5 ms·
>You see Mars is, a priori, just as likely a place for life to start as Earth. Asserted without evidence, and considerable waving of hands detected.
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
>You see Mars is, a priori, just as likely a place for life to start as Earth.
Asserted without evidence, and considerable waving of hands detected.
- quantdev 6y agoWe have no good evidence or accepted model for how life started, besides "randomness" in a primordial soup, which is as good as "no idea". As such, it seems like a reasonable assumption to explore.
- ivraatiems 6y agoThat's untrue. See here https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-did-life-begin1/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-did-life-begi.... An "Earthlike" planet is required. Mars may have qualified at one point, but doesn't now.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoAn earthlike planet is require for earthlike life. It is fallacious to assume other life couldn't be different -- we can't prove or disprove that. Likewise, we still don't know exactly how life started here; we simply have a few good theories.
- clairity 6y agothis is what has always annoyed me about basically every space movie ever made. even life a star away, let alone another galaxy away, is likely to be startlingly different from the oxygen-absorbing, ossified calcium-braced, protein-enriched, atp-powered water blobs with heads, legs, and feet we have on earth. and that's just the the biochemical stuff we're familiar with.
- pfdietz 6y agoWhat bothers me about every space movie made is that all those planets have life on them (or, worse, intelligent life). Fermi says hi.
- PoachedSausage 6y agoFermi can blast out "Hi" with a 100GW of power and he is unlikely to be heard in Andromeda, which for all we know could be teeming with life and host to something like an Iain Banks Culture series space opera.
- pfdietz 6y agoWe know that fewer than about 1 in 100,000 galaxies has a Kardashev Type III civilization. So the Fermi argument has some bite even at cosmological distances. But anyway, this was about SF movies where our heroes visit Arglebarg IV and have adventures with the natives. It's like Victorian adventure stories transplanted into space without bothering to think things through. Let's kill our dysfunctional tropes.
- nextaccountic 6y ago> We know that fewer than about 1 in 100,000 galaxies has a Kardashev Type III civilization. But we.. don't? We just don't have anything to compare to.
- pfdietz 6y agoA K3 civilization is one that has diverted a significant fraction of the stellar output of a galaxy to its own uses. They have to dump their waste heat somehow, and that's visible in the far to mid infrared. So we can compare the IR emission of galaxies to look for oddballs with a lot of IR. https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2015/04/16/g-hat-searching-for-kardashev-type-iii/ https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2015/04/16/g-hat-searching-f... “Our results mean that, out of the 100,000 galaxies that WISE could see in sufficient detail, none of them is widely populated by an alien civilization using most of the starlight in its galaxy for its own purposes. That’s interesting because these galaxies are billions of years old, which should have been plenty of time for them to have been filled with alien civilizations, if they exist. Either they don’t exist, or they don’t yet use enough energy for us to recognize them.”
- pfdietz 6y agoI don't think we have "good" theories about how life started here. In particular, the complexity gap from abiotic chemicals to the smallest known organism capable of independent reproduction (about 4 billion atoms!) is extremely large, and no theory has done more than handwave about how that gap is to be crossed.
- danudey 6y agoThat's also discussed in the article. The author states that Mars may have qualified before Earth did. Edit: Also, the article you linked specifically states "Scientists debate a range of ideas about how life on earth began", undermining your first point.
- mvn9 6y ago>Martian surface temperatures vary from lows of about −143 °C (−225 °F) at the winter polar caps[14] to highs of up to 35 °C (95 °F) in equatorial summer. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars Had to look this up. Seems like there is the same temperature window available on Mars that is needed for life on earth.
- dogma1138 6y agoThat’s today without atmosphere, liquid water and with a solidified core I’m not sure were close to estimating when the core has solidified as far as I know we also have no method for dating anything on mars. When mars was wet, geologically a GI d and still had an atmosphere the temperatures would’ve been much closer to earth today.
- notahacker 6y agoThe Mars panspermia theory mentioned in the original article simply moves the "randomness" to a primordial soup 83 million km away during the same time frame, and adds the exceptionally strong claim that Mars was so much more conducive to spontaneous formation of organisms capable of surviving on earth that it is more probable life emerged there and made an unexplained interplanetary journey than it emerged on the planet it currently [exclusively] lives on. Considering the best evidence of Mars being conducive to earthly life formation is the likelihood of it more closely resembling earth's conditions in the past, it doesn't seem like the sort of claim likely to resolve issues with earthly primordial soup hypotheses...
- simiones 6y agoI think the opposite conclusion is true: we know nothing about how life gets started, we know life exists on Earth, we have seen no evidence of life anywhere else, so the reasonable assumption is that life started on Earth. One thing we know (almost) for sure is that no new forms of life have emerged on Earth for hundreds of millions of years. So we should expect that the conditions required are quite special indeed, or the event is extraordinarily unlikely. As such, it is silly to assume that any other planet is "similar to Earth" in the ways that matter for life appearing based on simplistic observations (temperature, distance from the sun, existence of the most basic required elements).
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoDo plants count? Then I have cacti for you, which are thought to be only a few dozen million years old.
- simiones 6y agoI am referring to abiogenesis - life arising from non-life matter. Cacti have not appeared out of simple chemicals, they have evolved from other plant-based lifeforms (in fact, there is no "first cactus"). My point is that, despite the huge abundance of life on Earth today, it is all based on a very old abiogenesis event, with all indications that it was more or less a singular event. All life on earth seems to be part of the same philogenetic tree, so it seems that life appeared once and then kept evolving from that initial life-form. Of course, there is a good chance that there was some variety of initial organisms that either merged together in symbiotic relationships, such as mitochondria with the rest of the cell, or got out-competed by the one type of organism that we are all descended from. This still indicates that life arose in a single place and only over a relatively short amount of time.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoHm. OK. thx.
- danudey 6y ago"a priori" means "from theoretical deduction rather than evidence or experience", so yes, that's entirely the point of that sentence. What the author is saying is "theoretically, life could have started on Mars just as easily as it did here".
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe theories we have about how life started on Earth tend to disfavor Mars as a similar starting point, based on what we currently know about Mars. I think the author was trying to say "I mean, look, Earth and Mars are not that different, and even though we don't have any current evidence for the appropriate chemical conditions on Mars, I don't see why it couldn't have been where life started instead of Earth, because ... well, just because they're sort of similar, kind of. Oh, and next to each other."
- pfdietz 6y agoThose theories don't have much in the way of evidence that would compel anyone to believe them, though. So citing them isn't much of an argument.
- brudgers 6y agobased on what we currently know In two hundred years, conclusions drawn from what we currently know will be as out of date as conclusions from two hundred years ago are today. Or to put it another way, things known to the best of our knowledge are both as good as we can do and probably wrong because one of the things we know is that historically most of what people know at any given time turns out to be wrong at any given time.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoAbsolutely correct. But this article was written now, and makes a claim that is totally unsupported by anything we know now. I'm entirely down for our descendants in 200 years laughing at our scientific parochiality, just like we often get to do at our double-century antecedents. But that doesn't justify writing right now that Mars and Earth have a priori likelihoods of being the origin of life in the solar system.