4 ms·
The media has a huge bias to push a dominant narrative, and it's hard for actual data to get through. So the early, and false, narrative about population densi
by epistasis 6y ago
The media has a huge bias to push a dominant narrative, and it's hard for actual data to get through.
So the early, and false, narrative about population density posing an insurmountable challenge to preventing disease spread got a ton of play. Now, when it's clear that density is not driving spread, it will be rare to see a news article countering that narrative.
I also think that reports like this Zillow data will not see nearly as much media attention as the initial truths reports about people fleeing cities.
Same with the "techies are all leaving SF" stories; I'll wait for actual data before listening to the narrative that serves the interests of a huge factional divide in SF.
- m0zg 6y ago> when it's clear that density is not driving spread That's not "clear" in the least.
- TMWNN 6y agoepistasis is correct. Very few people live in the mountains and only come to town every six months. Density mattered a little bit early on, but SARS-CoV-2 is so infectious that it gets around no matter what, unless the strictest possible measures (such as the police-enforced lockdowns in parts of Melbourne at the moment, or the earlier reports of Chinese buildings' doors being welded shut) are adopted.
- m0zg 6y agoYou'd do well providing some studies to support your assertion. Best I can tell, urban centers have suffered disproportionately from C19, and they present an epidemiological nightmare with their shared public infrastructure and public transportation.
- jeffbee 6y agoThe thing that is really strongly associated with covid cases is housing overcrowding, that is the number of people in each dwelling, and not with density. This paper concludes that "Our most important finding is that density is unrelated to confirmed virus infection rates and inversely related to confirmed virus death rates, after controlling for other variables." https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01944363.2020.1777891 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01944363.2020.1...
- m0zg 6y agoLots of verbiage easily refuted by a simple statistic: NYC has C19 death rate of 2279 per million. 19K people died out of 8.337M. In comparison, NY state, as of today, has a death rate of 1693 per million, and it'd have a much lower death rate if NYC was excluded (1253 per million), and lower still if you only consider rural areas. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page
- jeffbee 6y agoSo, Tokyo? Seoul?
- m0zg 6y agoNot the same ball game, body count is so low you probably wouldn't get a reliable signal. And even then, I bet rural Japan and Korea are affected far less. It's simple common sense. R0 depends on fanout exponentially. On average, the higher the density, the higher the fanout. Downvote all you want, you know I'm right. :-)
- bluGill 6y agoUntil you get to a extreme rural most people do the same things with the same density. Grocery stores and the like tend to have similar densities everywhere because if you get any more dense someone else opens while any longer less and someone goes out of business. This is my observation in towns from as small 3000 to as large as 2 million. Similar for other activities, there are less people at the school games or theater, but the density is the same.
- ISL 6y agoFrom TFA: "In San Francisco, list prices have fallen 4.9% year over year and inventory has risen 96% with a flood of new listings. This divergence of active inventory is not evident in cities like Miami, Los Angeles, Washington, D.C., and Seattle." I'm not in San Francisco, but if we were to experience a doubling of inventory here in Seattle, it would be evidence of a big shift in the market. We neighbor-visited an open house on our block in the autumn that was attended by at least a person a minute during the half-hour that we were there. The article is super interesting for its incongruence with local anecdotes, but it would also suggest that the "techie exodus" in SF has some roots in reality.
- twblalock 6y agoOne thing people seem to forget is that leaving SF doesn't mean leaving the Bay Area. A lot of the people leaving SF are going to end up in the surrounding cities, which were always cheaper and considered more boring than SF. Now that SF is locked down, all of the Bay Area is equally boring, so you might as well live in San Mateo and cut your rent in half.
- bradlys 6y ago> live in San Mateo and cut your rent in half I think that's stretching... It's still very expensive in the burbs due to their proximity to big tech companies. I am not seeing rent be half in the peninsula compared to SF.
- chucknthem 6y agoYeah definitely not San Mateo, but east bay will do that. My realtor says her business in SF and the peninsula is drying up, but east bay is hotter than ever.
- epistasis 6y agoWell let's see if it's techies moving pretty if it's other people. In my Bay Area adjacent town, there's toooons of homes for sale but they are not newly purchased within the last 10-15 years, but homes that have been held for decades. There's also a huge exodus of people from SF that have lost jobs. It could be techies, but I'll wait and see the numbers to judge that, a mere overall exodus does not equate to a techie exodus for a city where techies are such a small part of the population, but which dominate so much of the discussion.
- ericd 6y ago>Same with the "techies are all leaving SF" stories; I'll wait for actual data before listening to the narrative that serves the interests of a huge factional divide in SF. Anecdotally, I know a good number of people who've left the Bay Area to be closer to family for at least the duration. So it's not purely a press narrative.