3 ms·
I think RF is a bit more subtle than that, and I'm not convinced that Scott Aaronson has really "debunked" it. "But clearly, even if no one literally measures
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
I think RF is a bit more subtle than that, and I'm not convinced that Scott Aaronson has really "debunked" it.
"But clearly, even if no one literally measures Charlie in the {|0〉,|1〉} basis, he’s still there, thinking either the thought corresponding to |0〉 or the thought corresponding to |1. And likewise Diane. Just as much as Alice and Bob, Charlie and Diane both exist even if no one measures them, and they can reason about what they know and what they know that others know. So then we’re free to chain together the “certainties” of Alice, Bob, Charlie, and Diane in order to produce our contradiction."
You can't use this argument without also explaining what "thinking" means - because in fact it makes no sense unless you assume consciousness exists as a quantum state which allows a phenomenon called "thinking."
And philosophically and practically, that's a very, very large can of wormns.
So this ends up in the usual place: it's not obvious how using an idea no one understands - like consciousness - to explain another idea no one understands - like QM - is supposed to solve any of these problems.
- Strilanc 6y agoIn order to implement the measurement described in the thought experiment, you basically have to uncompute Charlie's state back to the start of the experiment (to disentangle him from the qubit you want to measure), do the measurement on the single qubit, then recompute Charlie forward. This means that when Charlie is making deductions about the current state of affairs, like "if my qubit is |0> then the other qubit is |+>, that thinking needs to be valid during the computation and during the recomputation. But the conclusions Charlie is making are not correct during the recomputation, e.g. it is no longer the case that if his qubit is |0> then the other qubit is |+> at that time, and as a result the whole argument (based on Charlie's reasoning being valid so that an outside agent can use his conclusions) falls apart. More details: https://algassert.com/post/1904 https://algassert.com/post/1904