3 ms·
It's worth noting that Bell Labs existed because the government recognized that the Bell monopoly was a social ill and insisted that to counteract the problem s
by jandrese 6y ago
It's worth noting that Bell Labs existed because the government recognized that the Bell monopoly was a social ill and insisted that to counteract the problem some of the money had to be earmarked for research.
Today the government doesn't even dream of that kind of regulation anymore. The idea of doing something purely for the public good seems to be lost in the race to make the quarterly numbers as big as possible.
- devonkim 6y agoThe trend changed partly due to the 80s cult of shareholder value worship enthused by Milton Friedman / Reagan that permanently altered the social contract of corporations. If the only responsibility of corporations is shareholders, then long-term growth and investment is difficult to justify given market tendencies to be so short-term focused over time.
- eru 6y agoShareholder value capitalism was only ever an aspiration. In practice companies have always been run for the benefit of corporate insiders. Not the widows and orphans who might own a few stocks.
- scott_s 6y agoThese days, those corporate insiders have a lot of their wealth tied up their company's stock. So while it's a terrible way to think about running a company, a lot of companies are run that way because it benefits the people running them.
- eru 6y ago> These days, those corporate insiders have a lot of their wealth tied up their company's stock. Yes, that helps a bit to align incentives. In practice, it's only a start. (It's especially interesting because investors these days tend to be broadly diversified and typically own shares in all the companies in an industry. Managers are typically highly concentrated.)
- scott_s 6y agoI think you're coming to the opposite conclusion I implied. Because corporate insiders' wealth is tied up in company stock, they are incentivized to optimize for the value of the stock, which may be counter to the long-term health of the company.
- eru 6y ago> [...], they are incentivized to optimize for the value of the stock, which may be counter to the long-term health of the company. That would imply that shareholders are idiots. And especially that all hedgefunds are idiots as well. Otherwise you'd expect a lot of short-selling once the stock price exceeds the long term health, wouldn't you?
- scott_s 6y agoIf everyone was rational and had full information, yes. But it can take a while for outsiders to catch on, and people are not fully rational. For two high profile examples, look at GE and Boeing. They had a reckoning, but it took a long time.
- eru 6y agoWe don't need everyone to be fully rational. Especially not when short selling is safe and easy to do. With proper shortselling, a single entity can benefit from muckracking. Of course, short selling is the first thing that gets banned at the drop of a hat. To give a timeless example: https://www.google.com/search?q=france+bans+short+selling https://www.google.com/search?q=france+bans+short+selling You are right that it can take a while in practice. We should make it easier for the reckoning to come.
- Merrill 6y agoThe operating companies were charged a 1% fee on revenues as a patent royalty and this funded Bell Labs Research, Systems Engineering, and part of Advanced Development of devices and systems. A similar amount was provided by Western Electric for advanced development, development and research on manufacturing technology. At times the research and development funding by the DoD was larger than the civilian part. I was told that one reason that Bell Labs was formed from parts of AT&T Engineering and Western Electric Engineering was to keep the researchers from meddling with the business and to keep the business from meddling with the research. The latter was important because a strategic objective was to use technological change as a driver to prevent the monopoly telecom business from going to seed. Within Bell Labs there were often competing groups working on alternative next generation systems - analog versus digital, tube versus transistor, space division versus time division switching, coax versus microwave, microwave versus fiber, etc.