3 ms·
Honestly the devs probably didn't consider the worst case scenario. They probably thought "the users will be able to preview the e-mail and notice that s/he wil
by netsharc 6y ago
Honestly the devs probably didn't consider the worst case scenario. They probably thought "the users will be able to preview the e-mail and notice that s/he will send the attached files when s/he hits send" and that that's secure enough.
Sadly we have the year 2020 and as Rick Cook said: “Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs, and the Universe trying to produce bigger and better idiots. So far, the Universe is winning.”.
If the email program would pop up a warning that says "The following files have been automatically attached: [List of files]", would that meet the security concerns?
- paledot 6y agoWhile there are times where that quote applies, in the vast majority of cases, that's the programmer's cop-out upon discovering that the feature they thought was done is in fact broken and obtuse, and they don't care to take the time to understand their customer. I don't want my email client automatically attaching files from my computer, period. I don't care how well or poorly it displays that fact. There's no use case important enough to warrant that kind of intrusion.
- netsharc 6y agoImagine you want to send a few photos - currently stored on your disk - to your mom. File manager, select a few files, right click, "send via e-mail". Or a letter you're typing, to some company: in your word processor, File -> Send as E-Mail. For these features to be able to work, the email client would need to have an API so it can create an e-mail with attachments directly attached. Sure they're not important, but they're convenient. You might not like them, but hey am I glad you're not a product owner of a mail software.
- paledot 6y agoYes, of course you should be able to do that using an internal API. Maybe even an internal mailto: link, in the interest of interoperability. But no mail client should ever respect attachments requested by a mailto: link followed by a browser.
- mturmon 6y ago> If the email program would pop up a warning... A moment's thought should illustrate that "pop up a dialog box to ask permission" isn't really a fix for a hole like this. It has conspicuously failed in the past. I think your quote, which has the benefit of being funny, does miss one key thing, and it's that the number of users and our interactions with our systems keep growing. Prob(user error) might well be increasing a bit, but N * Prob(user error) is definitely increasing.