3 ms·
> both high- and low-achieving students were celebrating when the standardised exams got cancelled here in Ireland They celebrated the message "Exams are cance
by michaelt 6y ago
> both high- and low-achieving students were celebrating when the standardised exams got cancelled here in Ireland
They celebrated the message "Exams are cancelled"
If the message had instead been "Exams are cancelled, at this school A grade students will receive a C instead" I suspect you'd have seen a very different response.
- dmurray 6y agoWell, yeah, but they'd really be thrilled at the school where they announced C grade students would get an A. There is some benefit to society to matching up the right students to the right courses, so it's not completely zero-sum. But the cost of getting it a bit wrong isn't terrible: some marginal students get to follow their dreams and study medicine, some others miss out on medicine and have to try their hand at accountancy.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoThis discounts the sense of disenfranchisement that may result, which might be consequential, or that we may end up with inferior doctors.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 6y agoI would expect moderation to lower grades much more often than it would raise grades. After all, it's understandable why a teacher would over-estimate grades (assumption everyone else is going to do the same, and their kids will be relatively disadvantaged if they don't) and hence get moderated down. And it's understandable why a teacher would give spot-on estimated grades (honesty, valuing the credibility of their estimates) and hence not get moderated at all. But it's difficult to see why a teacher would under-estimate grades. So I suspect there are not many C grade students getting upgraded to an A.