11 ms·
Any UBI could be entirely reversed by an equal and opposite tax. Of course this would be pointless, but it shows that there are many possibilities, depending on
by skybrian 6y ago
Any UBI could be entirely reversed by an equal and opposite tax. Of course this would be pointless, but it shows that there are many possibilities, depending on what sort of taxes you combine it with, and some of them are certainly feasible because the net effect is small.
UBI is largely about symbolic equality, the kindergarten-level fairness of everyone getting the same amount. That’s important because symbols of equality are important. But from an economics standpoint it’s not a complete plan, and it’s a bit nebulous because the choice of which taxes to include in your analysis is arbitrary.
Assuming a progressive tax system, though, it does mean automatic benefits for people without other income and more financial security for almost everyone, assuming you think you have some risk of losing your job.
This is similar to insurance. We don’t buy it because we think we will make money on average.
- adamsea 6y ago> But from an economics standpoint it’s not a complete plan ... I don't know much about the economics. Curious, how so? > UBI is largely about symbolic equality, the kindergarten-level fairness of everyone getting the same amount. That’s important because symbols of equality are important. IMHO, what you described is justice. Equality. Not kindergarten-level, or, rather, I guess it is, in the sense of it being fundamental to our moral understanding : ).
- skybrian 6y ago“In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread.” Most apparently-equal rules aren’t actually equal in their effects. Charging everyone the same amount usually hurts poor people more. UBI is one of the few apparently-equal policies that would likely help the poor more than the rich.
- mason55 6y ago> In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread. Yes and on top of the obvious absurdity of this statement, there is a second level. As long as we punish things with fines they are effectively legal if you're rich enough.
- mamon 6y agoWhich kind of makes sense, because wealth is supposed to be a measure of one's contribution to society. You contributed more, you can get away with more.
- dane-pgp 6y ago> wealth is supposed to be a measure of one's contribution to society That principle is only relevant in societies that don't have lotteries or inheritance, among other changes.
- adamsea 6y ago> wealth is supposed to be a measure of one's contribution to society Curious where that idea comes from - source? Haven't encountered it. I know that many people _think_ that, or _feel_ that way, but I haven't read anything (philosophy, political philosophy, etc), that actually theorizes it _should_ be that way, or that it really _is_ that way. Tim Berners-Lee -- how much money does he have, and what is his contribution to society? Or, the classic kindergarten teacher vs NBA player, etc.
- tom-_- 6y agoI believe what commenter is suggesting is that the notion of "fairness" provided by UBI is too simplistic and easily fails to uphold that principle under any amount of scrutiny. By simply asking the question "Who will pay for UBI and who will receive it", the degree to which it's "fair", "just", or "equal" becomes obviously nebulous
- rorykoehler 6y ago"Who will pay for corporate profits and who will receive it", the degree to which it's "fair", "just", or "equal" becomes obviously nebulous
- adamsea 6y agoI didn't know UBI had anything to do with fair ... I thought it was a hopefully-pragmatic approach for creating a just and healthy society in our current era. Whether it'll work or not, I know that's a larger question. Also, I think it'd be more helpful if you would lead with what notion of fairness (why put it in quotes?) you yourself believe UBI represents. Because it's possible that some people may agree with you, and others may not. And that would be a good starting point for discussion.
- baconandeggs 6y agoAnd that is why it will fail. Fairness is not about everyone getting the same amount just for existing, for that in itself is not fair. Real fairness is everyone playing against the same rules and being treated the same under the law. Sadly governments and politicians are too corrupt to implement real fairness and have decided instead for the populist way out while keeping their insane advantage intact.
- Fargren 6y agoReal fairness under that definition can't exist as long as there are inheritances. People who are born in wealthier families are not playing under the same rules (just imagine if a person playing Monopoly started with ten times the initial amount of money). I prefer a definition of fairness that is actually achievable[1]: everyone has at least the bare minimum, regardless of fitness and deserving. You can quibble about what the definition of bare minimum, but to me it should include housing, food, education and health. Any society where anyone can't get those things by asking for them is not fair, as people who don't have access to those don't have the minimum to compete with those who do. We can't have an equal playing field. But we can perhaps make the bare minimum livable. [1]This is almost impossible, as opposed to entirely impossible
- gremlinsinc 6y agoI can't see our modern society lasting without this. Not much longer. Not after covid, and whatever 2020's throw at us, and global warming. Food riots, and real civil discord are only months away, if not weeks.
- vorpalhex 6y agoThat's alarmist and unfounded. The economy has recovered heartily, in general civil discord has gone away in most areas, and grocery stores aren't running out of food or going insane with prices - I'm still sipping fancy kombucha at the same rate I paid a year ago. More people are concerned about whether their uber eats driver is going to show up on time than food riots at the moment. I don't see that changing in the immediate future.
- sdenton4 6y agoIt's not about fairness at all: it's about poverty traps, and getting people out of them. With the learned understanding that if you give things to the poor, you also have to give them to the rich, because the rich are unable to look at any pie they can't have a slice of without wanting to destroy it.
- brazzy 6y agoI always saw the "also giving it to the rich" as much more about avoiding the bureaucratic overhead, social stigma and other associated downsides of trying to ensure that only the poor get it.
- dorgo 6y agoAnd the rich are so few that you wouldn't save much by exlucding them.
- Taek 6y agoThat's the thing. Not very expensive to also give money to the rich, and also there are extenuating circumstances. I know multiple people who had no jobs and no savings yet didn't qualify for covid checks from the US because they had high paying jobs in 2018. If you just pay everyone, wealth still disproportionately moves towards the poor.
- ramblerman 6y agoThis, and also the removal of welfare. Since you lose welfare when you get a job often there is an opportunity cost decision, should I really work 40 hours a week to make a little more than welfare. with UBI the salary is always additional.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoAye to take it a step further: there is a professor at UCSD who pushes for UBI Libertarianism, for that reason. Don't add conditions or requirements, just mail everyone a check and ditch all of the bureaucracy, EBT, etc. The problem is that it makes poverty traps smaller, but doesn't make them go away. Like, if Johnny Hobo isn't able to feed his kids and blows his welfare on smokes and 40s, UBI isn't going to magically make him a better father or better at spending his money, he's just going to buy better booze.
- totony 6y agoTax doesn't help if you make no money though? If you make below poverty line, UBI helps you, whereas progressive tax doesn't