a Mac developer, it's nearly impossible to run a viable software business when this is the first-run
by ryandrake 6y ago
It seems like the right balance. As the author says:
> As a Mac developer, it's nearly impossible to run a viable software business when this is the first-run experience of new customers. You'll never get any new customers! This is why every Mac developer I know signs up for Developer ID and ships only signed, notarized apps. It would be financial suicide to do otherwise.
If you have hung your shingle out to make a profit, then the developer account, signing, notarizing, etc. is a cost of doing business, and you can easily justify it. The more customers you get, the more money you get, so you are motivated to reduce the first-run friction.
If you are not in it for profit, you probably have a lot more tolerance for a little first-run friction, and having users drop out of the funnel. Fewer users does not affect you financially. As a hobbyist programmer, I wouldn't care. I'm just releasing a program--not looking to dominate a market.
- lucb1e 6y ago> the developer account, signing, notarizing, etc. is a cost of doing business, and you can easily justify it. But what if I'm not doing this for profit? Can Nirsoft or Mozilla apply for a waiver? Can I? We may not be looking to dominate the market, but it would be a shame if our work just went to waste because people would rather pay for something crappier that is closed source rather than our free (as in freedom & beer) software. (Yes, Mozilla is a huge project where it isn't worth employee's time to apply for a waiver, I just needed at least one name that people know is a non-profit software developer as an example.)
- KeepFlying 6y agoI appreciate this view except for the last point. As a hobbyist programmer, I am not "just releasing a program". I am usually "helping solve user's problems". And if my solution requires users to go through even more problems before they can use my tools, that's problematic. I don't need to many money on my side projects. I do, however, want to help people. If I can't help people on a Mac because of the install friction, then it isn't worth my effort to create a MacOS port of my software at all.
- saagarjha 6y agoI would generally like my open-source software not not be marked as malware.
- badsectoracula 6y agoI would generally like my software, regardless of it is open source or not, not be marked as malware when it is not malware.
- saagarjha 6y agoSure, but I picked that specifically because it seemed to be what the parent comment was talking about.
- coldtea 6y agoIs there any automatic way to tell your software apart from malware? Because that's part of what this mechanism tries to provide...
- saagarjha 6y agoIn theory no, that's impossible. In practice, I publish checksums on my website and people trust that I am not malicious.
- FabHK 6y agoThe thing is, your friendly scammer could also publish checksums on their website. It is clear to you that you're writing fine open source software, not malware. But how is the consumer supposed to tell? If people trust you, why bother with the checksums? (Over HTTPS, the downloaded content cannot be tampered with. If someone tampered with the content on your website, or performs a MITM, they can also replace the checksums.)
- saagarjha 6y ago