4 ms·
Some feedback for the author - including statements like "Or how not to be stupid", "half of your wealth will go to the big bad government", "moronically ignora
by refurb 6y ago
Some feedback for the author - including statements like "Or how not to be stupid", "half of your wealth will go to the big bad government", "moronically ignorant of basic economics" and "apocalypse hasn't happened" really detracts from their arguments and makes it seem like more of an angry screed rather than a well thought out argument.
It would have been a fine article without the childish attacks.
- piyush_soni 6y ago>> It would have been a fine article without the childish attacks But probably wouldn't have got the same number of readers ;) Edit: I thought the <sarcasm> tag was not necessary, but apparently it is.
- fermienrico 6y agoAbout the only person that has the authority is Linus because we all know he is tongue-in-cheek. :) This on the other hand is uncalled for and unnecessary. The analysis stands on its own by just saying "Paul Graham is wrong about this."
- actuator 6y agoI personally think even with the language it's a fine post. At least, even If I don't agree with the language, I would critique the content. He does a fine job in rebutting that PG post which made no sense and painted a very bleak picture of wealth tax. IMO this shouldn't have been flagged.
- andreareina 6y agoA fine rebuttal would acknowledge that a charitable reading of pg's original post includes the effect of growth---you're still left with the same fraction of wealth if not for the tax. It's not even a stretch to say that that's what pg originally meant, the phrasing in [1] is pretty careful and specific. FTA's thesis is entirely predicated on an error that arguably isn't there. It would do much better by acknowledging that yes, even under optimistic growth conditions the tax will take a big bite out of the final wealth, but that even under conservative estimates of growth the hypothetical founder will still be ahead. This is a facile "well-actually". [1] http://web.archive.org/web/20200818133017/http://paulgraham.com/wtax.html http://web.archive.org/web/20200818133017/http://paulgraham....