4 ms·
It seems like what you consider "understanding" is just accepting the police narrative that has been fueling the protests. > You don't require someone to use f
by mindslight 6y ago
It seems like what you consider "understanding" is just accepting the police narrative that has been fueling the protests.
> You don't require someone to use force to control a situation
Protests are not something to be "controlled" with force. That's authoritarianism.
> Protestors absolutely do not care about the specifics, they're not even playing that much attention. They're not reading the research on relative levels of violence per arrest etc.. It's a mob
Simple dehumanizing. There have been plenty of protests that have remained peaceful when they're not attacked by police.
> someone provokes a cop by walking up to them and saying something, the cop pushes the person, they fall down
It is illegal to attack someone because you don't like what they've said. This is criminal violence and needs to be prosecuted as such.
> A cop shoots his paintball gun at a reporter - on purpose. Again, not appropriate. But it's a paintball gun, they're used on people - for fun - all the time
It is illegal to shoot random people with paintballs. This is criminal violence and needs to be prosecuted as such.
> You don't have the right to block a road every day because you want to
Roads are public ways. People do have the right to use public ways to peaceably assemble.
> If anything the 'real' concern should be around actual policing, i.e. unnecessary police shootings.
That's exactly what these protests are about. Instead of accepting the message and submitting to accountability under the rule of law, police departments are escalating the protests so they can paint the protestors in a bad light, just as you are doing.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> Roads are public ways. People do have the right to use public ways to peaceably assemble. Do they have the right to block the road while doing so? For hours? More big-picture, I don't buy either your narrative or jariel's. I don't think the protesters are a mob. I also don't think that the violence is mostly because of the police. I see it like this: There are two groups, the protesters and the troublemakers. There is some overlap, but they are largely two distinct groups. A protest happens. It's usually in the daytime. The population is mostly protesters. Things are mostly peaceful. There is probably a police presence, watching the protest, but they usually don't do much. Time passes. Around sunset, many of the protesters go home. More troublemakers show up. It looks like the same protest, but the nature of the population has changed. There starts to be some acts of vandalism, maybe some assaults, maybe some throwing things at the police. Eventually the police say that it's enough. They either order the crowd to disperse, or try to arrest someone. The crowd, being by this time mostly troublemakers, won't disperse peacefully and won't accept having one of their members arrested without going the rounds with the cops. You now get videos with the starting point very carefully chosen to make the cops look like the instigators. Now, I am not saying that the cops never start the violence. I am not saying that only troublemakers are around after sundown. I am not saying that all videos of police violence are refusing to show the antecedent/buildup. I am not saying that everyone the cops get physical with had it coming. I am saying that the majority of the action follows the scenario I described.
- mindslight 6y ago> Do they have the right to block the road while doing so? For hours? Phrasing it as "blocking the road" is dragging in a bunch of assumptions. Another way of looking at it is that the protestors are using the road to the exclusion of others, in the same way that a parade or even rush hour traffic does. This is a judgment call, but given that protests aren't terribly common, I think the large group of people doing work to air their grievances deserves the benefit of the doubt. Remember, the entire point of a protest is to express outrage in a way that may be uncomfortable for everyone else. > Eventually the police say that it's enough. They either order the crowd to disperse, or try to arrest someone. The crowd, being by this time mostly troublemakers, won't disperse peacefully and won't accept having one of their members arrested without going the rounds with the cops This is the crux of the problem - the police asserting that they have the right to say "that's enough", declare a protest over, and then commit violence against anyone in the area. The dynamic is accelerated since the protest is explicitly against the police. The police need to either stick to arresting specific people committing crimes, or withdraw and accept that their authority has become overwhelmed in an area. Escalating the lawlessness by committing violence against the entire group is unacceptable in a society based around individual freedom.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoWell, as the law is written, the police do in fact have the right (under certain circumstances) to declare a gathering to be a riot, and to demand that it disperse. Those who refuse are in fact breaking the law, and can therefore be arrested, even under your criteria. And I argue that it should in fact be that way, at least in some circumstances. If you have a large group of people, some of whom are committing, say, vandalism, and the group's boldness is growing as they see that they can get away with such acts, and the group is making kind of a compact body, so that it's difficult for officers to reach and arrest any individual who has committed a crime, then... what? Just let it go on, because it's "just vandalism" (so far)? Then what do you do when it isn't just vandalism (if in fact it continues to escalate)? Or do you just trust that it won't continue to escalate? "Just trust people who are already breaking laws" doesn't seem like a reasonable police approach. Or do you just let it escalate however far it's going to, because violence by the police is unacceptable in all cases? > I think the large group of people doing work to air their grievances deserves the benefit of the doubt. I do, too... but not forever. That is, they want to block a road for a protest? Sure. It's inconvenient, but they have the right. They want to block it every day for two months? That's a bit of a different question.