4 ms·
> Is the EU hurting for tax revenues, or something? Yes it is, the core problem the EU has is that its budget almost entirely comes out of member state contrib
by mschuster91 6y ago
> Is the EU hurting for tax revenues, or something?
Yes it is, the core problem the EU has is that its budget almost entirely comes out of member state contributions (plus a bit of import duties and fines for rule violators). It does not have a meaningful source of funds that is at the sole discretion of the EU parliament - imagine the US federal government with a budget that is decided by the 50 individual states.
A proper funding source for the EU as an institution would finally allow things such as a joint EU foreign policy/military at the authority of parliament, decent wealth redistribution (i.e. equalizing especially the disparities between Eastern Europe and Core Europe), or major infrastructural works such as assisting all EU railroads to get rid of buffer/chain couplers... and especially to get rid of the political bullshit that the individual member states can pull off at the moment.
The EU parliament desperately needs to be reformed so that it stands on an equal footing with the member states.
- draugadrotten 6y ago> decent wealth redistribution (i.e. equalizing especially the disparities between Eastern Europe and Core Europe) Why limit socialism to Europe? Surely it would be much better with global "wealth redistribution".
- mutatio 6y agoJust a minor point; wealth redistribution is not socialism.
- philwelch 6y agoThe question is whether the EU is meant to be a federal government in the first place.
- int_19h 6y ago> It does not have a meaningful source of funds that is at the sole discretion of the EU parliament - imagine the US federal government with a budget that is decided by the 50 individual states. We don't need to imagine that - it's exactly how the USA worked under the Articles of Confederation. But the only solution to that involves significant transfer of sovereignty from member states to the federal structures. And it doesn't feel like most EU member states are willing to go there.
- dantheman 6y agoYeah, look at the disaster that has happened in federal governance in the US. We used to have a government of enumerated powers, now there is very little that the government can't do. The problem with a strong federal government is that you can't escape bad governance by moving to a neighboring state, you have to change countries. People are generally far happier with local governance than federal governance.