4 ms·
The FDA should be able to certify drugs as safe, effective, etc. They shouldn't be able to ban drugs for not being that. Helmets in America don't have to be CPS
by renewiltord 6y ago
The FDA should be able to certify drugs as safe, effective, etc. They shouldn't be able to ban drugs for not being that. Helmets in America don't have to be CPSC certified and that's fine. You can choose to buy an uncertified helmet if you want.
Certification is good. But uncertified drugs have their place.
- sithadmin 6y agoWhat you are suggesting is completely mad. The average US citizen cannot be expected to have a nuanced enough understanding of pharmacology to make informed decisions about the safety and efficacy of drugs. Even trained and licensed physicians often have difficulties making such decisions in non-mundane situations, and rely heavily upon their pharmacy colleagues (either by way of consulting practice-specific literature, or actually consulting with a qualified pharmacist) to assist with making determinations about what would be safe and effective to administer.
- renewiltord 6y agoThey don't have to. They can stick to the pharmacists and all that. If you want me to take a test to demonstrate that I am of sound mind and should be released of my restrictions, that's fine. If you want me to post money so you can afford to bury my body, that's also fine. But release me from the bonds that bind "the average US citizen".
- sithadmin 6y ago>They can stick to the pharmacists and all that. Again, your position is absurd. Individual pharmacists of the type that serve the average person most often (retail pharmacists) are not equipped or trained to be the gatekeepers deciding which products are safe and effective. Putting that sort of risk and power into the hands of pharmacists will necessarily result in a need for cooperation on de facto standards that will only result in strengthening cartels like the American Pharmacists Association, which are already anti-consumer enough as it is. >release me from the bonds that bind "the average US citizen". Well...that definitely vibes with the incoherent disestablishmentarianist approach you seem to be promoting, I guess.
- renewiltord 6y ago> > me: The FDA should be able to certify drugs as safe, effective, etc. > you: Individual pharmacists of the type that serve the average person most often (retail pharmacists) are not equipped or trained to be the gatekeepers deciding which products are safe and effective. I find your response stupefying since it seems to be responding to things I'm not saying... > > Well...that definitely vibes with the incoherent disestablishmentarianist approach you seem to be promoting, I guess. Hahaha, beautiful.
- sithadmin 6y agoI'm directly responding to your (insane) line of argumentation: You're arguing that medications that have not passed regulatory requirements for safety or efficacy should be sold to consumers, and that they can simply rely on retail pharmacists or the like as a stand in for the FDA's approval process.
- renewiltord 6y agoInteresting. Perhaps my English isn't that good. Please re-write "The FDA should be able to certify drugs as safe, effective, etc." in the way you understand it. In this universe, you can just get an FDA-certified thing. No stand-in required. > You're arguing that medications that have not passed regulatory requirements for safety or efficacy should be sold to consumers, and that they can simply rely on retail pharmacists or the like as a stand in for the FDA's approval process. No. No gatekeepers. The standard is you buy FDA drugs from pharmacists. If you don't want to, you don't, you buy it from who will sell it and you're on your own. It's the escape hatch. Just like you can buy non-Snell-certified helmets.
- skyfaller 6y agoDo they? The distinction may be lost on consumers, and if an uncertified drug harms people or fails to work and they die before further methods can be tried, it may harm people's trust in the medical system as a whole, causing them to turn to snake oil treatments with even less of a scientific foundation / vetting for harmfulness. If snake oil can kill Steve Jobs, don't think you and your loved ones are immune.
- renewiltord 6y agoI don't think I'm immune. I don't think the ones I love are immune. But for myself (and them) I'm willing to take the risk. If you want me to take a test, so be it. If you want me to post a $100k bond so be it. It's not like there's universal healthcare anyway so my costs to you are upper bound.
- sithadmin 6y ago> But for myself (and them) I'm willing to take the risk I truly don't think you have the education, training, or exposure to the field to actually make an informed judgment about what such risks would be. This isn't an insult to you, it's simply a fact of life: We can't all be subject matter experts in all things. This is precisely why regulatory apparatuses, licensure for the practice of certain disciplines, and product safety standards exist.
- renewiltord 6y agoAh, but there lies the rub. The regulators don't have the education, training, or exposure either. And crucially, they don't have access to my risk tolerance. This is most obvious in anti-mask rhetoric from the top public health service in America but also is common in that regulators are safetyists. They will let a million die so that not one will die by their hands. That's okay for them, but not so much for me.
- sithadmin 6y ago>The regulators don't have the education, training, or exposure either. Again, you clearly have no understanding of what the FDA approval process actually entails.
- curryst 6y agoThere are 2 reasons that's a bad idea. The first is the obvious; people will harm themselves. How many people would have taken hydroxychloroquine when that was the Covid rage, despite the limited effectiveness and severe complications? The second is that we still allow advertising on medications. How many people would get duped by ads for things that they don't need? How many hundreds of uncertified "Covid cures" would be making the rounds on Facebook and TV ads? I'm sure they'll all have wonderful test results, based on fundamentally flawed studies that are largely illegible to your average person.