4 ms·
That’s cool, but hardware kill switches don’t help your privacy. Why? Because nobody is ever going to want to turn off that functionality. I don’t know anyone
by dangus 6y ago
That’s cool, but hardware kill switches don’t help your privacy.
Why?
Because nobody is ever going to want to turn off that functionality. I don’t know anyone who turns off the software switches, why would they turn off hardware ones?
A smartphone without a camera, mic, Bluetooth, cellular data, and WiFi is basically useless.
What we need is a way to make these technologies more private while they’re in use.
Also, the PinePhone is barely usable, and I say that as an owner. It’s a neat toy but it’s got a long way to go.
- unethical_ban 6y agoThat is a huge, and incorrect, assertion. If I could hard-off my mic, I would. I don't use it but once a day, maybe, while I use others frequently. I turn off location manually whenever I am not using an app that requires it. I leave bluetooth on because I use it frequently enough, but if it were an easy hardware switch, I could get in the habit of shutting it off.
- AshamedCaptain 6y ago> I turn off location manually whenever I am not using an app that requires it Which is almost equivalent to teather from a security point of view. Either you trust the system, in which case you can trust that you can deny location to the programs that according to you "don't require it"; or you don't trust the system, in which case it will just broadcast the position whenever you enable the killswitch to everyone who could be even remotely interested. And again when you enable it is usually when you are most likely going to leak something interesting. There is here some usefulness in terms of having "another layer", but academically this is really debatable.
- def_true_false 6y agoSwitches are simple and predictable. Permission systems have shit UX, and are not granular enough anyway. Furthermore, suppose you need different things to be permitted at different times, e.g. you need the battery to last longer for a few days... good luck changing all your permissions manually.
- AshamedCaptain 6y agoNot to mention that whenever you finally enable the mic it is because you are probably going to say something interesting to it, which is exactly what whichever rootkit you're afraid of is going to be interested in. Not silence.