4 ms·
We're not making any progress on co2e because we've choosen not to. Even if we were, net zero by 2070 (the optimistic outcome here!?) would be pointless, civil
by LatteLazy 6y ago
We're not making any progress on co2e because we've choosen not to.
Even if we were, net zero by 2070 (the optimistic outcome here!?) would be pointless, civilisation would be over long before then anyway.
I find all this really frustrating. It's like someone moaning they're fat and telling me about their new diet, the 1000th one this week, where they eat 20 cheese burgers a day and hope for the best. Let's get real and either do something or enjoy the ride to hell.
- cagenut 6y ago> Let's get real and either do something or enjoy the ride to hell. Easy for anyone not on the Indian sub-continent to say: https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/chapter-3/3-4/3-4-11/figure_3-18-2/ https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/chapter/chapter-3/3-4/3-4-11/figure...
- hutzlibu 6y ago"Even if we were, net zero by 2070 (the optimistic outcome here!?) would be pointless, civilisation would be over long before then anyway." Why? Even with every worst case szenario of continous droughts and floods and loss of some islands and coastal land etc. We could grow everything we need in (automated) greenhouses. Only if the transistion chaos leads to all out nuclear war, but that is not really a fixed thing.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoCivlisation will survive, in one shape or the other, but some countries could be totally screwed, others badly damaged. Its possible to imagine that political system crumbles, liberal democracy is gone, and the label is somewhat justified. We are talking about most of bangladesh underwater and about 1 billion refugees globally in a poor scenario. Todays migration problems will pale in comparison. Many if them will die violently. Nothing we've done so far indicates to me that we can quickly organise global rollout of hundred million automated greenhouses to people that cannot posssibly pay for them. Or to build largest damns in human history. Even when we can afford to pay for infrastructure, in UK its taking us 40 years to build 1 line of rail, connecting two biggest cities, and its going to cost roughly as mich as the moon programm did.
- Tade0 6y agoThe same UK had its CO2 emissions per capita peak in 1973 and lowered that number by over 45% since then. Sure, some of that happened through offshoring, but still - it's nothing to sneer at.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoWhat you are referring to is production-based CO2 accounting, whereas we really should be taking consumption-based CO2 metric. No doubt progress has been made, but it's a fraction of what it should be. Uk had a chance to invest in nuclear power and didn't, has poor quality housing / insulation resulting in a lot of unnecessary CO2 emissions and money wasted on heating, and has a stupid law that banned large (read: economical) wind turbines!
- Tade0 6y agoWhat about Hinkley Point C? Sure, financially the results so far are terrible, but so are other such projects in Europe.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoIt's good in the environmental seance, but what I meant was: in the 80's Uk had a chance to invest in nuclear to become like France, almost entirely nuclear-powered. Instead the skills needed to build nuclear power-plants have been lost, and now even replacing existing few reactors is a great challenge.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"Civlisation will survive, in one shape or the other" Yes, that was my point. That the current path is not shiny, I very much agree. But I just disagree to the "we are all doomed" mindset. That just reinforces the dark szenario. We are not doomed, but yes, we have to start today acting in a serious way. And this is not really happening.
- peteradio 6y ago> civilisation would be over long before then anyway What are you even talking about? If you are truly worried about climate change then this hyperbole reflects poorly on your cause.
- snarf21 6y agoI agree that the globe doesn't have the political will to enact harsh enough laws to really impact climate change. It has become too politicized at this point. I do disagree that civilization will die. When there is massive drought and food shortages, changes will happen then. At that point it will be very real. However, we have way to much scientific knowhow and money for our species to be wiped out. I'm not saying it won't be a very different experience and a different kind of life but we're too smart to die off. We may lose the ability to produce food at massive scale but not at small scale. I don't even think we'll get to this point in this century. But we likely will at some point. Maybe we'll do better the second time around with a more sustainable global population.
- twblalock 6y ago> Even if we were, net zero by 2070 (the optimistic outcome here!?) would be pointless, civilisation would be over long before then anyway. The cause of fighting climate change is harmed by hyperbolic arguments like this.