22 ms·
The first thing to notice about a wealth tax is how little it fundamentally differs from an income tax on investment income. If you have a billion dollars and y
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
The first thing to notice about a wealth tax is how little it fundamentally differs from an income tax on investment income. If you have a billion dollars and you get a 2% return and pay 15% capital gains tax, you paid 0.3% of your wealth in tax. So then what's the difference?
For one, it pushes people towards riskier investments. At a 1% annual return, a 0.3% wealth tax is equivalent to a 30% income tax. At a 5% annual return, it's equivalent to a 6% income tax. This has various consequences, but a big one of note is that it makes it much less desirable to own government debt, which has a low rate of return, which means the government could end up having to pay significantly higher interest on the debt. It could also incentivize excessive risk taking.
Another concern is that it requires investments to be liquidated in order to pay the tax. Generally we defer taxes on investment income until the investment is sold in order to avoid this, because it can be quite problematic, e.g. you own 51% of your company but over time you're forced to become a minority shareholder just in order to pay the tax, or you owned 100% of it and are required to take on external investment over time just to stay in business. This also costs the government money because the government pays lower interest on borrowing than average investment returns, so paying 0.7% to borrow money in the interim while the investor is earning 5% returns on the money you'd have collected as tax means that when the tax is ultimately paid, the government ends up with more additional revenue than they paid in interest in the meantime.
It also increases foreign ownership of domestic resources, because domestic owners are forced to liquidate in order to pay the tax and domestic buyers are in the same boat so the liquidated securities go primarily to foreign buyers.
Another problem is that a lot of forms of wealth are hard to value. If you had a wealth tax and someone owned a piece of art, or some intellectual property, or shares in a privately held company, what are they worth? It's inherently subjective and estimates can very wildly. But then you're creating an opportunity for accountants to do their thing and avoid the tax. Waiting until the property is sold and then taxing the gain solves this neatly because then you have the sale price to go on.
- acheron9383 6y agoIt seems like, if you wanted to help stop the wealthy from ducking paying taxes, one should just stop providing a special long term capitol gains tax and tax capitol gains the same as income. It simplifies the tax code, stops punishing workers who receive a wage over those who earn investment income, and doesn't require a bunch of new accounting to implement. My cynicism hat tells me the reason it isn't the policy goal is that it could actually pass in the US, the wealth tax likely never will.
- bhupy 6y agoThe reason why long term capital gains tax is taxed at a lower rate is to index for inflation. Inflation on short term income is negligible. As a matter of tax policy, it is much simpler to reduce the rate than to compute a very large inflation deduction. > the wealth tax likely never will. It also requires a Constitutional amendment, because the Constitution only allows the Federal government to levy taxes on realized income (16th Amendment).
- conscion 6y ago> you own 51% of your company but over time you're forced to become a minority shareholder just in order to pay the tax, or you owned 100% of it and are required to take on external investment over time just to stay in business Doesn't this assume the owner receives no other income? I assume owners either receive a salary from the company, or are paid a dividend with which they could use to pay the monetary-valued tax. Or especially in the case of 100% owned company, the owner pays themselves a "bonus" equal to the tax. The company now is worth less, reduced by the amount of that bonus, so the owner's wealth has decrease and the tax has been paid.
- bhupy 6y ago> Doesn't this assume the owner receives no other income? I assume owners either receive a salary from the company, or are paid a dividend with which they could use to pay the monetary-valued tax. Not always. To use the extremely adversarial example, Bezos' annual salary is (famously) $82,000, and Amazon pays no dividends because our tax code incentivizes re-investing surplus into R&D rather than enriching shareholders. The wealth tax, as a result, adds the incentive to increase shareholder dividends and/or inflate executive compensation just for them to be able to maintain ownership in their own companies.