3 ms·
You don't think people haven't thought of that idea before? When innocent people are put to death, those involved almost always believed the evidence was absol
by kube-system 6y ago
You don't think people haven't thought of that idea before? When innocent people are put to death, those involved almost always believed the evidence was absolutely certain.
The problem is: they're still sometimes wrong.
There is no known system for applying capital punishment which is infallible. They all guarantee non-zero rates of innocent death.
How many innocent people's lives should we exchange to upgrade a sentence of life-imprisonment to death? And for what benefit? A feeling of retribution?
- toomuchtodo 6y ago> There is no known system for applying capital punishment which is infallible. This is a call to implement better systems around capital punishment, not to do away with capital punishment when the crime meets the criteria for it's implementation. As the old Texan proverb goes, “Some people need killin'”. This is not a pro-death, nor pro-revenge stance, this is the understanding that some humans are evil and beyond reform (and I believe there is enough criminal justice and behavioral science evidence that supports this thesis, but is beyond the scope of this comment). > How many innocent people's lives should we exchange to upgrade a sentence of life-imprisonment to death? As I said, this should only be done in cases where the evidence is irrefutable. There is zero doubt in what the Sacklers did, so I see no point in us continuing to argue over whether the evidence is substantial enough. If you want to hold the position capital punishment is still not acceptable for them, I'm sure I could find enough families and loved ones of those 250k people killed by the Sacklers' actions to rebut such arguments.
- kube-system 6y ago> this is the understanding that some humans are evil and beyond reform Then they can spend their entire life in prison. Capital punishment adds no additional value. > As I said, this should only be done in cases where the evidence is irrefutable. The bar for putting someone to death is already very high. But when you put someone to death, you may be unknowingly excluding evidence that you are not yet aware of. In most wrongful convictions, it is additional evidence discovered after the fact or a mistake found in the evidence previously used that indicates that the person was innocent. But at the moment of death, everyone was sure they were guilty. Whoops. For justice to be just, mistakes must be correctable when they are found.