3 ms·
Preventing people using your software on other hardware is not anti-competitive. It doesn’t do anything to prevent others from developing their own hardware or
by zepto 6y ago
Preventing people using your software on other hardware is not anti-competitive.
It doesn’t do anything to prevent others from developing their own hardware or software.
It’s not as if Apple has a monopoly on good operating systems or developers. Apple’s software isn’t magic.
It’s just well designed and managed relative to the competition. There is no reason it can’t be bettered, except that nobody is trying.
As far as the ‘at every level you can’t substitute other components’ definition of ‘anti-competitive’. That doesn’t work. Every company is like that. The only things which aren’t are certain open source licenses.
At any point where you want substitutable components, one must have agreed interfaces.
As I said earlier, the competitors failed in the early 2000’s because the process of agreeing on interfaces was hopelessly political. At that time the prevailing wisdom amongst VC’s was ‘there’s no money in hardware’.
The only way around that is for competitors (or open source contributors) to establish a truly open platform that commoditizes Apple’s core asset, and then for them all to realize it isn’t in their interest for anyone to seize control of it. That, or someone to just outdo Apple with low end disruption.
I’d like to think that this is what Google will do with Fuchsia, but anyone else can do it.
I actually agree with you that it would be good to have competition at levels other than the platform.
I believe that over a time it’s possible that such an ecosystem could be better for consumers than Apple’s ecosystem.
I do not believe that you can create such an ecosystem by forcing Apple to open certain arbitrarily selected parts of their system.
If anything, I think this would prevent the emergence of a new model indefinitely.
I also don’t think it’s a foregone conclusion that it would be better - only that it is a possibility.
As for the cash reserves. Those look quite wise in the present situation. At Apple’s scale, geopolitical risk is real. China as a last resort in the trade war with Trump could easily make it impossible for them to continue to work there. Trump could do the same.
$200B seems like a reasonable hedge against needing to rebuild their supply chains without Chinese cooperation.
It’s also just a concentration of wealth.
Look at all the other players with concentrated wealth who could just as easily be funding a competitor, and actually have a business interest in doing so.
If your argument is that Apple should be funding its competitors, surely that same argument should apply to anyone with enough money.
VC funds, Hedge Funds, Microsoft, Amazon, etc.
The part we agree on is that someone should be funding serious competition against Apple.
There is plenty of capital outside of Apple which could be doing this.
The reason it hasn’t been doing so is that there have been much quicker and easier ways to make money. Advertising engines, Ride share services, Office building scams, etc.
Any way you look at it, building a giant company slowly over decades is a bad way to make money compared to a quick investment in a Unicorn which never even becomes profitable.
That’s what we should be addressing.
- kbenson 6y ago> Preventing people using your software on other hardware is not anti-competitive. ... It doesn’t do anything to prevent others from developing their own hardware or software. Actually, since they also provide the hardware, in the truest sense of the word, it is. They are preventing alternative hardware for their software (they've sued over this), and preventing alternative software on their hardware. No competition is allowed in these areas, to compete you have to replace both. If you then consider that they lock down what apps can run on their software, that extends the link to software able to run on the device. That means to actually compete on an App level with an Apple app on iOS, you need to not just write a better app, but provide an OS of comparable quality and hardware of comparable quality means they have artificially prevented competition at those levels, since there's no reason that they have to be linked. It provides some small benefits, but there's a large difference between not supporting their OS on other hardware and actively preventing it from running on it, and not providing any softawre except their own for their hardware, and locking it down so no other software will boot. That difference is why those actions are anti-competitive. > I do not believe that you can create such an ecosystem by forcing Apple to open certain arbitrarily selected parts of their system. And yet the only reason we don't have that competition is because Apple has closed certain non-arbitrary selected parts of their system/platform. I'm not sure why preventing them from closing those to competition wouldn't help spur more competition in them. > If anything, I think this would prevent the emergence of a new model indefinitely. I'm not even sure "model" means in this context. What do you suspect preventing arbitrary removal of competition, which is what Apple does, would somehow prevent a new model? > $200B seems like a reasonable hedge against needing to rebuild their supply chains without Chinese cooperation. Having a few full years worth of profit stacked away so they can replicate their entire manufacturing infrastructure needs of a nation that specializes in manufacturing is ridiculous. The comparison to Japanese Zaibatsu was apt before, but you're actually saying it's a good idea if some conditions are met here. Those are known to have outsize negative effects on economies. > If your argument is that Apple should be funding its competitors No, my argument is that they have too much control over their platform, with allows them to be anti-competitive. This makes them more money, but at the expense of their users (who do not benefit from that competition), and most likely some ceompetitors, unless you believe Apple would still provide a much better solution, in which case it's just he users that win. > The part we agree on is that someone should be funding serious competition against Apple. The fact that you think VC is the answer is part of the problem. Right now VC is the answer, because it's almost impossible for anyone to compete without huge amounts of money, but that's because of Apple's arbitrary barriers to compete.