2 ms·
That makes so little sense that I hope you mis-worded it. You're not thinking from the perspective of a business owner. I've been taken to court before, and whe
by mattmaroon 18y ago
That makes so little sense that I hope you mis-worded it. You're not thinking from the perspective of a business owner. I've been taken to court before, and when facing that situation you don't think "well, I'll go represent myself and lose, and then I'll be in the clear legally." That makes no sense.
Your thought process is more like "fuck, I better find a good lawyer." Being taken to court is serious stuff. And I've never been taken to court by the government. That's really serious stuff.
- Alex3917 18y agoI am thinking from the perspective of the business owner. Let's say the government asks me to wiretap for them. I say no because it would be illegal, but if it weren't illegal then I would gladly do it (as an evil telecom). So the government then goes to court to compel me to do it. I go to court and put up no defense and I lose. Now because the government has a court order mandating that I allow them to wiretap, if I do allow them to wiretap then I cannot be held accountable. I don't see what is so misguided about this.
- mattmaroon 18y agoYou're missing where the legal fees begin. How do you know what the government asked you for is illegal if you aren't paying lawyers to tell you that? You're a businessman, not an attorney. Also, "going to court" even if you do the bare minimum is still costing money as well. Is your CEO going to go take the stand or something? This isn't a criminal trial (yet), you can't simply plead the 5th. Do you think you can just disobey the government, lose a court case, then obey them, and that's the end of it? No fines? Do you think you can just not even try to represent yourself in court and not anger shareholders? That strategy is just silly.
- Alex3917 18y agoIf the feds come to your office and ask for help with an investigation and you refuse to help, they'll just go away and there's nothing they can do. Then they either come back with a court order or they don't come back at all. You are never legally required to help with the investigation of someone else unless you are under a court order. It seems pretty cut and dry to me, and I don't see how any criminal charges could possibly be filed against you. Also, since the wiretapping program was classified any legal action would take place in a secret court (or possibly the transcripts would be sealed), so angering the shareholders is a non-issue. edit: If the feds come and tell you that you are legally required to do something THEN you need a lawyer. But that isn't what happened in this case.
- mattmaroon 18y agoAgain, how do you know this without consulting an attorney? You keep spouting legal facts that may or may not be true (I'll give you the benefit of the doubt) but are you, the CEO of a publicly traded corporation, going to simply say no because you think, despite no real legal expertise, that you are never legally required to help an investigation? Or are you going to consult with attorneys? What about the small guy who owns a video rental store that makes $40k a year in profit for him? He's going to have to go plunk down 10% of his yearly earn on a retainer just to discover that fact. And even if what you say is true, which it surely could be, and even if it were common knowledge, it's still irrelevant. Corporations don't exist to police the government, it's the other way around. Penalizing a private enterprise for cooperating with a government agency's request is ridiculous.