4 ms·
Thorium plants also have the unfortunate characteristic of not existing in deployable commercial form (and only very barely in experimental form).
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Thorium plants also have the unfortunate characteristic of not existing in deployable commercial form (and only very barely in experimental form).
- arcticbull 6y agoCANDU reactors support mixed Uranium and Thorium fuel. "CANDU can also breed fuel from the more abundant thorium. This is being investigated by India to take advantage of its natural thorium reserves." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CANDU_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CANDU_reactor
- dredmorbius 6y agoThanks, noted.
- arcticbull 6y agoI think the reason they don't go the Thorium route is that Uranium is just so abundant -- and so incredibly energy dense -- there's not a hugely compelling reason to switch to Thorium.
- pfdietz 6y agoThorium reactors are breeders. The Th gets converted to 233U. But breeders of any kind are uneconomical.
- dredmorbius 6y agoWhy is that?
- pfdietz 6y agoThey require an extra separation step (removing newly bred material from spent fuel, or removing fission products from molten salt). This is more expensive than just doing nothing to the spent fuel. In the past, the idea was that nuclear would be cheap, but would run into uranium supply constraints, so breeding would save money. But that's not how it turned out. Nuclear was expensive not because of fuel, but because of the cost of the power plants. Uranium prices remain low. Also, the move to gas centrifuges reduced the energy consumed in uranium enrichment by a factor of 50.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThanks. My understanding is that uranium supplies remain constrained --- fewer than two decades if supplying 100% of total global generation, say. Price doesn't tell you much about total resource stock.[1] That's based on terrestrial sources. Seawater U separation in theory would extend resources considerably, but remains unproven at scale. Thorium, other disadvantages notwithstanding, is at least more plentiful. I'll note I'm not generally a fan of nuclear, though don't rule out any contributory role. ________________________________ Notes: 1. I'd argue generally that nonrenewable natural resource pricing theory, dating to Ricardo, but especially Hotelling, is entirely flawed. Much of it under suspicious circumstances.
- pfdietz 6y agoYes, but the "supplying 100% of global generation" doesn't have any bearing on current reality. Anyway, this argument for thorium isn't something customers would care much about. It's basically "thorium would not suck as much as uranium-fueled burner reactors do if uranium gets much more expensive" rather than "nuclear power is more attractive now if we use thorium". The customer response to "nuclear as currently implemented fails badly if uranium runs out" is going to be "use something other than nuclear".
- dredmorbius 6y agoLate response, my apologies. At some point we've got to address the question of how much energy is supplied to how many people and for how long. Population is expected to rise for at least another 30-80 years, to between 9 and 12 billions by most estimates. These may not see US levels of energy access, but most authors project per capita energy wealth roughly comparable to present day European levels, largely as electricity. This represents multiples of present generating capacity.[1] And energy represented by virtually any nonrenewable stock, including most fissionanbles, is finite. That's before allowing for technical limitations, concerns, wastes, risks, or other impacts. When the U.S. was first transitioning from wood to coal, roughly 1860--1880, then-known reserves were calculated as sufficient for at least one million years at then-present rates of consumption.[2] The problem, of course, is that rates of consumption increased somewhat, by a greater rate than those of new coal discoveries. I can remember in the 1970s National Geographic adverts assuring readers that America's coal reserves were good for another 1,000 years, already a thousandfold reduction from 100 years prior. Today official estimates tend to run 200--300 years, though pessimistic ones suggest scarcely a century.[3] That's roughly 10,000 times sorter than initially anticipated, thanks largely to the Jevons Paradox: low-cost goods and increased efficience stimulate demand. And all this before acknowledging that we simple cannot burn much more of the stuff. So, no, I don't buy that "supplying 100% of global generation doesn't have any bearing on current reality.", as even a small fraction of a growing number, most especially an exponentially growing one, remains a large number. ________________________________ Notes: 1. 1991 per capita use, 287.8 GJ US, 75.3 GJ world, 123.6 GJ Europe. bp Statistical Review of World Energy 2020, p. 11. At 123 GJ * 12 billions souls, total global energy demand would be 1,476 EJ, vs. 584 EJ consumed 2019, a 250% increase. Total 2019 electric generation was 27,005 TWh, or 97.2 EJ, 16.6% of total global energy consumption. That works out to 3.46 MWh/capita, or about 395 W continuous per person. 2. Henry Erni, Coal oil and petroleum: their origin, history, geology, and chemistry (1865), p. 14. https://archive.org/details/coaloilpetroleum00erni/page/14/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/coaloilpetroleum00erni/page/14/m... 3. BP's 2020 report gives an R/P ratio, reseves vs. production, equivalent to years supply at present consumption, of 390 years. This is an increase, though almost entirely due to reduced extraction, down from 22.27 EJ in 2011 to 14.30 in 2019. Consumption has fallen by more.
- legulere 6y agoThere was a commercial thorium reactor in Germany, which was a financial disaster: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/THTR-300 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/THTR-300
- MertsA 6y agoThat was also a pebble bed reactor. The kind of reactor generating all of the latest hype is a molten fuel salt breeder reactor. There's a really substantial difference between the two and the MSRE was basically a mock up of the core running on Uranium fuel salt that would have been generated in a fertile Thorium blanket salt around the core and been reprocessed into the fuel salt. Pebble bed reactors have tons of drawbacks that don't apply to most modern Thorium reactor proposals. The biggest drawbacks to proposals like e.g. LFTR is corrosion risks which were largely addressed by the MSRE ages ago, and the chemical reprocessing equipment which again is mostly a chemical engineering problem more so than a nuclear engineering one.
- belorn 6y agoTo place it in the context of this compressed energy storage, when does the plant expect to be commercial viable through the method of buying energy cheap, storing it, and selling it expensive? As far as I can find information, this plant is built on 30 millions given from the government. They have also got 17 millions from an equity round and 20 millions from a asset manager that supports building out clean-energy infrastructure. In order to be commercial viable they need a significant overproduction in the energy grid from wind and solar which enable the company to buy cheap energy during peaks and sell it expensive during lows, and the difference need to be significant enough to pay both the energy loss, the operation cost and the investment costs. Wind and solar will also not over saturate the market beyond what is commercial viable for them, putting a short-term limit on how cheap the price can go during peaks.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThe tens of millions is a pretty cheap deal compared to nuclear power, which needs billions to get the ball rolling (and that's if it completes on budget)
- belorn 6y agoIts only a good deal if it produce profits. I rather have the government take a billion dollar cost in the energy sector that later turn a profit than a millions dollar cost that don't. If neither can make a profit then that says something about the energy market. Turn off the fossil fueled alternative (or incrementally add a carbon tax until fossil fueled become commercial nonviable) and let see if the market price adjust to the point where the profitability of either goes into the green.
- nicoburns 6y ago> I rather have the government take a billion dollar cost that later turn a profit than a millions dollar cost that don't. Surely that ought to depend on how much profit it generates. If it only generates a few millions in profit you're still down on your money.