3 ms·
Requiring strict adherence to arbitrary bureaucratic norms, and particularly berating someone for daring to question them, is absolutely abusive. An awful lot
by danaris 6y ago
Requiring strict adherence to arbitrary bureaucratic norms, and particularly berating someone for daring to question them, is absolutely abusive.
An awful lot of corporate culture is abusive, and designed primarily to give managers a warm fuzzy feeling of absolute control over their subordinates. Much of it derives directly from the assembly-line era, and much of the overall philosophy behind it is just thinly-veiled feudalism.
"But everyone does it this way" is not a valid defense against "this behaviour is abusive and designed to squeeze the agency and will to be more than a drone out of me."
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoAnd there we differ I guess. The job is the job. Wear this; show up then; answer the phone with that phrase - its the job. Do it, and get paid. Not abuse.
- grugagag 6y agoBecause the boss makes the rules and you should blindly follow them. The other team's boss is relaxed with these rules and the team is productive and happy but, you should still not question your boss, always put the head down and say I am sorry, always stay in late without overtime because the boss hasn't left the office yet and so on. And it doesn't matter that the boss doesn't produce anything and that you drive all the work, respect the boss because he might feel offended otherwise.
- prepend 6y agoI don’t think bosses should be followed blindly. But showing up and doing the job as required isn’t blindly following, it’s obeying. I think the difference in what is reasonable and what is reasonable. If I question a reasonable start time “9am” that makes me someone that few want to work with. Whereas questioning forced, unpaid overtime is an entirely different, and I think reasonable question.
- prepend 6y agoI guess they aren’t alone in their opinions then. Reasonable rules like “be here by 9am” are not emotionally abusive to enforce. Perhaps you feel that way, but I think that’s unreasonable and will result in tons of emotional abuse as you go through the world. Is a stop light emotionally abusive? Is not paying me $100k emotionally abusive? I’m glad that we’re not actually under feudalism, but I think employment is not feudalism.
- danaris 6y agoStop lights (which maintain a safe flow of traffic) and not paying arbitrary people arbitrarily high sums of money, are not meaningfully comparable to enforcing a single, inflexible schedule on all employees regardless of their work or personal circumstances. If there is no actual business purpose for it—beyond "I'm the boss and I want it that way"—then why shouldn't the boss be compassionate, and allow flexibility? Meetings with coworkers, as we've seen in the past few months, can work just fine being scheduled at times that actually work for everyone, rather than expecting everyone to be constantly available (and thus never able to truly focus on their actual work).