3 ms·
> We make it illegal for someone to come into your home and take your stuff It's not illegal however if you signed a contract to that effect, which is what you
by gtsteve 6y ago
> We make it illegal for someone to come into your home and take your stuff
It's not illegal however if you signed a contract to that effect, which is what you did when you started using the platform.
A better analogy is that you're renting some furniture and the furniture is found to be unsafe. The company can come and take it away, either replacing it with something else or refunding you.
In the software world nobody but the creators or IP holders of the software actually owns the software. They just provide you the license to use it.
It's illegal in many countries to modify the software so if you had a closed-source word processing application it would be illegal to mod it or to use it as part of a data transformation pipeline. You can only use it for the purposes stated when you bought it.
If there was a way to limit your oven to bake recipes the manufacturer allowed or to use specific approved ingredients, and would come with some sort of value-add to make consumers ignore that as a problem, I'm sure someone would actually do this.
(please note that I am stating facts as I see them and not necessarily agreeing with the state of affairs)
- badsectoracula 6y agoThe question above was about if something should be made illegal, not what the current state of affairs is. Also i'm not arguing about who owns the software, i never asked for ownership of the software, i ask for being able to be in control of the software that runs in the hardware i do actually own. This does not require me owning the OS that runs in my hardware. And yes, i'm sure someone would do the oven stuff if it was possible and making that illegal would also be something that would be needed.
- gsich 6y ago>It's not illegal however if you signed a contract to that effect, which is what you did when you started using the platform. Contracts are not above the law. Or: you can't contradict laws with your contract.
- colejohnson66 6y agoSure you can. Just look at arbitration. It’s not right, but it’s incorrect to say that a contact can’t remove your rights.
- sk5t 6y agoOnly to the extent that the law permits arbitration clauses.