4 ms·
I work in robotics. The problem for pretty much everything is one of scale and commercialization. Every one of these issues has been addressed, but almost none
by mchusma 6y ago
I work in robotics. The problem for pretty much everything is one of scale and commercialization. Every one of these issues has been addressed, but almost none have a good and bundled solution.
It feels like computers in the 70s. All the pieces are there but there aren't mass produced PCs yet somewhat because there aren't the suppliers to make things easier.
This is changing fast.
For example, SLAM has many things that work, but they require fine tuning, and most contain undocumented features that require reading the source to find. Slamcore is a company working on this, I hope there are more.
Teleportation was "possible but hard", but Freedom Robotics has a good solution now that mostly "just works"
Robotic bases work well, but they will ship them to you without things plugged in so you have to find the issue and fix it yourself. AWS Deepracer is clearly a prototype for a solid wheeled base. The documentation and build quality is an order of magnitude higher than anything else in the space. My guess is they launch it as a useful base in the next year or so.
Depth estimation is pretty good with Intel Realsense now, and the new OpenCV OAK is another attempt here. I think this is more solved and packaged than anything else.
ROS2 was only properly released in June 2020, and it is a huge step up from ROS1 for commercial applications. It probably needs another 1-2 years for the community to finalize supporting it.
I think for founders finding known robotic solutions and making them into robust commercial products is a great space to work in.
The next few years are very interesting in this space, as even 1 year ago everything was much harder and it's rapidly getting easier.
- MereInterest 6y ago> Teleportation was "possible but hard", but Freedom Robotics has a good solution now that mostly "just works" For somebody not in robotics, what does "teleportation" mean in this context. I assume that it doesn't mean the Star Trek style beaming that comes up from a Google search.
- rocketflumes 6y agoI think OP meant "teleoperation" - controlling a robot from afar
- mchusma 6y ago*yes, teleoperation (autocorrect).
- MichaelRazum 6y agoWhat do you think about RL learning approaches? Just wondering if that stuff may work in practice. If I'm not wrong Sergey Levine said, that the only problem is sample efficiency. So you would need to simulate the real world, or let your robot brake 1 million time dishes till it learns.
- malcolmwhite 6y agoNot OP, but where I work (Fox Robotics) we leave RL to demos and researchers. It is very promising, but less understood and less proven, so we aren't in a hurry to design any products around it.