4 ms·
That's strictly not true. People vote for Amazon the product (over Walmart's web experience), they don't vote for Amazon the Jeff Bezos Political Agenda. Those
by arcticbull 6y ago
That's strictly not true. People vote for Amazon the product (over Walmart's web experience), they don't vote for Amazon the Jeff Bezos Political Agenda. Those are two totally different things. For instance, there's plenty of right-wing folks who shop on Amazon while simultaneously hating the Washington Post.
As mentioned upthread, this is the difference between democracy and rule by wealth.
- ChrisLomont 6y ago>they don't vote for Amazon the Jeff Bezos Political Agenda. Plenty of companies take a hit on their wallet when the CEO has political agendas the customers don't like.
- arcticbull 6y agoSure, but I think that's conflating two things. You're welcome to take a hit to your wallet when you don't want to enrich a certain business leader. What you shouldn't have to do is take a hit to your wallet because you don't want to politically empower a certain business leader. This is especially true as there's less and less competition, and a few huge players control a disproportionate amount of the market (which is an issue on its own, albeit a separate one). The idea behind a democracy for better or worse is one individual gets one vote. When you start having to figure out how you're voting by proxy through the leadership of each company you do business with, I'd wager, that wouldn't be within the spirit of the system. Companies should compete for individual walletshare by merit, and it really should be apolitical. It won't always be, of course, but I think we're better off if we try and limit it. Conflating the two weakens both imo.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe CEO of Crossfit as a recent example.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoExcellently put. And put differently: even if people actually thought that Bezos was just a brilliant businessman, why would anyone think that he's a brilliant social strategist? Or resource planner? Or commander-in-chief? Just because someone knows how to build and run a company that's great at selling stuff tells you absolutely about their qualities as a political/national leader.
- WalterBright 6y agoAmazon tried to unseat a couple Seattle City Council members in the last election. It backfired, and Amazon faces a Council that has voted a huge payroll tax onto Amazon in revenge. So if Amazon can't even control local elections, I wonder where all this supposed political power is? Also, AOC was instrumental in preventing Amazon from establishing a second headquarters in NY. As a freshman Congressman.
- arcticbull 6y agoOne failure does not disprove a hypothesis.
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's a pretty big failure for Amazon and a big score for AOC.
- malcolmxtucker 6y agoArguably, the local election is probably harder to influence successfully than at the national scale. Federal-level lobbying and donations are hidden from sight, local elections tend to have much more scrutiny and direct community involvement.