3 ms·
If in the US: Roads Available utilities due to regulatory planning with normally private companies Your food supply is generally trustworthy Social security
by tomrod 6y ago
If in the US:
Roads
Available utilities due to regulatory planning with normally private companies
Your food supply is generally trustworthy
Social security.
Social safety net hospitals.
Generally clean and monitored environment to avoid carcinogens (less more recently).
Well defended.
I wonder if taxes are so high that anyone's income taxes, capital gains taxes, and consumption taxes are higher than the mulitipicative benefits from the above.
- cromwellian 6y agoDon't forget universal education so you have a literate population who feeds into your startup workforce. The problem with most libertarian arguments is that they love to point out all of the negative externalities of taxes, but none of the positive externalities of a well educated, healthy, fed, sheltered, happy society and a clean environment. People and the environment are treated as cost free infinite sinks and sources. Markets may be the most efficient mechanism for allocating goods and services using price signals, but that assumes your price signals aren't garbage. Garbage in/Garbage out, and if you have uncounted for costs your externalizing from your inputs or outputs, then you're effectively freeloading off of everyone else who will pay those costs down the line. Thus when someone makes billions of dollars and starts to whine about paying a chunk of it, what I hear is an ungrateful douchebag who participated in a game whose rules were set up before his birth, won big, and wants to loot the corpse and run off without paying it forward. (I'm looking at you Eduardo Saverin)
- tomrod 6y agoTo be fair, I'm a classical liberal (minarchist), but really that means I want frugality to be a design goal while achieving the services we as a society decide to achieve. Markets can be efficient, when externalities and asymmetric information, among other market failures, don't overwhelm the market value.
- dantheman 6y agoSure great, you've described a tiny percent of the US taxes. There are some assumptions built it to this - that if the US government didn't do it, it wouldn't get done. But some areas: 1. Extremely high housing costs due to zoning restrictions and government subsidized mortgages. 2. Extremely high medical costs due to regulation and central planning 3. Extremely high educational costs due to subsidized student loans. 4. Over 1 million people in jail 5. Involved in military actions and destabilizing actions around the world. 6. The war on drugs But even with that, based on the things above - is there any point at which taxes are too high? Why not make them 100% and then the government can provide food, shelter, and spending money?
- tomrod 6y agoThe things I described are not a tiny percent of taxes. You should revisit your assertion here. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#/media/File:US_Federal_Budget_Comparison_2016_vs._2015.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#/...