3 ms·
> Syphilis may have a new world origin. Smallpox, measles, bubonic plague, whooping cough are all way scarier than syphilis. > The most productive crop is the
by triceratops 6y ago
> Syphilis may have a new world origin.
Smallpox, measles, bubonic plague, whooping cough are all way scarier than syphilis.
> The most productive crop is the potato,
The thesis of Guns, Germs, and Steel was Europe's east-west orientation allowed varieties domesticated in one place to easily grow in another. If different varieties of potatoes grow differently at different latitudes (I don't know, I'm not an expert), then it doesn't really matter how productive a crop the potato is. You may also be basing this on more modern potato varieties.
> The Inca farmed guinea pigs.
Guinea pigs are pretty small. The Inca didn't have horses, only llamas. Horses were militarily very important. Look at how much trouble the Plains Indians gave the US government, relative to their numbers. They only acquired horses after Europeans came to the New World and adapted their culture and ways around them very rapidly.
> The Mapuche did not have guns, germs or steel yet, they defeated the Spanish.
After initially being defeated, acquiring guns, steel, and horses from the Spanish and then rebelling against them.[1]
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arauco_War#Campaigns_of_Caupolic%C3%A1n_and_Garc%C3%ADa_Hurtado_de_Mendoza https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arauco_War#Campaigns_of_Caupol...
- 29athrowaway 6y ago> If different varieties of potatoes grow differently at different latitudes (I don't know, I'm not an expert), then it doesn't really matter how productive a crop the potato is. The introduction of the potato reshaped Europe and boosted European population by 25%. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xROmDsULcLE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xROmDsULcLE > The Inca didn't have horses, only llamas. Horses were militarily very important. The horse is a valuable animal given a favorable terrain. But with elevations such as the Andes, a horse is not as useful. And wheels are a similar story. Horses were useless in the Battle of Ollantaytambo, where the Inca used terraces to their advantage, but proved very useful in the defense of Lima (a coastal city) against the forces of general Quizquiz. > After initially being defeated, acquiring guns, steel, and horses from the Spanish and then rebelling against them.[1] The Mapuche did not "acquire" guns or steel. They could not manufacture them, but they became aware of them and developed techniques against them. They knew harquebuses were not waterproof, and if they would prefer to engage during rainy weather. They knew that trying to pierce through steel was ineffective, so they prefered to stun. They also became aware of the usage of cattle and they frequently raided cattle and set structures on fire.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> The introduction of the potato reshaped Europe and boosted European population by 25%. I think you missed the parent’s explicit point or I missed your point. The parent wasn’t saying potatoes aren’t efficient; only that they didn’t spread widely throughout the new world due to geographic factors. As for the rest of your post, I’m really not sure what point you’re making by focusing on the Inca. Specifically what about Diamond’s thesis are you refuting? Note that I’m not partial to “Guns, Germs, and Steel”; I just want to understand the criticism better.
- AlotOfReading 6y agoThe GP simply made a mistake. Potatoes can't grow in hot equatorial climates and never made the jump to the north. Two more American crops are essentially as productive as potatoes and did spread widely before Europeans. Sweet potatoes were grown as far north as Mexico / the Gulf and Maize was growing from Canada down all the way through Argentina.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoPotatoes were not a panamerican crop, but they were grown in Spain and the British Isles as soon as they were introduced. The Inca had a population of 10,000,000, and warehouses with surplus food that could sustain the empire for over 10 years.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI think this is consistent with Diamond’s thesis—the New World didn’t have “guns, germs, and steel” because important developments (like potato agriculture) remained localized. But again, it’s not clear to me if your goal is to criticize Diamond’s thesis or not.
- jcranmer 6y ago> The thesis of Guns, Germs, and Steel was Europe's east-west orientation allowed varieties domesticated in one place to easily grow in another. It's worth noting that despite the east-west orientation of Eurasia, there is quite little evidence of technology and agriculture actually being shared between the Mediterranean and Chinese origins, especially if you restrict yourself to the traditional origin-of-civilization innovations such as agriculture itself, pottery, metallurgy. By contrast, the Americas show a great deal more transmission along its north-south axis, with maize (from Mesoamerica) almost completely supplanting native North American domesticants, pottery appearing to come from the Amazon rainforest, and metallurgy arriving from the Andes.
- riffraff 6y agoDidn't a lot of things from Asia come to the Mediterranean to become omnipresent things? E.g. oranges, lemons, rice. Isn't wheat itself something that spread both ways from the middle East?
- 29athrowaway 6y agoWheat, barley, lentils, peas, chickpeas. Goats, sheep, pig... Most of those come from the fertile crescent.
- jcranmer 6y agoFor all intents and purposes, I equate the Fertile Crescent with the Mediterranean world. The big divide I'm talking about is crossing from China across the variety of deserts to reach Mesopotamia and the Mediterranean.
- triceratops 6y ago> there is quite little evidence of technology and agriculture actually being shared between the Mediterranean and Chinese origins You mean apart from (just off the top of my head) gunpowder, paper, the Hindu-Arabic numeral system, stirrups, and pasta/noodles?