14 ms·
The West Is Becoming More Like China
- oxymoran 6y agoBut let’s continue to worry about Russia Russia Russia.
- badrabbit 6y agoWhy not both?
- mlvljr 6y agoDon't ya worry 'bout us! :)
- blaser-waffle 6y agoThe Russians have a literal "Manchurian Candidate" in the White House, who is openly murmuring about a 3rd term and displaying openly totalitarian tendencies. A report released by the Senate Intelligence Committee that just came out today clearly demonstrated that Trump received extensive and unprecedented levels of help from the Russians to get into office. The Chinese are walking, talking examples of the book 1984 -- but that doesn't mean Russia shouldn't be focused on either.
- LycheeKing 6y agoYou should ask your doctor about Trump Derangement Syndrome - you might suffer from it. You're no different from those who called Obama a Kenyan Muslim who wanted to install a dictatorship in the US using FEMA death squads confiscating guns in the wake of Operation Jade Helm[1]. To use a popular slogan from Hillary Clinton's campaign in 2016: "The election isn't rigged, you're just losing." [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jade_Helm_15_conspiracy_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jade_Helm_15_conspiracy_theori...
- g4rret 6y agonon-paywalled link: http://archive.today/j83zb http://archive.today/j83zb
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoCountries envy what China has become? Maybe those countries should be reminded they had all this in 1933, with a catchy theme song, and all the spätzle they could eat. They didn’t seem so envious then, spent something like 17 trillion (adjusted) to be less like China.
- mamon 6y agoI've written this multiple times on HN: democracy is a weird and temporary quirk, the natural state of mankind is totalitarism. For the short period of time (1.5 century) we were in this state where masses were educated well enough to demand political rights for themselves, and elittes didn't have the means to fully control them, so the compromise called "democracy" was made. Nowadays, with technical advances in many areas, like online banking, smartphones, social media, AI it again becomes possible for elittes to excercise total control over average citizen, therefore mankind will soon revert to it's natural, totalitarian state.
- carterklein13 6y agoDo you have any links to further reading I could do on this? This concept fascinates me and I'd be curious to learn more.
- glial 6y ago“Escape from Freedom” by Erich Fromm is a thoughtful historical take, written in the 1930s.
- helen___keller 6y agoAppealing to mankind's "natural" state is lazy thinking. Societies are massive, complex, ephemeral things. You may as well appeal that anarchism is mankind's natural state and that soon all governments will cease to exist.
- magicsmoke 6y agoI've got a theory that democracy develops in step with military technology and how "equal" an individual soldier is on the battlefield. Ancient Greece: Phalanx, requires groups of equal men to stand and fight in formation without breaking. Equipment and training was relatively even. The rich could afford better armor, but that wouldn't turn them into a super soldier. Medieval: Mounted cavalry or mounted archers. Expensive to maintain a war horse and equipment, years of training required. But a mounted knight was extremely difficult to kill for groups of peasant infantry and the nobility could dominate the battlefield. Industrial: Once again, large numbers of men wielding cheap firearms with much less training required than horseback combat. America being founded as a democracy probably had a lot to do with recruiting as many militiamen as possible rather than focusing on the interests of a highly trained military elite. One soldier, one vote reflects how much an individual soldier contributes on the battlefield during a time that spanned from musket lines to WW2. Today: Highly specialized militaries, numbers aren't as important as technology. Based on how democracy has advanced or retreated with the importance of an individual on the battlefield regardless of his wealth or experience, as the scale tips back towards a highly trained military class using expensive weaponry, expect democracy to retreat as the few wield military power over the many.
- recursivedoubts 6y ago" Whatever the price of the Chinese Revolution, it has obviously succeeded not only in producing more efficient and dedicated administration, but also in fostering high morale and community of purpose. The social experiment in China under Chairman Mao's leadership is one of the most important and successful in human history." -D. Rockefeller
- gnusty_gnurc 6y ago"Whatever the price"... in this case genocide and cannibalism.
- uep 6y agoThis is not at all what the article is about? I do not think the Chinese are as unified as they are made out to be. I think it's a joke to pretend that China is some ideal to aspire to, but sadly, I think the West will have to use similar tactics to continue to compete. I believe a big part of China's current strength is by actively exploiting the weaknesses of Capitalism. For a long time, they've exploited the race-to-the-bottom of pricing, and they've gotten rich from it, partially through the sacrifice of their people. Now that China has that new-found wealth (the country and the people), they are using that wealth to exploit Capitalism in a different way. Since Capitalism is inherently less directed and "top-down", now they're able to manipulate industries by being a big buyer instead. This is inherently part of Capitalism, but since the Chinese government has a more direct control of their economy, they're able to leverage a huge amount of economic power in a more directed fashion. You want to sell that product here? Well, you're going to have to do it our way. Western governments will have to do the same, putting restrictions on what compromises Western companies are allowed to make, and putting restrictions on Chinese products as well.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoCapitalism also expresses preferences and values. I suspect free people (consumers) see creepy stuff like cyber-dystopian Uighur genocide and when given the chance will go full behind whatever opportunity they have to say “screw you China.”
- charliebrownau 6y agoBecoming Welcome to the last 5-25-55-75 years 170 nations "goverments" signed the UN Agenda 21 pact in 1992 to form a single Global Dictatorship lead by Global Zionist Jews .. Since 1992 no Western or EU nation has been free .. None have declared ISRAEL + RUSSIA + CHINA the enemy of humanity and freedom ... If anything in the last 5-6 years we are finally waking up to the scam of Globalism, Government, corporations and how all parts of our society structures are compromised .. - Maybe all nations need to go thou Left wing National commie or left wing global commie to finally reject the left , authoritarianism and demand freedom .... Then again no one in china, HK, Russia has walked into the parliament as a collective group and got rid of the corruption ... Truth is Taxation is socialism , its wealth redistribution + state force thief, its also often takes 3-5 working class citizens to fund 1 person on welfare, which is often , female, disabled, old, children or non ethnic native person imported into the nation ... Also list ONE nation outside AMISH and ISLAM that actually holds women accountable...
- tabtab 6y agoSome have observed that the average family income of dictatorships tends to plateau at about half that of mature democracies, regardless of the economic system used. Things inside may start to get edgy when they hit that ceiling after everyone being used to growth. (Due to China's sheer size, half is still a big chunk of economic power.)