5 ms·
There's some discussion here about how destructive/unwise trading services like Robinhood can be. If you're looking for an alternative, I've had a great experi
by brundolf 6y ago
There's some discussion here about how destructive/unwise trading services like Robinhood can be.
If you're looking for an alternative, I've had a great experience with "robo-advisers" (Betterment, specifically). Many of the same advantages as something like Robinhood: $0 account minimum, 100% digital (create and manage your account through the website/app, no paperwork, no representatives), easy to cash-out with just a couple days' notice. The difference is that they automatically allocate a diversified portfolio for you and let you control simple things like the stocks/bonds percentage you want to have (a proxy for risk-tolerance). They do general investment accounts (analogous to index funds), as well as IRAs and savings. Fees are modest and automatically deducted from your growing balance. Dividends and gains are automatically re-invested in a tax-efficient way.
For several years now I've put all of my excess money into Betterment aside from some basic emergency savings. If you want a minimal-effort way to make your money grow and/or don't have much to invest, I highly recommend it.
Also: I promise I'm a real person and this isn't a shill :)
- easde 6y agoBetterment is easy but if you have more than a few thousand bucks to invest I would just open a Vanguard account and put your money there. If you have no idea what you're doing just use a target date fund, otherwise just buy stock/bond ETFs in the mix that you want. Not worth ~0.4%/year in fees (doesn't sound like a lot until you realize it's $400/year on $100K) to have someone else do that for you.
- brundolf 6y agoIn the years I've been using it the fees have totaled 5.2% of the earnings over that time (current balance - invested, not total account balance). It's not nothing, but personally I place a high value on simplicity and peace of mind in my life, so it's worth it to have a simple and excellent user-experience in the app, as well as the ability to do things like withdraw and deposit with literally the tap of a button.
- mariomariomario 6y agoYou're nuts if you think 5.2% is reasonable. Let's say for simplicity that's 1% per year for 5 years, if you chose VTSAX instead with an expense ratio of 0.04% (yes that's right) you're looking at total fees over 5 years of 0.2% versus 5% Compound that 30 years out, you would loose hundreds of thousands of dollars for a pretty UI. Forget that, take a day and go setup a Bogleheads [1] portfolio. [1] https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Three-fund_portfolio https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Three-fund_portfolio
- moneywoes 6y agoDid you get alpha
- atombender 6y ago5.2% is crazy. The target date fund I use, SWYJX (Schwab Target 2055 Index Fund) has a net ER of 0.08%. Over 25 years, the difference between 0.4% and 0.08% can be hundreds of thousands of dollars. Like Betterment, SWYJX an automated portfolio, but one adjusted for age, not some individual profile.
- bobobob420 6y agoBruh 5.2 percent what are you doing giving investment advice lmao
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vikiomega9 6y agoIs there something specific about Vanguard that you use it for, I can buy ETFs on e-trade and other platforms right?
- atombender 6y agoYes, you can. Vanguard is a brokerage, just like E-Trade, Schwab, Fidelity, etc. They provide all sorts products, such as IRAs. A good reason to use Vanguard as a company is their mutual funds. (Though you can trade Vanguard mutual funds elsewhere, they'll usually come with transaction fees.) Mutual funds are arguably superior to ETFs for many investors, in a few ways. * Mutual funds are fractional by nature — you can trade as little as $1. Right now, only a very small handful of brokers support fractional shares of ETFs. * Since MFs aren't traded as whole units, you can set up automatic investing. Let a certain % of your paycheck go into the MF every month. Not possible with ETFs on most platforms, a notable exception being M1. * Since MFs only settle their NAV once a day, you're discouraged from compulsively checking your portfolio every few hours. If the market is temporarily down, you won't see it reflected in real time. Some people consider the real-time aspect of ETFs superior, but for long-term investing, this lack of an instant dopamine rush means it's easier to just not think about it. Fewer emotional decisions. * Mutual funds can be "funds of funds". Regulations prevent ETFs from doing the same thing. A good example of a FoF is Vanguard's target date retirement funds, which are nearly exactly equivalent to a Boglehead-style three-fund portfolio. MFs have a reputation for being expensive, but Vanguard's have some of the lowest fees on the market. MFs also can be tax-inefficient, but Vanguard has patented a loophole that makes them as efficient as ETFs when held in a taxable account. Vanguard is also a great company; easily my favourite investment company. Its ownership structure is inverted: The company is collectively owned by its funds, which means that you, as a MF shareholder, will own a part of Vanguard. Note: The above points about MFs are largely moot with robo advisors like Betterment.
- Drdrdrq 6y ago> MFs also can be tax-inefficient, but Vanguard has patented a loophole that makes them as efficient as ETFs when held in a taxable account. Incredible... You weren't kidding: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2019-vanguard-mutual-fund-tax-dodge/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2019-vanguard-mutual-fund...
- PascLeRasc 6y agoI'm willing to pay a 0.25% management fee to prevent SIM swapping attacks. Vanguard will not allow you to remove SMS as a 2FA option, and their Yubikey authentication doesn't work with Firefox, which is pretty unique. The little millennial brokerages (Robinhood, Wealthfront, Betterment) are all more secure.
- kjksf 6y agoTell us how well Betterment did for you. I highly doubt it beats S&P 500 so you can do better by using Robinhood and invest into S&P 500 tracking stock like IVV. And the risk is more or less the same. It's not like Betterment would do well if S&P 500 tanks. I used Wealthfront for a while and I switched to trading stocks. The idea of roboadvisor sounded nice but their returns are sub-par because their allocation strategy is, by necessity, very risk averse. They put a lot of your money into bonds and similar sub-2% investements while in the last 50 years S&P returned 8% on average. That 8% return is about as risk free as you can get and paying Betterment fees to do worse than that makes no sense to me. BTW: if you invest in FAANGT (FAANG + Tesla) equal-weight portfolio, you'll do several times better than S&P 500 with very little risk. At lest for the next few years.
- brundolf 6y ago> you can do better by using Robinhood and invest into S&P 500 tracking stock like IVV That's an interesting idea I hadn't considered. I believe robo-advisers tend to beat the market by a little bit, but I could be wrong on that. I started investing in force at the end of 2016 and the time-weighted, annualized returns on the stock portion of my portfolio are 6.39%. So make of that what you will > They put a lot of your money into bonds and similar sub-2% investements while in the last 50 years S&P returned 8% on average Betterment lets you pick your percentage of stocks vs bonds; you can set it to whatever you want and your portfolio gets re-allocated to match. I'm young, so mine's set at 90% stocks. I imagine I'll gradually decrease that over time.
- CPLX 6y ago> That 8% return is about as risk free as you can get Yeah no. The S&P 500 lost about 35% of its value in 2008. If that's the year your kid starts college or you were planning to put down a big down payment on your first house, you'd be completely fucked. I used to think the same way as you, but when you get a little older and major life milestones and/or retirement aren't distant concepts it'll change your perspective.
- oconnor663 6y agoI think the standard advice is that whatever part of your savings you expect to spend in the next 5-10 years shouldn't go in the stock market, for exactly this reason.