5 ms·
Was curious how fast you could be. Apparently there's a guy that can hit 360 words/minute.https://www.nyscr.net/news/2017/1/13/can-you-type-360-words-per-minut
by tyingq 6y ago
Was curious how fast you could be. Apparently there's a guy that can hit 360 words/minute.https://www.nyscr.net/news/2017/1/13/can-you-type-360-words-per-minute-mark-kislingbury-can#:~:text=Mark%20Kislingbury%20can%20hit%20more,minute%2C%20with%2097%20percent%20accuracy https://www.nyscr.net/news/2017/1/13/can-you-type-360-words-....
That makes him about as fast as a 300 baud modem. And probably around 1.8x the fastest keyboard typists.
Edit: Curious if this as "optimized" as it can be. Is there a theoretically faster way to get words from your hands to something digital?
I'm also curious how this works for court cases where a language other than English comes into play, alongside English. Canada might be a good example, where French and English dialogue might often co-exist.
- shakna 6y ago> I'm also curious how this works for court cases where a language other than English comes into play, alongside English. Canada might be a good example, where French and English dialogue might often co-exist. The related Penti-Chorded keyboard apparently works fairly well for German [0], and Japanese Kanji [1]. I'd imagine that using the arpeggio to shift the characters would work similarly with the steno. [0] https://software-lab.de/penti.html https://software-lab.de/penti.html [1] https://picolisp.com/wiki/?TermuxPentiPicolisp https://picolisp.com/wiki/?TermuxPentiPicolisp
- recuter 6y ago> Is there a theoretically faster way to get words from your hands to something digital? For the sake of, err, discussion, I can envision some sort of wearable glove like input device. I know I can play notes on a guitar far faster than he is inputting characters because of the technique involved. I feel like it could be possible to come up with a faster method playing around with that idea. But the ultimate would be hands free, no? Makes one wonder if this is yet another skill/job about to be blown away by automation. Offline speech recognition with perfect accuracy will probably come standard with every phone in a couple of years.
- tyingq 6y agoSpeech to text is interesting, though the 360 words / minute is already quite a lot faster than typical speech. Though probably slower than the text to speech blind users use (450 words/minute?). I wonder if there's a blind stenographer that can really fly, but just isn't well known. I bet there are some unknown talents in the closed captioning space. Unrelated, I've seen some interesting typos there, especially with strong English accents like Scottish or Irish. And you can see them improving as episodes progress. The "RedRock" Irish soap is a good example. They get much better over time.
- lunixbochs 6y ago_humans_ are in the 5% word error rate ballpark for large vocabulary recognition. I think generalized perfect accuracy is very very far away unfortunately.
- Izkata 6y ago> I can envision some sort of wearable glove like input device. I know I can play notes on a guitar far faster than he is inputting characters because of the technique involved. Sounds like the perfect instrument for Steno Hero: https://killscreen.com/previously/articles/steno-hero-might-make-transcription-tolerable/ https://killscreen.com/previously/articles/steno-hero-might-...
- tanatocenose 6y agoI find it hard to believe the average guitarplayer can play notes faster than the average typist can write letters.
- pessimizer 6y agoAs for hands-free: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stenomask https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stenomask Half the speed.
- apostacy 6y agoCan confirm. My uncle is a stenographer, I learned all about it. If I remember correctly, just to get his license he had to hit 270w/m. He said he can get up to about 300w/m. The raw transcripts are composed of shorthand codes, and letters that represent syllables and other components of speech. I saw that many words were just represented by one or a few letters. So, by "words", we are often talking about codes of only a few letters. They are printed on thermal receipt width paper, and floppy disk (this was about 15 years ago). > I'm also curious how this works for court cases where a language other than English comes into play, alongside English. Canada might be a good example, where French and English dialogue might often co-exist. It shouldn't matter what language it is, because the stenographer has their own custom shorthand dictionary. The raw transcript that they generate is for the stenographers internal use. Only after the trail do they transcribe it into human readable form. Lawyers then have to pay the stenographer a fee for their transcripts. My uncle told me that it is common for multiple lawyers to each pay him a fee that he charges by the page. He, like most court reporters, outsources their transcription to other people via Email. It requires human transcription, because the raw transcripts need to be interpreted. It is not a something that you can just run through a filter. His scopists[1] will email him back and fourth for clarification on parts of the transcript they don't understand. This is important, because their transcripts are the official legal record of what happened in a trial. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scopist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scopist [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shorthand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shorthand
- stickfigure 6y agoIn an age where audio/video recording + storage is essentially free, this practice seems... quaint.
- apostacy 6y agoActually, it's more like the court reporter is the official witness. They are attesting to what happened in the courtroom. The actual instrument that the reporter uses is much less important. And trials have the audio recorded anyway. I know that when my uncle started in the early 90s, there were still some court reporters that used shorthand with pencil and paper. I don't think there is a requirement that they use a steno machine. Their job isn't to record what happened, their job is to generate a single authoritative transcript that everyone works from. In theory, they could probably not take notes at all, and just work from the recording later, but it is probably easier to take the first round of notes live. When a court reporter generates a transcript, they sometimes have to go back through the audio recordings sometimes and actually clarify in the official transcript exactly what was said. They have to make it clear in the transcript if people were talking over each other, or to try to clarify what exactly was said if it might be ambiguous. I think it is a good idea for a trial to have an official record that has been processed by a human, instead of just throwing a recording up and calling it a day. Think of how inefficient it would be otherwise, where all of the parties would essentially have to act as their own court reporters and generate their own transcripts. What if different parties disagreed with the interpretation of the transcripts? Perhaps the court would then have to appoint a neutral expert to make an authoritative determination of what was said; and we've now re-invented the court-reporter role. I think there is a tendency for people to look at this only as a technical problem to be solved. Like with voting, it isn't just a matter of securely tallying votes, there is much more to it. The process requires maximizing transparency and minimizing room for anyone to contest it.
- kqr 6y agoRe. languages: The issue with the Plover type stenography is that it heavily relies on a dictionary. If a dictionary does not exist for your language, it becomes close to useless. Many European languages use a form of orthographic stenography instead. This is perhaps a tiny bit less efficient, but makes up for it with flexibility in spades. I started working on a computer implementation of that, but sadly life got in the way. If there was any project I could be paid to continue work on, I would want it to be this. https://github.com/kqr/qweyboard/ https://github.com/kqr/qweyboard/
- rijoja 6y agoThe language itself is a bottleneck, English for instance is very redundant. I suppose this is an error correcting mechanism of sort. So reinventing the language could increase the bandwidth 7th fold. Alternatively an intelligent model could cut away this by means of compression, look into Dasher for more on that.
- convolvatron 6y agodoesn't it strike you that the stenographic model of english looks a like chinese?