5 ms·
What we need is inheritance tax. If you've made money, you can keep it. But you can't live for free just because some guy 100 years ago made money and you won
by LatteLazy 6y ago
What we need is inheritance tax. If you've made money, you can keep it. But you can't live for free just because some guy 100 years ago made money and you won the genetic lottery.
- bhupy 6y ago12 states have an inheritance/estate tax. Definitely worth replicating in the others, too.
- marcinzm 6y agoAs I see it, those just penalize people with moderate amounts of money (ie: trying to build generational wealth) while the truly rich simply find loopholes.
- bhupy 6y ago> while the truly rich simply find loopholes You'll have to walk through how exactly, otherwise this is just a hand-wavy and unfalsifiable assertion.
- marcinzm 6y agoCreate a non-profit foundation that pays them, store assets outside the country/state, legally reside 51% of the time in a different state/country at their 5th house, etc. That's just random thoughts, I'm sure the truly rich have dozens more that their high priced accountants and lawyers dreamed up. It's the same way Warren Buffett pays less taxes, percentage wise, than his secretary. When you've got millions to spend on lawyers and tactics amazing things are possible. edit: Also trust funds and setting up a family corporation to manage assets.
- bhupy 6y agoI think the argument that you're making is that the existing estate taxes need to close foreign asset loopholes, but that's about it.
- marcinzm 6y agoThen they'll find other loopholes as they have for centuries is my point. And the government has a vested interest in keeping those loopholes open for the truly wealthy since they're all friends and political donation buddies.
- bhupy 6y agoThen the strongest argument against a wealth tax is simply: "they'll find loopholes". It's circular and un-falsifiable.
- sumedh 6y agoIsnt there a loophole that you transfer all the money to a foundation and then your children control the foundation effectively getting the money but on the books they did not inherit the money.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThere are 1001 loopholes. They should all be closed just like they are for earned income...
- mrfusion 6y agoI’d gladly pay 100% inheritance tax on exchange for zero taxes during life. Would anyone else go for a deal like that?
- epanchin 6y agoNo chance. Deciding when to retire would be a nightmare. Many would retire too early. Most on death would donate 100% to the charity of their choice.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIf you want to know when to retire, you can just buy an annuity. That's what pensions are today.
- LandR 6y agoNo. The amount I will get in inheritance is more than the tax I will pay in my life.
- leetcrew 6y agointeresting idea, but I think I would decline. I don't plan on having children, but I would like the primary beneficiaries of my excess productivity to be my friends and family. plus, I think it sets up a weird incentive to spend as much of your money as possible before you die, which causes a big problem if you live longer than you planned. I actually think the current US estate tax rules (minus the loopholes) are pretty reasonable. you get to pass on $10mm or so to your beneficiaries untaxed, but any wealth past that is subject to a steep tax. if you remove the basis step-up for assets and somehow prevent super-wealthy people from avoiding the tax altogether, I think it would be a pretty good system. enormous estates would decay quickly through the generations, but ordinary to upper-middle class folks could still leave their life's excess productivity to people they care about.
- joelhoffman 6y agoIf you're working for a firm that isn't actively tanking, then the primary beneficiaries of your excess productivity are always your employers. As many other people here have said the floor of any wealth tax is far higher than anything you could ever accumulate on a salary income.
- dx87 6y agoThat's rarely the case as it is. The majority of wealthy families lose their money in just a few generations if they aren't actively working to maintain it. https://money.com/rich-families-lose-wealth/ https://money.com/rich-families-lose-wealth/
- LatteLazy 6y agoRight now, they piss that money away on fast cars and lose <insert partner preference>. So we could divert that money to pay for infrastructure or cut income taxes or whatever, and aside from fast car dealerships, everyone should be happier.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- amiga_500 6y ago"in just a few generations". One generation with an inheritance tax. With a land tax many wouldn't get rich in the first place, let's address the root cause.