5 ms·
At a certain point if photovoltaic panels become very, very cheap (far below the $0.20-$0.35/watt STC price to buy panels in huge quantities today), it will be
by walrus01 6y ago
At a certain point if photovoltaic panels become very, very cheap (far below the $0.20-$0.35/watt STC price to buy panels in huge quantities today), it will be economical to crack hydrogen from water and compress it into tanks, then use it to run massive fuel cells to feed power back into the grid.
Because of the significant engineering challenges in storing, transporting and refueling hydrogen at very high pressures, I am much more optimistic about the use of hydrogen in medium to large sized fixed, professionally-run facilities than I am about people driving around with hydrogen fuel cell powered cars. Or home use of hydrogen fuel cells.
- andromeduck 6y agothat generally requires high cost or temperature catalysts and even then it's not that efficient for short-medium term
- pfdietz 6y agoAlkaline electrolysers do not require high cost electrocatalysts, and are likely the low capital cost (and mediocre efficiency) ones to be used with intermittent renewables.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoOr spread it around the world and run lots of interconnectors. It's always daytime somewhere in the world.
- Tade0 6y agoEthanol may be better suited for this: https://www.anl.gov/article/turning-carbon-dioxide-into-liquid-fuel https://www.anl.gov/article/turning-carbon-dioxide-into-liqu...
- Mvandenbergh 6y agoTank storage is challenging because at that scale you're competing with batteries which have much better round-trip efficiency. There was a DNV GL paper earlier this year which quoted a time of about 24 hrs as the cross-over point between H2 and battery tech. Underground cavern storage lets you do inter-seasonal storage at a very low cost per MWh. It's critical to understand that liquid and gas fuels have uncoupled per MW and per MWh costs in a way that batteries don't. You can adjust battery chemistry of course but fundamentally you're stuck with a narrow range of peak MW / MWh performance which means that if you want to build a massive battery for inter-seasonal storage (needs MWh >>> MW) you end up "buying" discharge capacity in MW that you don't need. Hydrogen decouples the size of the production (in MW), the storage (MWh), and the fuel cell (MW) which lets you size them independently of each other. I am also sceptical of the need for home use or vehicular hydrogen (certainly in passenger cars). You get a lot of efficiency improvement if you are able to use the waste heat from fuel cells. Yes that can be done domestically, but putting them in large urban centres and driving district heating schemes from them seems like a much more natural fit. Especially in places like Europe where total energy demand (heat and electricity both) peak at the same time in the winter as renewable generation decreases. N.b. there are already times in the UK grid when prices are negative wholesale. Even one of the retail energy suppliers here had a few half hourly periods of negative prices a few months ago. The subsidy for hydrogen electrolysers in The Netherlands was set assuming 2,000 hours a year of operation (using the cleanest and cheapest 2,000 hrs) since that maximises the environmental benefit with the current Dutch grid.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- elric 6y agoIsn't storage a problem with large hydrogen quantities? I'm not sure what form it takes in storage, whether it's H or H2, but either way that's tiny and it's going to seep out of just about everything.
- pfdietz 6y agoIt would be stored underground, where the cost per unit of energy storage capacity is under $1/kWh, two orders of magnitude cheaper than batteries. The round trip efficiency is not good, though, and there are per-power costs too. But for very long term storage, or storage for rare cloudy-calm days over large areas, it's hard to beat.
- pfdietz 6y agoA recent gigawatt scale PV bid in UAE came in at $0.0135/kWh. https://www.forbes.com/sites/dominicdudley/2020/04/28/abu-dhabi-cheapest-solar-power/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/dominicdudley/2020/04/28/abu-dh... "solar PV and onshore wind are now the cheapest sources of electricity generation for at least two-thirds of the world’s population"