6 ms·
- Motion planning: already discussed. - Multiaxis singularities: much less of a problem than it used to be. We don't need closed-form solutions any more; we ha
by Animats 6y ago
- Motion planning: already discussed.
- Multiaxis singularities: much less of a problem than it used to be. We don't need closed-form solutions any more; we have enough CPU power at the robot to deal with this. You need some additional constraint, like "minimize jerk" when you have too many degrees of freedom.
- Simultaneous Location and Mapping. SLAM for short: Getting much better. Things which explore and return a map are fairly common now. LIDAR helps. So does having a heading gyro with a low drift rate. Available commercially on vacuum cleaners.
- Lost Robot Problem: hard, but in practical situations, markers of some kind, visual or RF, help.
- Object manipulation and haptic feedback: Look up the DARPA manipulation challenge. Getting a key into a lock is still a hard problem. It's embarrassing how bad this is. Part of the problem is that force-sensing wrists are still far too expensive for no good reason. I once built one out of a 6DOF mouse, which is just a spring-loaded thing with optical sensors. Something I was fooling around with before TechShop went down. I have a little robot arm with an end wrench and a force sensing wrist. The idea was to get it to put the wrench around the bolt head by feel. Nice problem because a 6DOF force sensor gives you all the info you can get while holding an end wrench.
- Depth estimation: LIDAR helps. The second Kinect was a boon to robotics. Low-cost 3D LIDAR units are still rare. Amusingly, depth from movement progressed because of the desire to make 3D movies from 2D movies. (Are there still 3D movies being made?)
- Position estimation of moving objects: the military spends a lot of time on this, but doesn't publish much. Behind the staring sensor of a modern all-aspect air to air missile is - something that solves that problem.
- Affordance discovery: Very little progress.
The real problem: solve any of these problems, make very little money. If you're qualified to work on any of these problems, you can go to Google, Apple, etc. and make a lot of money solving easier problems.
- deepGem 6y ago"The real problem: solve any of these problems, make very little money" - Just curious why have you come to this conclusion ? Object manipulation has potential products in dishwashing and vegetable chopping - sufficiently large markets, potential billion $ outcomes for a startup which takes the early mover lead. Two robotic hands that can work in co-ordination just as human hands do. Extremely difficult to solve, but money is there.
- NalNezumi 6y agoI'm not the OP, but the real issue in robotics is two-fold and he mention both. 1. The cost & technical limitation. The cost, as some of the solution per problem OP suggest include "Lidar, visions and sensor" and all of those thing cost a lot by themselves. On top of that you need good actuators (Harmonic drives etc) for precision, and then good computing unit to handle all of it. Now you also need more power supply, and if it is mobile it needs a battery. Now your robot have a price tag only Arabic princes and well funded academic labs are interested in. And we haven't even touched the cost of try&fail iterative engineering process to make these work. In that process most companies/labs realizes the problem/condition have to be severely limited (run time, indoor/outdoor, general applicability vs made for one & one application only). 2. Human resource. Really, there's not much money in robotics, as a robotics engineer. Software robotics engineer can get a better working condition, security, salary & fulfillment in a software company. Mechanical, EE, embedded, etc is in a similar situation. Most robotics people I know are in for the passion. Application specific development (that is the norm right now) also require very niche knowledge that is hard to find.
- nwatson 6y agoHmmm, lawyers, they will be involved. Add astronomical insurance and liability costs when things do go wrong in less-constrained and less-controlled environments.
- bluGill 6y agoThe points you make are all true until they are not. Many useful robots should be able to work well enough for the purpose at a reasonable cost. Part of that is mass production brings prices down. The problem is of course until we can solve the problem of making it work at all price isn't a consideration. You can go bankrupt advancing the state of the art which then is enough for someone else to take your work and (repeat the bankruptcy part many times until someone works it out), and finally someone makes a ton of money with their useful robot.
- jbay808 6y ago
- Autowired 6y agoDo you think depth estimation could be done with two cameras plus computer vision (to find markers)? I think this is more or less what we do with our own eyes. Of course you would need much more processing power, but maybe for some applications the robot's brain doesn't need to be inside its body.
- Mvandenbergh 6y agoParallax methods are widely used, I think it's how Tesla's driving assist features work. The problem with it is that humans don't just use binocular vision - we have a whole model of the world. So for instance, if I see an object, I usually know roughly how big it is supposed to be because I have a conception of "object". I also know that the straight line on both sides of an object is a wall, and that the wall continues behind the object and therefore the object is in front of the wall and the object is closer than the wall. That means I'm not just working with my binocular vision and it can be deceptive to think that because it works for human vision it will also work well for computer vision.
- treeman79 6y agoLost binocular vision for a number of years back. You get around just fine without it. Got it back after some speciality glasses (PRISM). Was a complete shock see depth again. Didn’t seem to help anything getting it back. Mostly just trippy. Chairs were amazing to stare at.
- etrautmann 6y agoI’m curious to hear more. What caused you to lose and then regain depth perception? Were you able to see with both eyes or did you lose vision in one eye temporarily?
- arpa 6y agoIf prism glasses helped regain depth perception, then probably something went wrong with eye motor function, causing diplopia (double image due to misalignment of eye). Could be trauma to the eye socket? Vision loss in one eye i think can be ruled out.
- tgflynn 6y agoI don't really understand why depth estimation using binocular vision is still a problem. I worked on this a bit a number of years ago and I thought I had scene matching working pretty well. The problem is I was trying to make it work without actually having two cameras (ie. on a smartphone where binocular cameras were not available at the time and for the most part still aren't). I was hoping to use the accelerometers and other sensors for dead reckoning the camera's position as the user swept it over a scene, but that turned out to be too hard.
- alfanick 6y agoIsn't your "that turned out to be too hard" one of the answers? People tend to think about machine vision in perfect conditions. This is the problem, me thinks. In practice, you will get a lens flare in most important case, or lose a sensor or get some rain. Instead of designing solutions starting from most hardcore edgecases (which are common with humans), robotics researchers tend to provide MVP that works in best situation. That is far from end-user environmnent. This needs global fixes, if you (I don't care) want robots working in real world.
- tgflynn 6y agoBut what I said was that the "turned out to be too hard" part had nothing to do with binocular vision. I'm certainly not claiming that I had a fully robust solution but I'm pretty sure lens flares wouldn't be too hard to filter out and there are lots of useful things that need doing in rain-free environments.
- Animats 6y ago> Isn't your "that turned out to be too hard" one of the answers? That's a "we need an expert in filter theory" problem. I had four people crash and burn on that problem when we were building a DARPA Grand Challenge vehicle. Combining GPS, accelerometer, gyro, compass, and odometer data to get position is a hard problem. All those sensors are noisy, but in quite different ways. There are off the shelf solutions now, but there were not in 2004. We could not get below 3 degrees of heading noise, and had trouble keeping the sensor map aligned to the real world.
- christopher22 6y agoKinda feels like that old life pro tip. Want to know the answer to something? Don’t ask a question, but make a false statement. Every expert in the field will rush to correct you and give you the most up to date and relevant information.
- acoard 6y ago>Cunningham's Law states "the best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer."[0] Also I'd like to point out that you incorrectly stated it was an "old life pro tip" instead of an "internet law". Anyways, here is the correct information for you. [0] https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Cunningham%27s_Law
- christopher22 6y agoThanks for setting me straight. :)