3 ms·
Economic mobility is more or less the lowest in the US of all OECD countries. This means that it is extremely likely that whatever quartile/quintile/percentile
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
Economic mobility is more or less the lowest in the US of all OECD countries. This means that it is extremely likely that whatever quartile/quintile/percentile you are born into in the US, you will also die in the same economic bracket.
Yes, you can cite whatever exceptions you like - the statistics are clear.
Most billionaires are born to other billionaires (or at least extraordinarily wealthy people compared to median wealth). As such, they represent an ancestral inheritance just nearly as much as the aristocracy.
There is almost no evidence of de novo great wealth being correlated to great talent. It may (or may not) be a necessary component, but it certainly is not necessary, even if it was possible to quantify precisely what is meant by "great talent".
In a capitalist-ish society, there are always going to be great winners in the competitive economy. Pointing them out as if they are special is absurd: the system is designed to generate such cases.
- WalterBright 6y agoBack in the 90's, the Seattle Times reported that there were over 10,000 millionaires (excluding home equity) in Seattle as a result of working at Microsoft and getting stock options. I expect its far more than that with Amazon.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoMillionaires? Not even in the ballpark of the group of people we're talking about here. Also, US$1M is not what it used to be (even though it's more than most people will earn in 20 years).
- WalterBright 6y agoA million bucks is nothing to sneeze at, it's upper middle class. And that's the cutoff - many are in 8 figures. Without Amazon and Microsoft and their billionaires, Seattle wouldn't be the wealthy city that it is. Not even close, and that wealth has filtered out all over the area. For example, there are all Paul Allen's initiatives and developments in the area, and that's only a tiny bit of what has happened. Be careful what you wish for in getting rid of billionaires. A lot of very nice things we all have will go away with them.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI was an Amazon millionaire. I know how life changing that money can be. Which is why I can have some understanding of how unimaginable 1000x that really is, let alone 100,000x times that. I'm all for nice things, but I'm not for Paul Allen deciding what's nice or what we get.
- WalterBright 6y ago> I'm not for Paul Allen deciding what's nice or what we get. The thing is, Allen didn't take anything from you to give those things. He didn't raise your taxes. He didn't impose any levies. They were gifts you could ignore if you chose. Me, I liked his flying WW2 aircraft museum very much. It's a little thing in the grand scheme of things, but I've enjoyed it a lot. If you read his autobiography "Idea Man" you're sure to find a number of things that have benefited you - without costing you anything. Musk has given us a space program. Carnegie gave us public libraries. Gates has saved millions of lives through his foundation. BTW, you don't get to decide what nice things government does for you, either. A vote is not the same thing as a choice. I've lobbied my Congressmen. Did they do what I wished? Absolutely not!
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoApaprently you're not aware of the gigantic shift in the proportion of GDP that ends up in the hands of labor vs. capital. A significant chunk Paul Allen's share of the GDP would have been in the hands of workers had he been economically active during the period 1949-1978. That's what he "took" from people to be as wealthy as he is. I am flabbergasted that you feel that the "lack of choice" over what your government does is the same thing as the "lack of choice" over what rich people do with their money. In fact, I feel sorry for you in that you live in a country fundamentally built on formalizing this difference and creating a nation based on a belief in government "of the people". You don't believe that - you're not alone. But I still feel pity for you that you've been forced to give up the dream that this country was built on after just a couple hundred years.
- 6y ago