3 ms·
Here are a couple of things that are very rarely explained in QM pedagogy but which are very helpful in understanding Shroedinger's cat: 1. The wave function
by lisper 6y ago
Here are a couple of things that are very rarely explained in QM pedagogy but which are very helpful in understanding Shroedinger's cat:
1. The wave function does not exist in physical space, it exists in configuration space. Configuration space is the same as physical space only in the one very special case of a single non-entangled particle. The intuitions of physical space do not generally carry over into the general case of configuration space.
2. In order to produce interference you have to split up the wave function into two pieces and then bring those pieces back together again with a phase change. But since the wave function exists in configuration space, "bringing it back together again" becomes increasingly difficult as the number of entangled degrees of freedom grows. As a practical matter, it is effectively impossible to do this once the number grows beyond a few hundred (this is why building quantum computers is hard). But an actual macroscopic observer consists of O(10^23) degrees of freedom, and is also entangled with their environment. This is the reason that large systems behave classically and don't exhibit interference.
3. Whether or not a system is in a superposition is not a physical fact about the system, it is a consequence of the measurement you choose to make. A vertically polarized photon (for example) is in a superposition relative to a measurement axis rotated away from the polarization axis. For a more complicated system, the measurement axis, like the wave function itself, is in configuration space. But we can only do measurements in physical space. This is the reason that in order to see interference in an entangled system it is necessary to do multiple physical measurements and look at the correlations between them. Doing those kinds of measurements on actual macroscopic objects is way beyond the current state of the art, and may well be impossible even in principle. But this is the sort of thing that is contemplated in the theory behind these experiments. This is the reason that single particles are used as stand-ins for Wigner's friend.
- taneq 6y agoIs physical space an actual thing? Or is it just a statistical interpretation of configuration space?
- lisper 6y agoThat is a really good question! The answer is: no one knows. There is at least one serious interpretation of QM that says that the 3-D physical space that we know is just one of many possibilities [1]. [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.06451 https://arxiv.org/abs/1812.06451
- taneq 6y agoWell that's my brain bent for today. Thanks for the interesting read!
- zackees 6y agoThis entire branch of physics is the equivalent of a geo-centric earth model. Tesla based his entire electric theory on the Aether. This theory was wrongly suppressed by results of a Michelson Morley experiment... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_ ...which failed to measure Aether-Drift because of the fact that it was done in a basement, and which was later contradicted by Dayton Miller when he repeated the experiment on a mountain top: http://www.orgonelab.org/miller.htm http://www.orgonelab.org/miller.htm This scientific tragedy, likely done by powerful oligarchs, set the progression of physics back 100 years. We now have fraudulent branch of particle physics, which has a terrible track record with pretty much every prediction it has made, and which would be laughed out of the scientific community if it weren't for the sustained push by the mainstream media to hammer it into the minds of intellectuals. We've been told that light has a set speed of propagation, yet time after time there are articles posted about light exceeding the speed of light for example gamma ray jets from quasars, which is explained by positing that the space-time fabric is moving and causing the reference frame containing the light wave to increase it's speed above the limit. https://www.sciencealert.com/faster-than-light-speed-in-jets-that-produce-gamma-ray-bursts https://www.sciencealert.com/faster-than-light-speed-in-jets... The media has become so twisted that we now accept completely broken interpretations such as virtual particles (used to balance equations), string theory (completely made up and didn't work), multiple universes, time travel and a smorgasbord of hilarious interpretations from a fundamentally broken model of physics. This article is just yet another desperate attempt to patch up this hilariously outdated physics branch. Einstein physics is on it's way out. And when it comes crashing down we will replace it with the work of Tesla and we will move faster in one decade the entire previous 150 years.