3 ms·
The GPL is not anti-capitalist but it will in some ways stop businesses profiting of your work withing giving back. I believe all software should be either som
by mhh__ 6y ago
The GPL is not anti-capitalist but it will in some ways stop businesses profiting of your work withing giving back.
I believe all software should be either some variant of the GPL or GPL/Commercial dual. The latter is so a company can choose not to comply with the GPL but still give back to the project (financially).
Anti-capitalism is a strange ideology given recent history. Most flaws pointed at capitalism today actually stem from problems that most capitalists would take issue with (corruption, overregulation, underregulation etc.). The people who built the Soviet Union and other socialist countries weren't stupid, the task is just impossible.
- throwanem 6y agoThe SaaS paradigm trivially defeats the intent of the GPL, doesn't it? The problem people have with capitalism isn't that it has failure modes; every economic ideology has those. The problem people have with capitalism is that, in a capitalist society, the failure modes of capitalism are the ones that are the problem, and it's very hard to see how the status quo could be repaired without having to be replaced. (Which I think is fair. Look at what it took to fix it last time, and how long that hasn't lasted...)
- bccdee 6y agoAnti-capitalists would argue that those problems (corporatism, money-in-politics, wealth inequality) are inevitable products of capitalism. Obviously the Soviet model was a failure, but I think it's a bit silly to use the failure of one competing model as an argument that no other model could ever succeed.
- zepto 6y agoThe Soviet model is not proof that no other model could ever succeed. However it (and other failed communisms) are proof of particular failure modes. Given that these are the outcomes we know about, they are a reasonable null hypothesis. Amongst modern proponents of socialism I have not so far seen anyone actually say how those failure modes would be avoided.
- bccdee 6y agoThe failure mode of authoritarian communist regimes was simple. They failed in the same way that authoritarian capitalist regimes like the Pinochet's Chilean government did: the people in power didn't care about the well-being of the general public, and so the economy ultimately collapsed because the needs of the public weren't being met. This is a problem solved by democracy. Now, if you want to argue that there are problems with economic planning, I'm right there with you. I think that market incentives have historically been a more reliable way of running an economy, and that market socialism [1] is a much more viable alternative than a state-planned economy. But it's worth noting that it's hard to make strong claims about the consequences of economic planning when it's never been implemented in a democratic society. Regardless, concerns about the failure modes of authoritarian communist states don't really make sense in the context of market socialism, since it involves neither authoritarianism nor economic planning. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_socialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_socialism