3 ms·
The IMEI just identifies your phone. The IMSI identifies your number. So it's perfectly possible to change the IMEI if you leave your IMSI alone. The network w
by GekkePrutser 6y ago
The IMEI just identifies your phone. The IMSI identifies your number.
So it's perfectly possible to change the IMEI if you leave your IMSI alone. The network will think you just stuck your SIM in another phone. Everything will work fine. You can't change your IMSI as it's hardcoded on the SIM (technically you could with an eSIM but it simply would be unrecognised and just not work then).
Of course they still know who you are, and they need to to connect your calls. But apps that look at the IMEI for identification will be confused. Not sure how much it helps in terms of privacy. I doubt it helps a lot as any app can just make up a random number and dump it in their long-term storage to know it's you (just like a cookie).
And yeah the illegality of changing it is an issue in some countries. Also, if you 'clash' with another live IMEI weird things happen :)
PS: IMEI changing was outlawed in those days to stop people stealing phones and changing IMEIs to resell them and bypassing carrier blocks of the stolen phone. It was never that successful as thieves are lawbreakers by nature and don't care at all whether they break an extra law or two. Apple and Google's activation lock were much more successful. I'm personally not a big fan of laws when there are technical solutions that are equally or more effective.
- labawi 6y agoAFAIK, a SIM card itself has a card id (ICCID), which should not be changed and is not used often. The subscriber id (IMSI) is in the "application" layer of the card and theoretically could be changed by the provider, or as a speciality, multiple ones installed. That being said, I've never actually seen a card's IMSI changed. They usually give you a new sim and IMSI, even for a replacement card.
- extrapickles 6y agoMost SIM cards are one-time programmable, so they can’t change anything on the card. They do still have a small RW area, but thats generally for user data (contacts). You can get SIM cards that have large amounts of storage for running applets and have better support for OTA, but most carriers don’t like the extra expense.
- dogma1138 6y agoAren’t most SIM cards today use over the air provisioning since networks employ thin provisioning theses days?
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYes they do almost all support it (with many security vulnerabilities as a result, Karsten Nohl did a really great presentation on this at OHM2010). But the IMSI is almost always provided at manufacture time. I think it's also because the card would not be able to be provisioned over the air without getting connected to the network first, and without an IMSI there is no network connection :)