2 ms·
There is probably something in the contract that says that Microsoft is not criminally liable. I trust their lawyers for that. But if companies become criminal
by GuB-42 6y ago
There is probably something in the contract that says that Microsoft is not criminally liable. I trust their lawyers for that.
But if companies become criminally liable for bugs, this can be bad news for open source projects. For example. My company wants to use some GPL software, but we need some extra features, so following the license, I implement them and release the source. The original maintainers like it and put it into the official tree. Unfortunately, my contribution introduces a serious security flaw in some other part that my company doesn't use, we simply overlooked that part, it is our fault, but we didn't mean any harm. We may even have seen the CVE, but because it wasn't about something we used, we didn't look into it. And now, suddenly just because we did everything by the rules and released our source code, we are now criminally liable... That kind of thing makes you think twice before you contribute to any open source project...
Usually open source projects have a very big "we are not responsible for anything, to the maximum intent permitted by law" warning to avoid this kind of problem. Companies are of course free to provide additional guarantees on derived products, that's one business model for open source developers.
But if you make a law where software developers are responsible for their bugs no matter the contract, even if there is no ill intent, this is going to be a problem.